10 ms·
Ship crosses Northwest Passage, sails into history
- chollida1 13y agoFrom the article. > “The Canadian government needs to take a firm stand on shipping via the Northwest passage in order to safeguard the environment and to enforce Canada’s sovereignty, This is a big deal in Canada right now. There have been a bunch of rumblings from our neighbor to the south that maybe Canada doesn't really own the islands in our north and that the Northwest passage should be considered open water for everyone. This is troubling for a number of reasons, specifically sovereignty, mining and oil rights and most importantly shipping of oil and nat. gas through the passage. There is a bid debate going on as to what sort of cargo should be allowed to go through the passage, specifically should oil tankers be allowed. many people want this shipping lane closed to oil tankers, some for environmental reasons, other because they've spent billions on pipe lines. The only consensus you can get in Canada is that we own the shipping lanes and therefor can control what and who goes through it.
- otoburb 13y agoCanada doesn't have the military resources to enforce this without a corresponding increase in military budgets. We will have no choice but to partner with the very same folks who are eyeing these lucrative areas. I guess we'll get a taste of what it feels like to be a country where to protect our resources and land we'll be forced to give some (most?) rights away in exchange for military augmentation and favourable procurement prices.
- jacquesm 13y agoCanada does not have the resources to defend against any scenario. That does not mean that it should be walked over like this either.
- clarkmoody 13y agoWhen it comes to international trade, there simply is no substitute for a strong navy. Friendly relations and treaties with countries possessing strong navies can only go so far.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- otoburb 13y agoI agree with you that countries shouldn't be walked over like this. However, our territorial claims will be ignored if we don't boost funding in a navy fleet, coast guard fleet and/or ports to assist with patrolling. Unfortunately, it's easier said than done given our lack of appetite for even higher taxes which would probably come in the form of a GST hike. It seems our options are: 1) Raise funds to patrol or enforce our territory; 2) Partner with other countries and attempt to negotiate minerals, resources or access in exchange for adherence and continued international recognition of Canada's territorial claims; or 3) Do nothing.
- jacquesm 13y agoCanada is simply too big. Infrastructure and defence are a function of the GDP divided by the area. Too small a GDP or too large an area and you can't properly wire, put roads in or defend a country. Even so, we have these borders that were agreed upon in the past, a change of the weather shouldn't cause such a border to be redrawn.
- VladRussian2 13y ago>a change of the weather shouldn't cause such a border to be redrawn. look at climate changes during last 2-3 thousand years and how whole empires/civilizations got appeared and disappeared as a result. On the [kind of] positive side [for high-tech industry i mean] Canada will become a big customer for air-, ground-, navy- and submarine drones :)
- troymc 13y agoI'm guessing what will happen is that various companies will propose building ports in the Canadian north, and Alaska. Then there will be debates about levels of investment and ownership and preventing oil spills and so on. Similar debates have happened with respect to developing Canada's oil and potash resources (in the interior). I don't see the need for the military to get involved.
- grecy 13y ago> arious companies will propose building ports in the Canadian north, and Alaska. I don't think so, because those ports won't be ice-free, and will therefore be of little use. Valdez (the end of the AK pipeline) is the most northerly year-round ice-free port, and it's not North at all, by AK/Northern Canada standards (I have to drive many hours South to get there...)
- troymc 13y agoCanada already has an arctic port that's iced-in for much of the year: the Port of Churchill on Hudson Bay. Tourists go there to see polar bears. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_of_Churchill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Port_of_Churchill
- otoburb 13y agoAs far as I understand no foreign countries laid claim to Canada's oil and potash resources in the interior. The difference for the Canadian North is that we have a few countries disputing our territorial claims[1] such as Denmark (via Greenland), Russia and the US. Thankfully these disputes are contained within diplomatic channels. My point is not that we must go to war, but that if we expect other countries to obey our laws typically the best way of enforcement is an actual show of force via patrols. Ironically, as I read about the Canadian Coast Guard, it is one of the few coast guard services that has a strictly civilian mandate with no military nor law-enforcement responsibilities[3]. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2007/jul/11/climatechange.climatechange http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2007/jul/11/climatech... [2] http://opencanada.org/features/the-think-tank/comments/2013-a-decisive-year-for-canadian-arctic-ambitions/ http://opencanada.org/features/the-think-tank/comments/2013-... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Coast_Guard#Civilian_role http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Coast_Guard#Civilian_r...
