4 ms·
Not wrong but misleading. Agriculture lead to a massive increase in effective population size and in selection parameters, some of which were very strong and su
by barry-cotter 17y ago
Not wrong but misleading. Agriculture lead to a massive increase in effective population size and in selection parameters, some of which were very strong and sustained. The higher population means more mutations which means more raw material to work with in terms of potential beneficial mutations. As for recently selected alleles the canonical example is probaaly lactose tolerance. You can make a good case its behind the spread of the I-E language family. As another example alcohol tolerance, better tolerance for high starch diet and lower levels of ADD in populations with long histories of agriculture. Contrast recent hunter-gatherers like Oz aboriginies or 'nesians with Europeans or Chinese. Diabetes, alcoholism, poor educational outcomes because of the ADD and other things. AFAIK ADD is practically unknown among East Asians, subsistence rice farming and more than a millenium of civil service exams as social mobility would both select against it.
- Retric 17y ago10,000 years is a blink in the eye in terms of human evolution. The problem is the time it takes people to have children. Assuming the average parent is 20, and you go back 20 generations (1000 years) you only have 1 million ancestors which is still a small subset of the population. Thinking in the other direction useful mutations only spread as they help people survive longer / have more children so the change is normally vary slow. If anything the shift to agriculture has reduced genetic diversity as stuff that had little impact on hunter gatherers are culled from a civilized society. PS: Alcoholism is actually the default, populations with a long history of alcohol use have far less Alcoholism. However, it's far from eliminated in society's that have been using Alcohol for thousands of years.
- barry-cotter 17y agoRe:alcoholism, yes that was whajt I was trying to say, apologies if I was unclear. But as for fast genetic change 99% or so of Danes are lactose tolerant. Among Chinese less than 5. Agricultural populations will only have less variation than h-gs due to population bottlenecks or if a h-g variant is selected against in an agricultural environment. For a small effect gene assume a 1% higher survival rate. I'm not really up on the maths but with 10k years with 25 year generation time we have 400 generations. I think that's plenty of time to reach fixation. If I was at a computer instead of doing this at my phone I'd do it properly, but if you google the Hardy-Weinberg equation something useful should come up. As a thought experiment consider the polynesian migrations. Assume that given the longer distance between islands each migration event between islands culls thd weakest 20% so each new founder population has a higher mean muscle mass. That's a one generation selection a lot higher than 1%. With 5 such events it wouldn't surprise me if you moved 1or 2 standard deviations in the mean. Look at the difference in physiogonomx between native Taiwaneese and Maori. Less than 1000 years in those migrations, IIRC.
- philwelch 17y agoADD is pretty much the deepest evolutionary change that would have happened to humans post-agriculture. I'm not sure if lactose tolerance is genetic, or if it is the result of acidophilus symbiosis (or both?) Here's a couple other nitpicks: 1. Lots of white people have ADD 2. Lots of East Asians are descended from the Mongols, who were hunter-gatherers well into medieval times.
- barry-cotter 17y agoI don't know anything about acidophilus but it certainly has a very, very large genetic component. 1. White/Caucasians do still have ADD sure but its definitely lower than h-gs. Just so story explanation: more fragmented government together with a crop package that didn't support the same kind of population density as rice, and hence a smaller government/military class meant there were still benefits to ADD, just at lower frequencies than as hunter-gatherers. Frequency dependent selection like psychopathy or morphs generally. 2. AIUI East Asian means Chinese, Japanese and Korean, Vietnamese if you're really pushing it. The important bit is rice farming, with long histories of stable government, occasionally interupted bx war-is-hell but not really disrupting the system. The North Chinese are wheat farmers and relatively genetically distinct from their brethren. They, and the Mongols do almost certainly have higher levels of ADD but I'd bet against it being higher, even as high as amonp Europeans. Even taking the Mongols as East Asian they're a rounding error if you're counting .ch,.jp and .kr
- philwelch 17y ago"AIUI East Asian means Chinese, Japanese and Korean, Vietnamese if you're really pushing it." All except Japan were within the Mongol empire mere centuries ago. All have significant genetic influence from the hunting/gathering Mongol hordes. Don't underestimate the genetic influence that nomadic tribes of horseback rapists can have when they conquer a continent.
- dkarl 17y agoAIUI East Asian means Chinese Perhaps you should say Han instead of Chinese? In context it looks like you mean to exclude Uighurs, Manchus, and other non-Han ethnic groups.