11 ms·
Disappointing, but not a surprise: 1. Galaxy S 3 includes undeletable Pizza Hut bookmark http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1707047 http://forum.
by nailer 13y ago
Disappointing, but not a surprise:
1. Galaxy S 3 includes undeletable Pizza Hut bookmark http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1707047 http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1707047
2. Galaxy custom web browser allows random web sites to make links that wipe and reset the phone: http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/117422-samsung-galaxy-s-3-reset http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/117422-samsung-galaxy-s-3-re...
- panacea 13y agoI sure could eat a chocolate Kit-Kat right about now... who's with me, open source brethren? (Kinda Suprise banned in the US)
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoDid you mean Kinder Egg? Or are you poking fun of the recent Android name / announcement thing?
- dingaling 13y ago> I sure could eat a chocolate Kit-Kat right about now... Technically Kit-Kats aren't chocolate. The Germans refer to vegetable fat-based cocoa mixes as glazed fat, the French mockingly call them brown margarine. But under a controversial European Parliament ruling, vegetable fat mixes are permitted to be sold as family milk chocolate or house chocolate. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/678141.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/678141.stm
- markbao 13y agoThe link that resets phones in #2 resets them without warning. Along with #1 and this article, I'm seriously baffled that any company can be this incompetent.
- m_mueller 13y ago#2 is a link from September 2012. You mean this is still not fixed (as in >99% can update to a version that is fixed)? Edit: "UPDATED 26 September: Samsung has told SlashGear that Galaxy S III users should ensure their phone is running the latest software as this resolves any issues: 'We would like to assure our customers that the recent security issue concerning the GALAXY S III has already been resolved through a software update. We recommend all GALAXY S III customers to download the latest software update, which can be done quickly and easily via the Over-The-Air (OTA) service.' Question: Is this OTA Update depending on whether providers let those updates through?
- ZoFreX 13y agoRegarding #2, that bug was fixed a year ago to the day, according to the very source you linked. I feel it's unfair to include what was clearly a mistake in the same category as deliberate malicious activity (#1 and the linked article)
- nailer 13y agoAgreed, one is incompetence (remember, the stock Android browser had to be specifically patched by Samsung to enable the feature) and the others are simply not caring that much about customers. I don't feel it's unfair though.
- eli 13y agoIs the Pizza Hut bookmark from Vodafone or Samsung? I have a Galaxy S 3 from T-Mobile and I don't have any bookmarks like that. It does have useless undeletable T-Mobile apps, but that's clearly T-Mobile's fault.
- mikeash 13y agoIt's also clearly Samsung's fault for not simply refusing to include those apps.
- eli 13y agoshrug I guess so. I'm not sure they have as much leverage as Apple did with the iPhone. (Fun aside: Verizon was Apple's first choice for a launch carrier, but Verizon balked at the level of control they wanted over the device. Well, that and the cut of the monthly data plan fee.)
- selectodude 13y agoAnd then Verizon hemorrhaged customers until the CDMA iPhone 4 came out. I doubt people would be willing to switch carriers to get the Galaxy S5 (there is a lot of substitute goods in the Android world), nor does Samsung care to find out.
- gamblor956 13y ago#1 is not a GS3 problem, it is a carrier problem specific to Vodafone, which had a marketing deal with Pizza Hut at the time of the GS3's release. Other carriers did not forcibly include undeletable Pizza Hut bookmarks.
- nailer 13y agoWould Apple let Vodafone do the same?
- nwh 13y agoCuriously, a SIM can enforce bookmarks and contacts on a new iPhone- but they're certainly deletable.
- shurcooL 13y agoA sim can have contacts, but bookmarks? Are you sure?
- vl 13y agoI just put in Italian Vodafone SIM into unlocked iPhone 4S with iOS 7 and got Vodafone bookmark in Safari, which is indeed deletable. Haven't noticed new contacts so far.
- giovannibajo1 13y agoIt's not the SIM, it's the carrier bundle. Each iPhone ships (and updates) some XML files for each operator that contain all specific operator settings. These vary from radio configurations to features lock/unlock; eg: you can tell the iPhone how to remote-check whether tethering is activated on the data plan, and change the UI accordingly; it can also contain a custom action box to show to the user when they try to activate the feature, and/or activate the feature itself directly, communicating to the operator network so that they can bill the user. Carrier bundles also allow carriers to specify bookmarks to add to Safari, the idea being that users "might find useful" to have direct links to check their invoices or so. Such bookmarks are of course deletable.
- afterburner 13y agoMy S3 has never had a Pizza Hut bookmark. Never had the second problem.
- piyush_soni 13y agoAll those complaining about Vodaphone S3 coming with a little bookmark which can't be deleted, and still somehow don't find Apple's crapware which can't be uninstalled too bad, two things: 1) That was really only the stock browser. You can very easily install much better browsers and make them the default - Chrome, Firefox, Dolphin browser. Isn't it amazing and unheard of in Apple's world? 2) And, FYI, you can still delete those bookmarks by a small trick, without rooting. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1707047 http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1707047
- comex 13y agoThere was also a trick to hide Newsstand in a folder without jailbreaking, before that became a feature. Doesn't matter to almost all users. I'd say the main factors for determining whether something is "crapware" are (a) the inherent odiousness of the software/bookmark/etc., (b) the difficulty of avoiding it, and (c) the level of technical justification for making it unremovable... For Pizza Hut: (a) very odious, because it's pure marketing, irrelevant to the normal use of the device, and adds no useful functionality, since most users probably don't want a Pizza Hut bookmark, or could easily add one if they did; (b) requires switching completely to a new browser; (c) none, since a user is very unlikely to accidentally delete the bookmark and then be at a loss for how I get it back. For Apple apps: (a) not much, since the apps are well designed and using Apple services with Apple's phone is a normal use case that applies to most users; (b) generally can be entirely avoided by moving to a folder, although it isn't always possible to replicate their functionality in third party apps, which is unfortunate (the previous inability to do so with Newsstand is essentially an implementation defect, since it was treated as a folder itself); (c) some, since although all apps ought to be redownloadable from the App Store, system apps are sort of a holdover from the original iPhone OS, and most new Apple apps have been put on the App Store, even things like iBooks. Neither situation is great, but there's a big difference.