- dhughes 13y agoIt's not so much the shipping that is upsetting it's the arrogant dismissive tone by certain countries deciding the water belongs to everyone because it's convenient for them. When your so-called friends ignore your sovereignty and we are so small population-wise what choices do we have for defence? I know the US wouldn't stand for it if the situation was reversed. Good luck with search and rescue too we have a tough time now finding ships and planes we know about let alone some unknown ship who knows where. The recent Coast Guard helicopter crash is a good example the ship that the helicopter came from knew where they were but still couldn't get to them before they occupants froze to death. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/three-die-in-canadian-coast-guard-helicopter-crash-in-northwest-territories/article14216223/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/three-die-in-ca... Prime Minister Harper is putting a push on lately to visit the north but it's more PR than anything but his party has spoken about building massive Coast Guard ships to patrol the arctic in the winter. I think they had giant tracked wheels on the front to help break ice; the bows of ice breaking ships ride up onto the ice they don't push through the ice.
- Semiapies 13y ago"Sovereignty" and "defense"? Good grief. I guess it's useful for Canadian politicians that they can wrap things like jockeying for a cut of international shipping in both the maple leaf flag and the Canadian inferiority complex. "Good luck with search and rescue too" Waters you can't secure, waters you can't patrol, waters you can't provide search and rescue for...You need to be able to at least give a decent pretense of doing those things in order to board ships and demand money without being called a pirate.
- ianstallings 13y agoActually I would like to put forward a counter point that is does have the capabilities to enforce it. They could put the pressure on the US and EU through the WTO by threatening to cut off oil sand exports (which is already being disputed in public with the EU), Canadian wheat, and logging exports. Canada could bargain with the US and seek to get backing for their EE zones and counter any claims by EU states. Canada and the US already have a close military relationship and the trade between the two countries is larger than any other trade between nations at ~$300B USD thanks to NAFTA. Military warfare is a thing of the past when it comes to nations of our size and strength and what it would do to both. Economic warfare is the new way that Canada can fight. IMHO Canada has a lot to negotiate with.
- Semiapies 13y agoCanada could do that. It'd be profoundly stupid, as Canada would be hurt far more than the US and EU would be. (On the US/EU side, prices would go up, with eventual repercussions. On the CA side, no money would come in for those export industries, and you'd quickly have tons of people laid off and those companies clamoring for government assistance.) But yes, Canada could do that in hopes of getting a cut of potential future shipping money. Their politician probably aren't that foolish, though.
- FigBug 13y agoSlightly more than 100,000 people in 3,867,271 km^2 of the 3 northern territories. (Just under half of Canada by area, bigger than India) It's going to be very hard to assert sovereignty when it's such a large area to monitor with so few people. For example a German weather station build in Labrador in 1943 wasn't found until the 1980s. Who knows what other countries are already doing in Canada's north.
- saym 13y agoLink for the intrigued: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_Station_Kurt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_Station_Kurt
- troymc 13y agoThese days we have remote sensing satellites, plus sophisticated software to analyze their data, so it would be quite a bit more difficult to do something big and go unnoticed.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoIf you rely on non-visible spectrum, its even easier. People and running equipment are going to stand out.
- stekoz 13y agoThere is a reason why Geographic Information Systems (GIS) were created in Canada back in the 1970.
- bsullivan01 13y agoCanada can be the next USA, they just need around 100 million people to start. How about handing out a few acres for the brave souls?:-)
- grecy 13y agoSure, come up here to the Yukon, the government still gives away land up here. As a plus, -40 is fun.
- ubernostrum 13y agoAs I understand it, the island ownership doesn't necessarily solve this; there would still be a dispute over what happens if a passage wider than 24 nautical miles opens up. Canada isn't an archipelagic state, so would not be able to make an argument for the same sort of broad internal waters that, say, the Philippines have, so any such passage would be outside of Canada's territorial waters. There would still be exclusive rights to economically exploit, of course, but Canada would not be able to forbid international shipping through such a passage.
- otoburb 13y agoI didn't pick up on this subtlety. Really good point. Can I ask about the significance of 24 nautical miles? Assuming that's an international boundary condition between Canadian territorial waters vs. international waters?
- ubernostrum 13y agoTerritorial waters extend 12nm from the coast. So if there's a path through that's more than 24nm wide, some part of it must lie outside of Canadian territorial waters, regardless of the status of the islands.
- ianstallings 13y agoYes but exclusive economic zones extend much farther and are how a country can claim parts of the sea. Canada's exclusive economic zone covers this part of the world currently: http://arcticecon.wordpress.com/2012/01/13/the-northwest-passage-dispute-canada-map-with-exclusive-economic-zones/ http://arcticecon.wordpress.com/2012/01/13/the-northwest-pas...
