7 ms·
Ways You’re Making Your Employees Less Productive
- ffrryuu 13y agoProcess, management, de-empowerment, hiring B people.
- smtddr 13y agoOf course, it's more complex than that. Surely you're not suggesting to completely eliminate all four of those. They each have a certain value in their own way.
- logicallee 13y agoYeah all the YCombinator startups that are killing it started with 2 guys/girls, then proceeded to add on a lot of process, management, de-empowerment, and hiring B people. That's how they made it - look at any of them!
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoIn fact, that is exactly what happens in most startups due to the lack of experience on the part of the founders. Mature companies have already made those mistakes. Startups in the early growth phase are often some of the worst places to work until they figure out how to operate at scale. You would be surprised how many young companies fall straight into old school corporate habits as soon as they grow past 20 employees.
- jiggy2011 13y agoSomebody has to hire us "B people".
- DrJokepu 13y agoI understand that you are using self-deprecation to poke fun of the elitist parent comment, but the fact is that nobody is required to hire "B people".
- jiggy2011 13y agoThere aren't very many "A people" to go around, most people who think they are hiring A people are hiring B or C people. Most of the useful work on the planet is done by B or below people.
- smtddr 13y agoI'm not clear on the definition of an A person versus B person. But if I apply my assumptions, experiences and observations to this situation, I would argue that you'll have to hire B-people because A-people have too much pride and ego to do B-work; a.k.a. whatever work they deem is below them. If Google was really filled with only Ph.D. holding A-people with engineering degrees and published books under their belts, no work would ever actually get done ;)
- nikatwork 13y agoI see this comment all the time on HN. This is the reality of the corporate hiring world versus the Valley: 1) You are hiring for boring but important projects 2) There is a limited pool of local talent 3) The org will have banded salary caps 4) Differentiating A talent from B players is not a solved problem It feels great to say, "Just hire A graders! Problem solved yo!" The corporate world does not work like this.
- misterjangles 13y agoOf course everybody would like their team to be all "A" level players. But unless you work at an elite startup with a tiny team and buckets of cash - you have to learn how to build a team from players of all levels. An all "A" team is not realistic for most companies, and even if you did assemble one they won't all stay forever. If you have a good process and thoughtful management then you can get great results from "B" level players. I see that as a great challenge as a manager - to get the most out of the whole team.
- 13y ago
- bonemachine 13y agoMy faves: 4. Pretending To Know 3. Not even attempting to communicate (or "communicating" through hints.) Particularly in high-pressure situations. 2. Microcontrolling. (By which I mean: grabbing control of some low-level aspect of the project, or of the team communications, thinking you know better than the team member who already took action to such an extent that you don't need to explain your actions. See also (1), (2). And my favorite of all: 1. By your very presence. Seriously -- things like overbearing demeanor, poor tact, sexist or jockish language etc can not only be toxic, but instant invitations for your team members to not only begin their job searches immediately, but look forward to the task with vim and glee.
- jiggy2011 13y agoNumber 2 is what Joel Spolsky calls "hit and run management". "hit and run management because managers tended to pop up unannounced, give some silly order for exactly how they wanted something done, dammit, without giving any thought to the matter, and leave the room for everyone else to pick up the pieces." http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000072.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000072.html This is the most frustrating when you have spent an entire afternoon carefully considering different approaches to solving a problem and figured out all of the non obvious but important edge cases that show why a particular approach won't work to have someone come in and give it five minutes consideration and say "nah, we should do it that way, it'll work out".
- mprovost 13y agoAKA Seagull Managers ("Fly in, make a lot of noise, shit on everything, fly out"). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seagull_manager http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seagull_manager
- famousactress 13y agoI live in San Diego (where a huge Intuit campus is located) and have known lots of people who work there, but none that work remotely with any regularity. I'm curious what #7 (let employees telecommute when they need to) means at Intuit. I wonder what their definition of "need to" is.
- markanderson 13y agoI see the article is from Alison Green of Askamanager.org, a professional writer not affiliated with Intuit. Looking at their other content it appears most of it is professional done by some pretty well known authors from NY Times, Forbes.com, etc. Pretty good stuff. Subscribing.
- yzap 13y agoI worked at Intuit in the bay area for about three years. During that time, I knew many people that would work from home regularly 1-2 times a week. I really preferred working on my multi-monitor setup in the office (I lived easily bikeable three miles away from campus), so I never took advantage of the liberal WFH policy while I lived out there (except for when waiting for cable man visits and the like). After three years working in Mountain View, my girlfriend got into a PHD program at the University Wisconsin and Intuit was A-OK with me working remote. So I packed up all my office gear, got issued a Desktop VPN VOIP phone, and moved to Madison, WI. I did that for about two years before I left to cofound a company with several longtime CS friends here in Madison. So, yeah, Intuit is pretty liberal with telecommuting when it fits the situation (as long as you don't abuse it). : )
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIt seems self-evident to me that if you treat experienced, talented, highly paid developers like minimum wage workers then you're either losing out on much of that experience and talent or you're paying far too much.
- pasbesoin 13y agoHypocrisy. Telling employees it is "up to them" while in reality giving them no resources, control, nor choices -- or none that matter, i.e. not really listening and responding to them. Aka "passing the buck".
