3 ms·
If he's frustrated with app engine, he hasn't built a complex system and had to refactor it in order to scale -- app engine puts these decisions in your lap up
by grandalf 17y ago
If he's frustrated with app engine, he hasn't built a complex system and had to refactor it in order to scale -- app engine puts these decisions in your lap up front, not after you get on techcrunch.
This is my favorite aspect of app engine -- you can be confident that if you follow the best practices your app will scale. Try that with a rails or django app.
Sure you can scale Rails horizontally, but what about Sphinx? What about Mysql? If you're lucky your app will scale in a way that the "simple" methods of scaling these tools happens to work. But what if it's not?
Before long you'll wish you'd just been forced to make all requests complete in under 4 seconds initially :)
These are problems that you as a coder can address directly with app engine. Without it, you have to wear all sorts of sysadmin hats and hope you're not doing something foolish.
- wmf 17y agoBig design up front is bad, but big scaling up front is good?
- grandalf 17y agoNot at all. Consider Rails: Convention over configuration. The same applies to app engine, only with a slightly more restrictive set of conventions.
- kragen 17y agohe hasn't built a complex system and had to refactor it in order to scale You've heard of the C3 project?
- grandalf 17y agoI've heard of it. I'm curious about your thoughts in relation to this topic.
- kragen 17y agoI think it was a complex system, they spent a lot of time refactoring it to add features, and some anecdotes suggest that performance (so it could scale to all of Chrysler) was one of the major feature categories that they were working on — and kind of failed on, I think. And it's the project Beck's best known for.
- jcapote 17y agoI think if you follow best practices with any platform you'll achieve great results.
- jshen 17y agoNot really. If you normalize all of your data according to typical relational best practices you will often later find that you need to denormalize it to scale.