- ubernostrum 13y agoYes, which was why my original comment distinguished between the right to bar shipping and the right to economically exploit. Even if Canada prevails on ownership of every single Arctic island, a passage more than 24nm wide would mean supertankers could come through, and Canada would not be able to forbid it.
- Ras_ 13y ago"Canada does not have a single port along the Northwest Passage but that Russia, by comparison, has 16 deep water ports along its Arctic coastline." The article seems to end by identifying Canada's first major problem. Then you move into things like ice breakers etc. where Russia leads, while Finland and Sweden are ahead of Canada/USA. Here's a nice infograph on world's ice breakers. It tells you something about short-term capabilities / general knowhow in this area. http://news.usni.org/2013/07/23/u-s-coast-guards-2013-reivew-of-major-ice-breakers-of-the-world http://news.usni.org/2013/07/23/u-s-coast-guards-2013-reivew... "Presently, 60% of all diesel icebreakers are produced in Finland, 100% of all nuclear icebreakers are produced in Russia." Meaning Finland and Russia have a big head start here... http://barentsnova.com/node/1573 http://barentsnova.com/node/1573
- Gravityloss 13y agoYou can buy icebreakers easily. We would be happy to sell you as many as you want as the global shipbuilding industry is doing extremely badly. Just last week a whole dock was shut down in Rauma, Finland.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoIn the mean time, Canada is spending $300 million just to acquire the ability to build ice breakers. http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/shipbuilding-contract-holds-250m-mystery-1.1300816 http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/shipbuilding-contract-holds-...
- vacri 13y agoCanada has icebreaking hovercraft - I remember seeing a documentary with footage of the driver doing spinouts in the giant machines. My first impression was that the demand for that job must be intense.
- ianstallings 13y agoGiven Canada's already claimed that area part of it's Exclusive Economic Zone: http://arcticecon.wordpress.com/2012/01/13/the-northwest-passage-dispute-canada-map-with-exclusive-economic-zones/ http://arcticecon.wordpress.com/2012/01/13/the-northwest-pas... I would think that any nation calling it "international waters" is going to cause a lot of problems. Now that doesn't mean they should tax anyone that passes through, but fishing and port rights will obviously be part of it and there will probably be an agreement made through organizations such as the G8 or WTO to counter any threats to that exclusivity. Basically it's just going to be negotiation time and Canada will come out the winner. IMHO. Edit: why on earth was I down voted? Err, whatever. Sorry for my fact-based opinion. Loons.
- Semiapies 13y agoEEZs are for resource-extraction, not shipping.
- saym 13y agoCan I use this as a tangible example of climate change when discussing with my doubting f̶i̶e̶n̶d̶s̶ friends?
- mvalle 13y agoNot necessarily: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roald_Amundsen#Northwest_Passage_.281903.E2.80.931906.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roald_Amundsen#Northwest_Passag...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hristov 13y agoThere is a difference between Amundsen a seasoned explorer making the passage in a tiny 46 ton ship by hugging the coast and dodging ice and a 75 THOUSAND ton ship making the trip.
- cromulent 13y agoIt took less than 3 weeks. Amundsen (awesome as he is) took 3 years and 3 foot of water.
- hristov 13y agoYes.
- clarkmoody 13y agoDo your friends doubt climate change is happening at all? Or do they doubt that it's our fault?
- saym 13y agoI love the man, but my father listens to Rush Limbaugh. It's difficult to find facts he accepts on global warming. For all the vitriol he spews, Rush does an impressive job at framing situations so that he's impossible to argue with.
- 13y ago
- cbr 13y agoThe important thing isn't the crossing, it's not needing to be accompanied by an icebreaker. The oil tanker SS Manhattan [1] made the trip in 1969, but unassisted crossing makes this economically competitive. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Manhattan_(1962) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SS_Manhattan_(1962)
- enupten 13y agoYes, and that is likely going to mean that, the Arctic is never going to freeze again (if this takes off). Goodbye, Polar bears, we like you, but we don't think your survival is in our "national interests". Meh.
- enupten 13y agoThe sad thing is that, apart from whatever feedbacks are there in the environement, there are far to many economic feedbacks pushing our civilization towards greater environmental destruction. Do you think there will such a furore over Canadian tar sands, when the oil from the middle east comes to a trickle ? When the fertilizer plants stop, plastics manufacturing ends, and transporting coal becomes harder ? Should governments care for the Earth or its subjects ? I'm sorry for being so dystopian, but I don't think Science has the ability to bear the burden of, what will be, 10 billion people. This will happen sometime, I just wish I'm not alive to see the day; climate change makes it much worse.
