4 ms·
Being from a solidly middle class family (my mother is an elementary school teacher) puts me at the 10th or 15th percentile by family income at Harvard. The Ivi
by jacobolus 17y ago
Being from a solidly middle class family (my mother is an elementary school teacher) puts me at the 10th or 15th percentile by family income at Harvard. The Ivies are indeed institutions mainly for the wealthy and the super-wealthy.
I'm not sure that most people you ask at Harvard would favor a "classless society". A distressingly large percentage of them want to go join a financial consulting firm or hedge fund and make as much money as they can right out of school.
- req2 17y agoI don't think it's a terribly larger percentage than at any other college. The guys at the other colleges just regret that they don't have the leg up on such a plan that Harvard would give them.
- jacobolus 17y agoCould be. But a few years ago, 40% of the graduating class got jobs in finance. I find that a sickening indictment of our whole society and its priorities.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoI agree. I just want to add that this is what happens when the financial sector gets so heavily subsidized by the government, directly and indirectly. That's where the money is sent, so that's where the fat salaries are. I've heard truly disgusting stories about how cash is spent on Wall Street.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoA distressingly large percentage of them want to go join a financial consulting firm or hedge fund and make as much money as they can right out of school. Oh, I absolutely agree. But ask them directly and quite a few of them will still tell you, with a straight face, that they want a classless society.
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoA distressingly large percentage of them want to go join a financial consulting firm or hedge fund and make as much money as they can right out of school. Why is this distressing? Few people really want a true "classless society". I'd assume that few of the founders on HN plan on donating 100% of all income they earn above the median level.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoThis wasn't addressed to me, but I'd say it's distressing because the financial sector has been artificially stimulated by the government for decades. Resources which would have been directed to more productive uses were instead sent to finance. Who knows how much we've lost because some smart people were screwing around on Wall Street instead of doing something more useful?
- sho 17y ago"Few people really want a true "classless society". I'd assume that few of the founders on HN plan on donating 100% of all income they earn above the median level." There's a difference between believing that a classless society is a worthy goal and, noticing that one is not currently in a classless society and that being in an above average class has certain benefits, seeking to achieve an elevated class for the time being. I would like to think I am a fairly strong believer in a classless post-scarcity utopia, but giving away most of what I own is not going to bring that any closer - all I'd be doing is reducing my own power to act. Better to retain it for now and use it to work towards the long term goal. Sounds self-serving, maybe, but what can you do?
- adw 17y agoThings like this make me glad to have grown up in the UK. I went to Cambridge, which is (at least academically) as good a university as you can find, and it's a state school. You apply through the unified UCAS system and the fees - around £3000 a year now, I think - are the same as you'd pay at almost any UK university. Sure, you get more private school kids and people from rich backgrounds, but it's not nearly as unbalanced as the scenario you paint.