3 ms·
Lest any youngsters take seriously the value of shares a startup is offering you, take a look at how seriously the author takes it: > With retention structures
by justin66 13y ago
Lest any youngsters take seriously the value of shares a startup is offering you, take a look at how seriously the author takes it:
> With retention structures and contracts, a buyer can make sure the money goes where they want it to go — to a promising junior engineer they want to keep on, for example, instead of the office manager who technically owned 20% of the company’s equity.
"Technically owned." Yeah. Think about that.
It's adorable that the author has that money going to a junior engineer rather than management in his example. Don't be sucked in.
- stephengillie 13y agoLike technically correct, "technically owned" is the best kind of ownership.
- walshemj 13y agoYes explain to me this concept of "technical" ownership which you dont actually own something.
- Retric 13y agoYou own shares but the total number of shares is not fixed. Say you own 20,000 shares out of 100,000 shares and you own 20% of the company, they issue another 9,900,000 shares 10 min befores selling the company and you now own 0.2%.
- pedalpete 13y agoThere are dilution clauses in contracts that cover these things, but yes, you should be aware how your ownership stake is handled.
- walshemj 13y agosounds like fraud to me.
- dhugiaskmak 13y agoWelcome to the world of finance.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoLike "technically owning" DVDs for example.
- kogir 13y agoUsually it's common shares that are affected. If your company sells for $15 million, but $20 million was invested with 1x preference, there's not enough money to pay out investors, let alone common. It doesn't require dirty tricks like issuing more shares, and happens reasonably often. In cases like the above, investors will often agree to take even less and allow some of the money to go directly to employees as retention bonuses. It's still sometimes better for them to get some rather than no money back.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nugget 13y agoThis only works up to a certain valuation and on a certain % ratio. Yahoo paid $1.1 billion for Tumblr and $70m personally to retain Karp. They probably couldn't have paid $1 billion for the company and $170m for Karp, for example, without permission from his shareholders. And even then, any shareholder could hold out, claim fraud and file a lawsuit. In smaller startups, up to the low teens or maybe 20 million, it's true that there is less protection for common shareholders. Many deals are <50% payment to the shareholders and >50% payment to acquired and retained employees. But in most of these cases the primary value IS the team itself. In a case where you, as a shareholder (either employee or investor), felt there was real value in the assets, independent of the team, that was stolen away in an improper acqui-hire type deal, you could sue and cause all sorts of problems for everyone. Of course the best rule is still and always has been to try to work for people whom you trust and stay far away from those you don't.
- netcan 13y agoThere are certain protections and more importantly, risk awareness & risk mitigation for investor-shareholders that employee-shareholders rarely have. They don't have the information. The savy or bargaining power to negotiate the specifics of their contracts. Etc. That doesn't mean the equity is worthless. It's a few steps up from a verbal commitment but it has the same caveat, you need to trust the person its coming from.
- buckbova 13y agoOptions (if you are publicly traded) are a great way to pay talent to stick around, especially if your stock is trending upwards.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThey used to be. But the market and IPOs are much different today.