3 ms·
The underlying problem with patents is basically that the upside of owning a patent is essentially unlimited, where as the cost is finite (and large for an indi
by beagle3 13y ago
The underlying problem with patents is basically that the upside of owning a patent is essentially unlimited, where as the cost is finite (and large for an individual, but peanuts for an established corporation).
What needs to be done is make those two things related: For example, require patent holders to declare the value of a patent on their tax filings (say, in April for the previous year), pay a 1% tax on that value, and limit any infringements damages to that value (per defendant, per year). Perhaps also make a forced "imminent domain" seizure possible by any sued part for 10x of the value.
We do not want anyone to have a patent economically worth $100K or less being able to assert it to stop production of something worth $100M or more -- and yet, the current system facilitates that (see e.g. eolas vs. ms, the xml case against microsoft, creative vs. carmack).
Once you have a "cost of carry" for patents, carrying offensive patents will become expensive enough that patent holders assign value (thus, enforceability) to patents they dim worthy.
(And no, this does not push a "small inventor" or "small patent holder" out of the game. If you have a patent worth $100M but do not have much more than $1M to enforce it, you do NOT have a patent worth $100M - litigation is going to cost you much more than that; They are already out of the patent game - so let's fix other aspects first)