3 ms·
In other words, they are still guessing, however to keep themselves in business they give their dire predictions even more wildly varied results and put them fa
by Shivetya 13y ago
In other words, they are still guessing, however to keep themselves in business they give their dire predictions even more wildly varied results and put them far enough out that accurate incremental measurement is meaningless, 26cm over the next ninety years? So in four years or so when the next reports comes out what will the prediction be.
That is the key here, its prediction based on theory. They are constantly having to adjust this because they haven't got it figured out. They do seem adept at changing the years referenced, its likely cherry picking data is far easier when you keep moving the points.
When called to task to explain why observed data is not matching models they always fall back on the "the time frame is too short" or other such nonsense. Call me when there aren't so many people more interested in profit, political or monetary, who push this
- sambeau 13y ago"In other words, they are still guessing" That's called science. Only it isn't guessing.
- kaybe 13y agoHey, it's complicated, ok? New information and data improve the models and add more influences like ground-atmosphere interaction or sea-atmosphere gas exchange. It means the results at the current state will not be exact and might have variations. That doesn't mean the basic theory is in doubt and the problem doesn't exist. (And theory does mean set of rules, proven by experiment after experiment after experiment, not some random idea someone had.) If one of us found decisive arguments againt climate change - just imagine the money that person could make, and the good news, and the fame.. and there's too many idealistic researchers (and students) around for noone to go that way. And in the long run, it will be necessary either way to control the climate, just look at those million years temperature charts, thus funding might go down but not away.
- DanBC 13y agoThe lack of imagination from some HN readers is always disappointing when climate change is discussed. Imagine for a moment that climate change is a scam, and isn't happening, and that we're all wrong about it. Why are increasing efficiency, reducing waste, investigating new energy generation methods, etc, bad things? Bob has a car that can do 25 MPG. Does he want more cup holders, or does he want better fuel efficiency? (actually, he probably wanted more cupholders, which is one of the reasons the US car industry is so broken now. I know you need comfy cars when you drive so far, but I don't understand why you don't need better fuel efficiency even if fuel is cheap.) PS: Googlers: It'd be interesting to see how popular a (https://www.google.com/lowercarbon https://www.google.com/lowercarbon) site would be. That site would use Google's best tech to aggressively reduce the CO2 cost of searching. (http://www.slate.com/articles/business_and_tech/design/2004/03/drink_me.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business_and_tech/design/2004/...) > In a recent New Yorker article on sport-utility vehicles and safety, Malcolm Gladwell quotes the French cultural anthropologist G. Clotaire Rapaille expressing amazement that the first thing educated car-buyers look at in a car is how many cup holders it has. My experience is that people shopping for a new car or truck are more discriminating. It is not so much the number of cup holders as their design that can tip the balance between choosing one vehicle over another. (I have repeatedly heard articulate people say that their family's latest automobile purchase hinged on which cup holders worked best for them.)
- npongratz 13y ago> Why are increasing efficiency, reducing waste, investigating new energy generation methods, etc, bad things? These are not bad things. They are clearly good things. The "bad thing" is when someone proposes to use government force and threats to push these things to market. Obviously, force and threats are bad. If these things are good enough, then smart people engaged in peaceful, free exchange will introduce them to market. No force or threats necessary.
- rtpg 13y ago>obviously, force and threats are bad Dunno about that. Some people don't mind the existence of government to patch some things up. Force and threats are pretty useful when trying to fix market failures or tragedy of the commons-type situations. Lack of regulations wouldn't suddenly create free markets because consumers aren't always smart , information isn't perfect, sometimes there are only two producers (so there's pricing influence), etc.
- glenra 13y agoThere's no free lunch. Mandating more gas efficiency means you necessarily get less of other important things people like and want, such as safety and cost savings. One way to make cars a lot more fuel efficient would be to get rid of the weight of the roll cage...but then more people would die in auto accidents. Another would be to replace much of the metal with stronger, lighter, higher-tech alloys...but then the car would cost twice as much. That's the sort of tradeoff that makes a difference. If we could somehow get rid of all the mandates - not just the environmental ones - we'd tend to see better overall cars and a wider range of cars available with some that specialize in super-low emissions while others specialize in better safety or higher performance or whatever. But just piling on new requirements atop all the previous ones isn't going to get you major improvement - there's diminishing return on that.
- DanBC 13y ago> Mandating more gas efficiency means you necessarily get less of other important things people like and want, such as safety and cost savings. ...or cup holders. See parent post.
- cowcatcher 13y agoRight, this report is based on input from groups like Greenpeace and the WWF. What is the point of posting this leftist troll bait?