- jonnathanson 13y agoExactly. I have had this boss, unfortunately. To a t. He'd tell me a project was "completely up to me," that I was "the leader" of it, and that I should feel "totally empowered" to make decisions, allocate resources, etc. He proceeded to show up to each of my project meetings, often late and out of context, disagree out loud, offer unsolicited opinions, micromanage, and badger me into implementing his ideas -- thoroughly undermining any ostensible authority I had over the project, or reversing any progress the team had made up to that point. His ideas came in two flavors: a) completely off-the-cuff and unconsidered, and b) foregone conclusions (what the team and I liked to call his "pet" ideas). Both of these types I had to entertain, and often to implement. And of course, when it came time for him to chip in with the execution in any way, or even to explain his rationale, he'd bolt for the door. Essentially, I was his task rabbit. If a project went to shit, he'd claim it was "mine" and be able to pass the buck accordingly. If it went well, he'd swoop in and scoop up the credit. Attempts to talk to him about it in one-on-ones went nowhere. Attempts to "check in" with him prior to meetings, in the hopes of pre-selling him on a plan, went nowhere. He'd be dead set on a pet idea, and it was my job to "totally lead" the execution of that idea. Bosses like this are toxic. I'm not sure I've ever found a good way to work successfully with this personality type. If this describes your boss, figure out how to transfer, how to escape, or how to develop Vulcan-like mastery over your anger and your pride. Some tigers can't change their stripes, and I can guarantee you that this kind won't.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- misterjangles 13y agoI have been on both sides if this, although as a boss I have always tried to give others the glory and take the heat. Also I probably do swoop in with ideas, but I don't leave people high and dry to figure them out. The solution is really to speak up for yourself. You may have to remind your boss that he put you in charge. I can be a tough boss but I will listen to any argument and will be glad to be proven wrong or told that my idea is going on the list for later. But - you must convince me that your idea is better, or more practical, or that you at least have thought things through. I know it can be tough because bosses tend to be older and, maybe in some cases wiser (but not always). As the boss your pressure is to keep a team moving forward and so you grow used to delegating. I had to be reminded that I gave somebody a project once and I felt really bad about not letting him do it on his own. I really just didn't want to see him fail, but I was micromanaging. It was difficult for him to bring it up to me but I was glad he did and we got past it. I'd say - face it head on. If the boss still won't listen, then start figuring out another employment opportunity.
- bane 13y agoFun pop-psychology on hiring people by 1-10 ratings and what it says about the hiring manager. If you hire an n, where 0<=n<=5 then you must be an m where n<m and 1<=m<=6. Because incompetent people want to hire more incompetent people to make them look good and secure their position in the organization. If you hire an n, where 6<=n<=7 then you must be an m where n<=m and 6<=m<=7. Because reasonable competent people don't want to bring failure into an organization, but don't want anybody showing them up. If you hire an n, where 8<=n<=10 then you must be an m where 8<=m<=10 and there is a high probability that n>=m. Because truly competent people want to bring in other truly competent people and aren't threatened by people with higher levels of competency, and even might welcome it.
- mryan 13y agoInteresting - sounds like a more detailed version of "A's hire A's, B's hire C's".
- RougeFemme 13y ago#5 is one of my favorites. One of my co-workers refers to one of our managers as a "drive-by" manager. He agrees with the concept of carving out chunks of time - even remotely - to focus. In reality, if you are on-site, he is constantly "driving by" with things that could have waited or been communicated via IM/email.
- JoeBlog 13y agoAllowing unrestricted Internet access. Seriously, whitelist only the domains necessary for the job. If it's programming, I would only recommend specific StackExchange sites, GitHub, and any documentation sites. Some people have horrible self control and will waste all day on the Internet, despite that they may be great programmers and can actually get stuff done if they put their mind to it. It's not even that the job is boring, it may actually be exciting, and their project may be something they really enjoy, yet the distractions are still more entertaining to them. Like reading and interacting on Hacker News.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- EdwardDiego 13y ago> Allowing unrestricted Internet access. On the contrary - filtering my internet indicates that you don't consider me capable of self-regulation... I prefer being treated like a responsible adult - responsible for my great code or my slacking off, whichever I choose. I greatly value this level of respect from employers.
- skeletonjelly 13y agoIf they're going to slack off I'm sure they'll find another way.
- andrewkreid 13y ago>> Seriously, whitelist only the domains necessary for the job Ok. How _exactly_ do you plan to whitelist the domain of every search result for every query of the form "How do I do [technical task] in [technology/language]"? I can find at least seven of these in my browsing history for the past week that aren't SO. Not being able to access them would have added hours to the time required to finish the tasks they were related to.
- RogerL 13y agoYes, because there is certainly no way to browse the web via your phone's hotspot! I think this is called shutting the barn door after the horses have fled.
- andyjohnson0 13y ago"8. Insisting on doctor’s notes in order to take sick days." Is this common in the US? Even for a single day? I'm in the UK and my contract states (from memory) that I have to get a doctors certificate after five contiguous days of sickness. I'm fairly sure thats been the same for all other companies I've worked for.