4 ms·
Either Adobe open sources Flash, or it's as good as dead. And one had to start worrying about Flash dying earlier. It's somewhat late for such concerns now. For
by shmerl 13y ago
Either Adobe open sources Flash, or it's as good as dead. And one had to start worrying about Flash dying earlier. It's somewhat late for such concerns now. For example newer versions of Flash aren't even released for Linux anymore for a while. Isn't it a clear indication that it's time to move on?
- Jasper_ 13y agoAdobe actually wants to open-source Flash, but they're concerned about the security impact. The source would make it a lot easier to find a 0day and infect somebody's computer. They actually have trusted customers that they share the Flash source code with: Google and Mozilla both have it, for instance.
- shmerl 13y agoSecurity by obscurity is not a real security anyway. So I don't think open sourcing would hurt it. If anything, it can even improve security, since more researchers would be able to review it.
- CamperBob2 13y agoPatent trolls are also a big disincentive to open-sourcing one's commercial products.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoIs that something with any real evidence behind it or just Microsoft FUD? I have a hard time believing that patent trolls would even be interested in hiring engineers to read source code. Their business model is to send you a threatening letter with a settlement demand which is noticeably less than the cost of vindicating yourself in a courtroom. What do they care anything about what the code actually does, so long as they can maintain the charade sufficiently to make the threat credible?
- Jasper_ 13y agoThese are Adobe's concerns, not mine. I don't work for Adobe, but I'm familiar with Flash and have talked to Adobe engineers before. And it's not an easy call to make: keep in mind how many computers have Flash installed. If open sourcing the project would double the rate that vulnerabilities get found and exploited, that's a real problem for Adobe. Trusted partners already have the Flash code and report security issues.
- mikeash 13y agoI think that depends on just how many security flaws are in the codebase. If the codebase is so full of bugs that Adobe wouldn't be able to keep up with the flood of exploits when it's open sourced, they're better off keeping it closed for now. Basically, open source makes it easier to find security bugs, but that's no help if you already have your hands full with the ones you can find yourself. I don't know if Flash is in that state, but it kind of sounds like it.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>Either Adobe open sources Flash, or it's as good as dead. It's already dead, it just hasn't hit the ground yet. Imagine that the features that make Flash useful were added to browsers without the need for a plugin. That's what's been happening. The process hasn't completed yet, but it will, give it time. It takes time because standards bodies move slowly etc. etc. At that point, who prefers Flash to the standard? Nobody. Not developers, not users, not even Adobe -- who is only in it to sell software, which they can sell just as well if the output is HTML as if the output is SWF. It even benefits them to kill Flash (the plugin), because then they don't have to maintain it anymore. Everyone would be happy to have Mozilla do that part instead. So you say, fine, open source Flash, make that the standard everyone is converging on so we don't have to wait. Ignore for a moment the probable licensing issues Adobe would have in doing that if they've licensed anything from anyone for use in Flash. Ignore the wailing you would hear from Hollywood if the "DRM"/obfuscation they think they get from Flash were to be made transparent by releasing the source code. Who actually wants the plugin? The features that Flash provides would work better if they were properly integrated into the browser. But doing that requires you to rewrite the code as part of the browser instead of a plugin -- which you want to do anyway because as we all know the Flash plugin is a dungeon of sorrow and despair. But if you have to rewrite it in any event then what good is having it? You just throw it away and start over as you would anyway. So Flash is dead. All that releasing the code would get you is to extend the period of time that we spend lugging around its corpse in the passenger's seat pretending it might wake up again. If you really want to do something productive, find a feature in Flash that isn't in HTML and submit a patch implementing it to Mozilla and Chromium. Shipping code wins -- implement it and people will use it, and implement it the same in two major browsers and the other will follow and standardize it. The sooner that happens the sooner Flash can disappear and make everyone the happier for it.
- shmerl 13y agomake that the standard everyone is converging on so we don't have to wait No, I don't see any benefit in it as a standard. I only said it's the only way for Flash to exist in the future. It doesn't mean it has to be used with that. In vast majority of cases Flash now is used to decode video. HTML5 video suffers from crooked companies like Apple and MS who refuse to adopt open standards. When situation will improve, Flash will surely hit the ground for good. And to clarify, I don't think there is a point for Flash to continue.