4 ms·
"So 'this statement is false' is false if and only if it's true, so there's a problem." I don't understand this. This seems to assume that the meaning of a phr
by Alex3917 17y ago
"So 'this statement is false' is false if and only if it's true, so there's a problem."
I don't understand this. This seems to assume that the meaning of a phrase is contained within the phrase itself. But if you instead assume that the phrase is a pointer to meaning that is contained somewhere else then the paradox goes away.
- parenthesis 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liar_paradox#Possible_resolutions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liar_paradox#Possible_resolutio...
- Alex3917 17y agoInteresting. So what I was getting at was exactly what Tarski said. Except for that he coined some cool words for his explanation, which I will steal for future use.
- ubernostrum 17y agoExcept Tarski didn't really solve it, he just kinda swept it under the rug. The object language/metalanguage distinction introduces an infinite regression (since, the moment you want to talk about the metalanguage, you need a metametalanguage for those statements, which means you'll need a metametametalanguage, and so on). And then Godel blew everything up anyway :)
- anigbrowl 17y agoWell, that's a pretty large assumption. At least in american English, the phrase 'this _____' is commonly understood to be self-referential in some manner unless some other context has been previously established. For example: This sentence contains ten words and is a true statement. If you haven't read Godel, Escher, Bach, now is the time.
- Alex3917 17y agoSelf-referrential to the words themselves, or to the meaning of the words?
- anigbrowl 17y agoEither, and occasionally both, my favorite example being 'this sentence no verb'. There's a big difference between being able to find a way out of a given paradox and in being able to generalize that insight to makes statements about computability (or proofs, in the context of mathematics).
- ubernostrum 17y agoDepends on what sort of metaphysics of propositions you accept, whether you want to deal with an extensional or an intensional language, and a whole bunch of other stuff that generally only philosophers and some mathematicians have cared about. If you're interested, though, let me know and I'll see what I can dig up for you from back when I was studying this stuff.
- BerislavLopac 17y agoOh, come on, guys. Those who read www.thedailywtf.com are well aware that a logical statement can be: a) true b) false c) file not found
- stan_rogers 17y agoAnd that (the Humpty Dumpty reading, wherein the meaning and intent of words is subordinated to the reader's desire) is an assumption of the sort one has to make in order to "prove" that it is fundamentally impossible for a statement to be self-contradictory. Such statements are always introduced in intellectual discourse as self-referential; that is, the words "this", "I" and "me" are identities of the statement by definition. There is no ambiguity of the sort that one might find in Magritte's "Ceci n'est pas une pipe", where one may chose to infer "ceci" to refer to any of the depiction of the pipe, the painting as a whole, or just the written statement (none of which is a pipe as such). Think of it this way: If a stranger were to approach you on the street, say, "I am a liar," then walk away, you'd likely think that the fellow is a little depressed and perhaps a bit remorseful about a habit of lying whenever it suited him. If the same fellow, in the same circumstances, had instead said "I am lying to you right now" before wandering off, you're left with two choices -- seriously psychotic or smartass. People are reluctant to think of systems such as language and mathematics as seriously psychotic, so a cottage industry has sprung up trying to prove that these systems are merely smartasses out to infect our internal source code repositories with Brainfuck or some other Turing tarpit. It doesn't matter how many times one invokes the demons of deconstructionism, these paradoxes are and will remain very real.