3 ms·
As a non-American, it seems strange to me that such a successful centre of innovation -- the bay area -- can survive within what is, from all reports, an utterl
by cperciva 17y ago
As a non-American, it seems strange to me that such a successful centre of innovation -- the bay area -- can survive within what is, from all reports, an utterly dysfunctional state. Can someone here with more understanding of US politics explain how this is possible?
- anigbrowl 17y agoIt wasn't always as dysfunctional, or the debts as yawning. CA's fortunes tend to swing with the economic winds. When things are good, you can make a ton of money here, and that tends to make people forget what it's like when things are bad. This is also how our property market came to be sooo overheated.
- mustpax 17y agoAs a wiser man once said, "the reports of my death are greatly exaggerated." California has big problems, but remember that it is also the 10th largest economy in the world (at least it was in 2007 according to the CIA factbook). These problems, given the scale of California's operations are never fatal, and usually quite temporary hiccups. The state also tends to march to the beat of its own drum, which is not entirely unique coughTexascough, but this intensifies the criticisms of California's idiosyncrasies, and it's left leaning government expenditure programs. The Bay Area, for all its business hustle and bustle, owes its origins to this, dare I say, quite Commie mentality. It's the blend of this socialist and capitalist ideology that creates an original mix of creativity and business sense.
- alex_c 17y agoit's left leaning government expenditure programs. [...] Commie mentality. It's the blend of this socialist and capitalist ideology I keep reading similar sentiments, but I don't really understand it. I believe the tax rate is basically on par with Canada's (so, pretty high). However, to give two counterexamples, California obviously doesn't have universal health care, and I've never seen as many homeless people as in the Bay area (the weather might have something to do with it). So what does all that money get spent on, compared to other states which might be more right-leaning or have lower tax rates?
- krakensden 17y agoThe prisons. Three strikes means we have an awful lot of prisoners. There's also a lot of dysfunctional allocation- in the school system, for instance, a majority of funds are earmarked for specific purposes, like special ed, regardless of local conditions. Which leads to bizarre things like bankrupt districts embarking on multi-million building projects.
- bwd 17y agoI think California succeeds in spike of its political system, not because of it. The bay area has fantastic weather, a cultured urban center, plenty of nearby outdoor activities, and a climate of technological innovation that predates many of the problems with the political system. I have never personally visited L.A. but it is also reported to have excellent weather, and is clearly a center of the entertainment industry (this development once again occurring before their problems got really bad). I've lived a semi-nomadic lifestyle for most of my life, and have wanted to move to California, but have not done so precisely because of the high taxes and the dysfunctional politics, which make some sort of disaster seem almost inevitable. The question is not how it survives, but how much better it could be if the system worked properly given the number of advantages that the state enjoys.