4 ms·
"Only the scientific method can give us reliable knowledge" Wrong. Math also gives reliable knowledge and has nothing to do with the scientific method. Also r
by raverbashing 13y ago
"Only the scientific method can give us reliable knowledge"
Wrong. Math also gives reliable knowledge and has nothing to do with the scientific method.
Also remember that science had proved light was a wave and not a particle. Until it was disproved. (Amongst other examples). And several "scientists" forget that what's 'true' today for science is the best answer from what's know today, but that may change in the future.
But more commonly, science is a concept. What we have contact with is the result of the application of that principle by researchers, which usually is close to the ideal thing, but sometimes is not.
"There is proof that X is correlated with Y (cites study).
Correlation does not prove causation"
This is important, and I would bet on a lot of studies implying the causation where there's none.
- daemonk 13y agoScience in its purest form is simply using our fundamental capacity for logic to, as objectively as possible, perceive the world through our senses and instruments. We make observations at low resolution to make correlations and at high resolution to deduce causation. Do a lot people make wrong conclusions based on theirobservations? Yeah. But that doesn't make the scientific method wrong. It just mean it's very hard for scientists to completely remove themselves (to be objective) from their results sometimes.
- fluidcruft 13y ago> "Only the scientific method can give us reliable knowledge" Did you read the topic sentence of the paragraph you excerpted that from? You're failing to address it in the context of "knowing whether a treatment is effective". > And several "scientists" forget that what's 'true' today for science is the best answer from what's know today, but that may change in the future. Which was addressed in #18
- protonfish 13y agoI don't think you have a clue what science is and I doubt I can thoroughly correct you in this short space but I'll give it a shot. Math is a language - it has no inherent analogies to reality. It can be used to describe a natural phenomenon, but the validity of this description must be tested through experimentation. If it is not disproven, a mathematical (or other type) model can be a useful tool in simulating the observable world.
- raverbashing 13y ago"Math is a language" Beyond the fact that languages can be described in a mathematical way, yes. And science is a philosophical concept. It also does not have any formal verification towards the validity of it. It has certainly has had a practical success, but one could say that is even anecdotal.
- protonfish 13y agoA better way to say it is that math is a formal system - It is a set of symbols and rules for transforming those symbols. It is often mistakenly believed that it is the one and only universal system. But not long ago we used Roman numerals and did not even have calculus. (How Archimedes did his work I can't imagine.) What we consider modern formal mathematics is only one possible system and there is no reason to think that a completely different one would not do the same job just as well. You use the terms "verification" and validity." These terms are used in symbolic systems to describe formulas that are well-formed (follow all the rules of their formal system) or equivalent to another formula (derivation) or a legitimate combination of multiple formulas (proofs.) Unfortunately, no matter how much you "prove" a pure mathematical theorem, it will never mean a darn thing about our observable universe. That is a job only science can do.