6 ms·
Rising Above I.Q.
- Matti 17y agoAfter reading that column, read "Logical Fallacies used to dismiss the evidence on intelligence testing" by Linda S. Gottfredson. It's available here: http://www.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/2009fallacies.pdf http://www.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/2009fallacies.... Now, go back and re-read the New York Times piece. How many fallacies did you notice?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- te_platt 17y agoThe point of the article isn't that IQ differences don't exist. Only that on average how hard you work is much more important than how smart you are in achieving success. At least in the measures used in the article - graduate degrees and income. From the article: "In any case, he says, the evidence is overwhelming that what is distinctive about these three groups is not innate advantage but rather a tendency to get the most out of the firepower they have."
- jerryji 17y agoReminds me of the rice paddy chapter in the Outliers, and to me they are equally not very scientific.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoMainstream commentary on the IQ debate is worthless. The vast majority are too innumerate to understand statistical concepts used in gathering the data in the first place.
- david927 17y agoAnd those who believe they are "above" the vast majority are too arrogant to discuss the issue rationally. Simply, if you believe that IQ measures intelligence, you lose 80 IQ points.
- tokenadult 17y agoif you believe that IQ measures intelligence, you lose 80 IQ points. Expand on that thought, please. Is your disagreement with the word "measure," with the word "intelligence," or with both?
- david927 17y agoIQ can't measure intelligence because intelligence is qualitative, not quantitative. It's not like height or weight, it's like beauty. People can generally agree on it, but there's no concrete way to measure it. IQ is useful, and only useful, in its "industrial" capacity, meaning where it's used statistically over large sample sizes. To explain this better, let's use the analogy of a Beauty Quotient (BQ). It would be calculated to give a higher value to large eyes, high cheekbones, etc. This could be used in aggregate to understand why so many female models come from the Czech Republic, but to apply it individually is meaningless. There are people with big eyes and high cheek bones who look like freaks of nature, and people with smaller eyes and lower cheekbones who are stunning. BQ doesn't exist because what it would measure is self-evident; you could just look at someone saying, "I have a BQ of 180! I'm gorgeous!" and agree (or laugh). IQ, however, measures something that can't be so quickly assessed, and so many grasp onto it to validate themselves. That's an abuse of the purpose and displays a lack of understanding of the difference between qualitative and quantitative, thus my jibe at losing 80 IQ points.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoI agree with you. It's exactly like the race debate. People who think that statistics are useful for judging individuals are dumb.
- 17y ago
- ram1024 17y agomeh it's not a race thing, it's a cultural thing. if children are patterned to strive for excellence by the culture they grow up in, they will do better than typical lax parenting. if they investigated further into individual situations and compared them you would see that successful students either have very attentive parents nurturing them or they have another familial situation that is driving them
- yummyfajitas 17y agoDid anyone notice the tricky wording when he talked about race? "Asian-Americans are renowned...for ruining grade curves in schools across the land... As for Jews...a quarter of Jewish adults in the United States have earned a graduate degree, compared with 6 percent of the population as a whole. West Indian blacks,...are one-third more likely to graduate from college than African-Americans as a whole..." So Asians and Jews outperform all Americans, while West Indian Blacks only outperform American Blacks (but presumably not Americans in aggregate [1])? This hardly seems like evidence against racial differences in intelligence/achievement. (Note: I don't have a strong opinion on racial IQ differences, just pointing out the tricky wording in the article. Unfortunately, the science on that topic tends to be written mostly by activists on both sides, and is fairly untrustworthy.) [1] I assume that if West Indian blacks outperformed Americans, Kristoff would have mentioned it (as he did with Asians and Jews).
- frossie 17y agoSo Asians and Jews outperform all Americans, while West Indian Blacks only outperform American Blacks (but presumably not Americans in aggregate)? This hardly seems like evidence against racial differences in intelligence/achievement. He doesn't say there aren't racial differences in intelligence. He is saying that irrespective of any actual differences in intelligence, some groups do better than others purely due to cultural norms. It's along the lines of genius being "1% inspiration and 99% perspiration". The point put forward is that any natural variations in the inspiration part are dwarfed by sufficient application of the perspiration part.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoHe does try to imply (without actually stating) that there are small/no racial differences in intelligence. He first debunks a straw man ("success as a simple product of intrinsic intellect") and then quotes someone claiming that intelligence is malleable and non-genetic. But lets ignore that. Going from his examples, cultural norms can help some blacks outperform other blacks. But it doesn't actually allow blacks to outperform whites. If his examples are representative, the natural variations of the "inspiration" part are actually similar in size to the "perspiration" part of the equation.
- tungstenfurnace 17y agoThe way to rise above IQ is to stop thinking about oneself and stop being so competitive. This parochial attitude leads to depression and failure. The truest, most promising motivation for mastering a field or a craft lies in the beauty of the craft itself. Beauty is the greatest stimulus for creativity and imagination. It makes all things gentle and easy. Technical competence follows as the night the day.