- kamjam 13y agoThis is the first thing that crossed my mind when I even read the title. This is a sad thing and I don't think it is a cause for celebration. Next up, oil platforms in the Arctic.
- VladRussian2 13y ago>Next up, oil platforms in the Arctic. on that side. Other side is already full steam: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aG0VgaMUm_c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aG0VgaMUm_c
- redthrowaway 13y agoI'm curious what this will mean for international shipping as a whole. Not having to transit the Panama Canal means freighters are limited in size only by the dimensions of their ports of call. That alone might make the Northwest Passage attractive even for those routes where it's not the shortest path.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoKeep in mind that the locks of the Panama canal are getting bigger. By 2015 a new set of locks will increase capacity of the canal and also allow ships that are up to 60% wider (55m), 33% longer (427m), and with 45% deeper draft (18m) to pass through. Granted, even that size is not large enough to accommodate a monster like a Maersk triple-E class container ship (which is 59m wide and has too deep a draft to dock anywhere in the Americas), but the vast majority of the largest container ships in the world (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_container_ships http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_container_ships) will fit (91 out of 100 by my count). Whereas none of the ships on that list could pass through the current locks in the Panama canal.
- ianstallings 13y agoAnd China plans on building another canal through Central America: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/10212169/Chinese-entrepreneur-reveals-route-for-Nicaraguan-canal.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/1021216...
- kgermino 13y agoI realize you mentioned this, but there would be ships bigger than New Panamax[1] and if nothing else a Northwester Passage might mean that more larger ships get built. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panamax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panamax Interesting, if nothing else.
- pyrocat 13y agoWelp. Countdown until a giant oil spill in the arctic.
- enupten 13y agoIt is very sad to see that this is the case. I'm becoming more convinced that Humans have become, as Attenborough put it, a plague on the Earth.
- drob 13y agoAh, fantastic. The only thing missing from the global warming "debate" was a party that heavily benefits from a melted arctic.
- plq 13y agoAs far as I know, they could only have used Iridium satellites for communications. All of the alternatives that I'm aware of have satellites on geostationary orbit, which makes it impossible to cover anywhere outside 80 degrees North and South, whereas Iridium has 75 (originally 77, one failed, another collided with a defunct Russian satellite) satellites on the polar LEO orbit that covers literally the whole earth. Iridium constellation consists of LEO satellites which have an orbital period of less than two hours. Trivia: Iridium is #77 in the periodic table.
- droithomme 13y agoThere are only a small number of countries that consider the entire Arctic to be national/internal waters. Most of the world, including the US (http://www.parl.gc.ca/Content/LOP/researchpublications/prb0561-e.htm#BRelations http://www.parl.gc.ca/Content/LOP/researchpublications/prb05...) and all of the EU other than Denmark and Norway, consider the Arctic to be international waters. In this particular case the coal was being shipped from Canada, which benefits Canada, who happens to claim to own much of the Arctic. Presumably ships carrying Canadian cargo would be cleared to use this route, and legally be required to seek such clearance in order to be cleared to leave Canadian port. Other ships which do not leave from, refuel at, or stop on Canadian land, would presumably be asked to seek permission to pass through what most of the world considers international waters. There are only certain countries that would even want to, but it would obviously be useful for China, Japan and Korea to use this route for shipments to Europe. Eventually someone will take the route without permission, and then Canada will need to figure out to what extent they can assert their claimed ownership of the Arctic. Should Canada succeed in their claims internationally, it may be a good opportunity for other countries to make use of the new doctrine as well. For example Somalia has long claimed that ships going through the Suez canal are passing through their territory, and other nations claim that these are international waters not subject to Somalian boarding for inspection and collection of fees (which other countries call piracy). It will be interesting to see if Canada prevails in its Arctic claims, while maintaining Somalia has no similar claims to control of what they consider national waters, which don't extend anywhere nearly as far from land as Canada is claiming here.
- AYBABTME 13y agoThe difference with Somalia is that the Northwest passage is bounded up, down, left, right, by Canada's territory and not only passing near it. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d0/Northwest_passage.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d0/Northwes... The northern islands have been part of the territory since 1880. Claiming the water in between them aren't part of Canada's territory seems odds. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_evolution_of_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_evolution_of_Canad... Note: I'm no specialist in this domain and I've only done a cursory research to form this argument.
- 13y ago
- whyenot 13y agoThanks in part to humanity's over use of fossil fuels, the northwest passage is now open for commerce. The first cargo ship to make it unaided through the passage carries a load of coal. It's sad and funny.