3 ms·
It seems to me that endless copyrights, or perhaps copyrights that last until the death of the creator, are the only logical extensions of having any copyrights
by baddox 13y ago
It seems to me that endless copyrights, or perhaps copyrights that last until the death of the creator, are the only logical extensions of having any copyrights at all. If "artists deserve to be paid for their work," and "copyrights are the only way to make sure artists get paid for their work," then why should the artist stop deserving to get paid after some arbitrary number of years?
- hsitz 13y agoMaybe because most works generate revenue, if at all, in the few years immediately following first publication, so a period based off that is all that's necessary to encourage creation? Maybe because if a copyright holder has a family and dies 6 months after creation of the work it seems wrong to prevent the family from profiting off the work? Maybe because when limits on periods are required in the law there is often no absolute reason to prefer one of several good candidate periods over another, so the ultimate decision is always in some sense arbitrary? Note that in the U.S. patents are generally granted for a period of 20 years. Why do copyrightable works require or justify more?