- Emore 17y agoInterestingly, my impression is that this is exactly the strategy that Asian-Americans _don't_ use. While I completely agree on your argument, I don't see many people driven by the beauty fo the craft itself. My guess is that competition and shortcuts are simply much more effective in quickly reaching success. The sad fact might be that it is perfectly possible to master a field or craft without a passion for the subject. Simply because passion is not competitively passable.
- gruseom 17y agoI don't mean to pick on you personally, but the fact that you responded to that rather profound comment with a borderline racial slur is indicative of what's wrong with this thread and this entire class of conversation and article. It makes me want to walk on the other side of the street. Edit: I guess I should be more careful in putting this. I like frankness and don't believe in imposing ideological rules on discourse. But I also observe that discussions around this stuff tend to be of low quality. Your comment struck me as a nice example because the first sentence seemed nasty and jarring and the rest of the comment was just fine.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoThese three groups may help debunk the myth of success as a simple product of intrinsic intellect, for they represent three different races and histories. I must have missed something. Couldn't he just as easily have said "These three groups may help confirm the fact that success is a product of intrinsic intellect, for they represent three different races and histories, with different average levels of intellect, which strongly correlate with their outcomes."
- nostrademons 17y agoYeah, I took this article as a great case study on how different people can look at the exact same data and draw totally opposite conclusions. Almost exactly the same example is used in The Bell Curve to argue that intelligence is innate, because Ashkenazi Jews and Asian-Americans tend to have higher IQs than whites, while West Indians tend to have higher IQs than Africans.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoAnd I can't believe I missed this earlier, but: he cites the IQ difference between the Ashkenazim and the Sephardim (two groups with a common culture and very different genetic characteristics) as proof that culture, not genetics, determines success. Was this a parody?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- xiaoma 17y ago"Richard Nisbett cites each of these groups in his superb recent book, “Intelligence and How to Get It.” Dr. Nisbett, a professor of psychology at the University of Michigan, argues that what we think of as intelligence is quite malleable and owes little or nothing to genetics." Stephen Pinker argued very persuasively in The Blank Slate that this is not the case. Brains are malleable to some degree, but genetics are still very important. One of the more convincing pieces of evidence is the similarities in the abilities of twins raised in separate families. He recounted case studies in which identical twins who had never even met each other both had the same proffession, favorite hobby and even shared odd habits, such as wearing a rubber band around their wrists More bluntly, if intelligence "owes little or nothing to genetics", why is it that children acquire an understand of the language spoken in their home while house pets do not? As Chomsky's discovery of universal grammar implies, humans already have a great deal of what we need for language processing built into our brains from birth.
- emmett 17y agoPsychologists love twin studies, but they're mostly worthless. The unstated assumption is always "A twin study holds genetics constant while randomizing the environment". Of course the families of two identical twins are far from independent variables. They're both made of the kinds of people who would adopt a child in the same city at the same point in time. You haven't managed to separate the variables at all!
- tokenadult 17y agoMoreover, studies of broad heritability (a pre-Mendelian concept) merely establish a minimum influence of environment on the trait of interest. More extreme variance in environment, or more specifically directed variance in environment, could still result in greater variance in the trait.
- xiaoma 17y agoAnd yet, the odds of a random adoptee growing up in the same city, choosing the same profession, favorite color, and rubber-band wearing habit are astronomically lower than those of an identical twin doing so. Many twin studies, particularly those done in the past few decades have been rigorous. And the correlation in IQ, career and age of marriage between such twins, are far higher than those of siblings, or adopted siblings growing up in the same house. There may be a political reason for rejecting the role of heredity or the large body of research supporting it, but there isn't a scientific one.
- bokonist 17y agoThis article is both is both fallacious and intellectualy dishonest. Richard Nisbett cites each of these groups in his superb recent book, “Intelligence and How to Get It.” Dr. Nisbett, a professor of psychology at the University of Michigan, argues that what we think of as intelligence is quite malleable and owes little or nothing to genetics. Nisbett actually writes, "The evidence of the adoption studies indicate that postnatal environmental factors - biological and social ones combined - probably outweigh the genetic ones" (p. 79). On another page, "The environmentalist camp estimates heritability to be .50 or less... And I agree with these scientists - in fact I suspect heritability may be even lower than .5" (p 21) In both quotes Nisbetts uses couched language to suggest that heritability may be lower than .50. Kristof then morphs this this into, "owes little or nothing to genetics." That's a lot different than what Nisbett said. And of course, Nisbett is a member of the environmentalist camp. Kristof fails to acknowledge that many others who have studied the evidence strongly disagree with Nisbett's conclusions. “I think the evidence is very good that there is no genetic contribution to the black-white difference on I.Q.,” he said, I read Nisbett's case. Personally I found it much less convincing than articles that have suggested some genetic contribution: ( http://www.slate.com/id/2178122/entry/2178123/ http://www.slate.com/id/2178122/entry/2178123/ , http://www.gnxp.com/blog/2007/02/race-iq-and-ses.php http://www.gnxp.com/blog/2007/02/race-iq-and-ses.php , and http://members.cox.net/bvv/h2b.html http://members.cox.net/bvv/h2b.html ) As