4 ms·
Amazon isn't the whole problem, it's just that Amazon was the winner. It used to be that most towns had a bookstore, and larger towns or cities had several. Ev
by dsr_ 13y ago
Amazon isn't the whole problem, it's just that Amazon was the winner.
It used to be that most towns had a bookstore, and larger towns or cities had several. Eventually they were displaced by chains: Waldenbooks and B. Dalton, Borders and Barnes & Noble. First the chains chased out the independent bookstores by being able to cut costs and order more efficiently; then the chains ate each other at the same time that Amazon was cutting costs even further. Now there's one limping chain, B&N, and some specialized chains -- mostly religious, secondhand or otherwise discount -- and Amazon.
Efficiency is best served by a single distribution system with maximum economies of scale. That isn't actually a desirable outcome for customers or producers, though.
- Spooky23 13y agoI think the key thing is that efficiency isn't the same as a free market, but people tend to equate the two things. It's a rectangle/square problem: free markets drive efficiency, but efficiency doesn't drive free markets. When an efficient competitor "wins" and drives the competition out of business, everyone loses, as that competitor eventually turns into an entrenched toll-taker. As a consumer, you want your vendors fighting each other all of the time. The situation in books, where Amazon tolerates the existence of B&N, and doesn't give a hoot about Jesus books isn't good for anyone.
- JackFr 13y agoI don't think its fair to say that "it isn't good for anyone." I remember buying books before Borders, the big Barnes & Nobles and Amazon. It sucked. The selection was poor, it was impossible to order, because it was very hard to know what was available. I even used order books by mail order. (In particular Dover published a catalog which had a lot of their math and science reprints. You'd fill in an order form and send it with a check through the mail; 4-6 weeks later your books would arrive.) The current situation for the consumer is much better.
- ceedan 13y agoAgreed, book publishers need to work on their marketing and sales. If they were able to target their audience more directly and efficiently, they wouldn't need to rely on Amazon. No Starch Press (nostarchpress.com) did a fine job selling "Learn You Some Erlang for Great Good!" (and their other programming titles) without Amazon.com
- Spooky23 13y agoAgreed. Too sweeping of a statement. I should have said "in the long run, it isn't good for anyone". I used to camp alot in the Adirondacks in upstate NY. There was one grocery store that was basically the only store in a 50 mile radius. Guess what? The store hours sucked, and milk was $4/half gallon. Even now, it's difficult to resolve situations with Amazon -- good luck figuring out how to contact a human to resolve a complex problem.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- polarix 13y agoWhy is this not a desirable outcome for customers?
- waxjar 13y agoBecause you end up with a monopoly.
- ierceg 13y agoMonopoly is just a description of a market situation. You're using it as a pejorative term without actually explaining why, in this particular case, it's a bad thing.
- the_watcher 13y agoMonopolies are bad only because the winner in a monopoly nearly always uses their market position to increase the barrier to entry to upstarts, often by lobbying for increased regulations (costs) in the market that didn't exist when they started. If monopolies (at least some - Amazon works as an example) operated in the same way they did on their way up - looking for ways to disrupt and improve on the status quo rather than looking for ways to ensure the status quo does not change, they wouldn't be nearly the negative force that they generally are.
- JackFr 13y agoI assume because monopolists can demand economic rents. But I imagine that Amazon is continuously under competitive pressure -- consider the disruption e-books caused. Had that caught Amazon flat-footed, it could have decimated their book business.
- grey-area 13y agoBecause once a company obtains a monopoly, their interests and those of the customer diverge, and there's no longer any control imposed by the market, because there is no market - just one initially efficient supplier with no incentive to remain efficient and every incentive to boost their margins at the expense of producers and customers. This is why we have a regulated market, and rules about monopolies.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Touche 13y ago> Now there's one limping chain, B&N, and some specialized chains -- mostly religious, secondhand or otherwise discount -- and Amazon. That's not true, there are many online book sellers out there, and I'm guessing not all of them are in danger of going out of business. Amazon is the biggest player, but what has played out is that book selling is too low-margin to be viable as a meat-space transaction.