for Jews, some not-very-rigorous studies have found modestly above-average I.Q. for Ashkenazi Jews, though not for Sephardic Jews. Again, this also supports the case for genetics. Harpending and Cochran argue that the selection for Ashkenazi intelligence occurred from 1000 AD to 1800 AD, long after they separated from the Sephardic Jews. Read the book "The Ten Thousand Year Explosion" to learn more: http://www.amazon.com/000-Year-Explosion-Civilization-Accelerated/dp/0465002218 http://www.amazon.com/000-Year-Explosion-Civilization-Accele... One large study followed a group of Chinese-Americans who initially did slightly worse on the verbal portion of I.Q. tests than other Americans and the same on math portions. But beginning in grade school, the Chinese outperformed their peers, apparently because they worked harder. Cross group studies that use early-childhood comparisons can mislead, because different rates of development can alter IQ measurements. For instance, if group A on average will have a lower adult IQ, but a faster rate of childhood development, the children of group A may have an equal or higher IQ than average at a young age. It's also noticeable that in twin studies environmental differences matter much more at an early age, and then gradually disappear over time: "Another way to demonstrate the vanishing nature of the shared environment is to look at non-twin siblings. When reared together, their IQ correlation is 0.49 in adulthood. When reared apart, their IQs correlate at 0.24 as children, but this rises to 0.49 in adulthood. Unrelated children, reared together (adopted) correlate at 0.25 in childhood and 0.01 in adulthood." http://members.cox.net/bvv/h2b.html http://members.cox.net/bvv/h2b.html It’s that the most decisive weapons in the war on poverty aren’t transfer payments but education, education, education. Since 1930 government spending on education has risen from 1.5% of GDP to 6% of GDP. That equates to an extra $6,000 per household spent on education. Today 40% of Americans are either in school or working for the education industry. Yet despite this incredible increase in education, measurements of both vocabulary and numeracy have been flat ( http://www.miller-mccune.com/article/349 http://www.miller-mccune.com/article/349 ). So even if IQ could be improved through the environment, the policy implication that we should spend more on education does not follow. What evidence does Kristoff present that spending more on education will make a difference? What dramatic change does he propose to actually make education work as advertised? One study found that a child of professionals (disproportionately white) has heard about 30 million words spoken by age 3; a black child raised on welfare has heard only 10 million words, leaving that child at a disadvantage in school. I hear this study cited more and more. The education establishment needs a new explanation to help account for the continued failure of education spending. Why hasn't spending $800 billion a year on education made a whit of difference in vocab? Well, because we forgot the tots! Perhaps if we increase spending to $1 trillion a year so that we can give toddlers 8 hours a day of vocab immersion, the dream of true equality - as envisioned by authors like Aldous Huxley - will finally be achieved. The next step is intensive early childhood programs, followed by improved elementary and high schools, and programs to defray college costs. I jested in the previous paragraph, but there is a real tragedy here. Six thousand dollars per family is no joke. If differences in achievement stem mostly from genetics, than education spending is really a transfer of wealth from hard working carpenters, machinists, engineers, etc to high IQ teachers and administrators. Thus increasing schooling even more will not wipe out the academic achievement gap, but it will widen the income gap between college grads and the laboring class. After the gap widens more, people like Kristof will then use this as evidence that we are not spending enough on education. This cycle has been in place for 80 years, and it is rotten to the core.
- yters 17y agoSo, why do people care so much about IQ in the first place? If it determines your success, then it doesn't matter what you do, you might as well learn what you are passionate about. If it doesn't, then you should learn what you are passionate about since that'll raise your IQ... The real issue is that people think success is a determiner of human worth. So, if people are inherently less capable of being successful than others, they think they are inherently less of a human. The IQ debate is really a debate about what determines human worth.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe IQ debate is really a debate about what determines human worth. I think you are on to something.
- bokonist 17y agoPolitics. The political left is the faction of academia. As institutions, the universities and the teachers unions wish to reallocate money to education spending [1]. To do so, they must simultaneously get people to believe two things: 1) that scholastic achievement is extremely important and 2) that everyone can achieve any scholastic goal. Conversely, those on the right wish to debunk #2 so that politicians will stop reallocating money to academia, and instead allocate it to their favored causes. Scholastic achievement is closely related to tested IQ. The SAT is a not-so-thinly veiled IQ test. Every American is taught by the educational establishment that both scholastic achievement and the SAT are very important to our future. For the first twenty-two years of our life, we get graded continuously on scholastics, but rarely on character. In all, we are raised to be obsessed about IQ, and we are caught in the midst of a political battle where trillions of dollars are at stake. [1] Note - I do not impute cynical intent to the actual individuals comprising the educational institutions. Institutions promote themselves via selection effects. True believers who believe what's good for Harvard is good for the country will fill the ranks of Harvard and enter leadership positions. Cynics will find jobs elsewhere. Thus an institution will fill with people who sincerely believe in promoting the institution, whether or not the institution actually is doing any good. Thus the actions of an institution as a whole can be self-serving at the harm of the whole, while the individuals comprising it are sincere. Other institutions besides academia have the same effect, see for instance, the 16th Century Catholic Church.