6 ms·
He receives $1,200 from Social Security and a $600 a month pension from his last corporate job. When the 2008 financial crisis hit, what little Palome had save
by cperciva 13y ago
He receives $1,200 from Social Security and a $600 a month pension from his last corporate job.
When the 2008 financial crisis hit, what little Palome had saved -- $90,000 -- took a beating
He then sold his New Jersey home for $180,000, kept what he needed to quickly pay off his credit card debt and divided the rest among his children so they’d have down payments for their own homes.
Ok, so he retired with $270,000 of assets plus $1,800 per month from private and public pensions. Buy a life annuity (as a 65 year old male) with the $270,000 and you're getting around $1,600 per month. That yields a total income of $3,400 a month or $40,800 a year, which is considerably above the national median income (around $28,000/year according to wikipedia).
As I see it, the problems here are entirely of his own making:
1. He gave away 2/3 of the wealth he should have been relying on during his retirement,
2. He gambled his remaining assets in the stock market rather than making investments suitable for his demographic (mostly bonds) or buying an annuity, and
3. He picked up expensive habits when he was younger -- he takes regular flights to visit relatives and occasional vacations.
(And I suppose I could add 4. He should have saved far more money before retiring -- but my point is that even at the point he retired he was in decent financial shape.)
- kevingadd 13y agoAre you saying he shouldn't have supported his children, and that he shouldn't go see his relatives? That's fucked up.
- freiervogel 13y agoAre you saying it's wise or smart to cripple your ability to retire by lavishing your children with your life's savings? That's what this guy seems to have done. And now his situation is a bit f'd up.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoI may be wrong but I'm guessing he's not a parent. For most parents a choice between yourself and your children is no choice. He's accepted a level of financial hardship to be, or at least feel like, a good parent. I see no issue with that.
- Shivetya 13y agoThe open question is, will the children reciprocate?
- tls 13y agoParenting is not about quid pro quo, improving his childrens livelihood is his investment.
- NovemberWest 13y agoIt isn't quid pro quo but it shouldn't be martyrdom either. I think cutting your own throat for your kids teaches them something bad, not something healthy. (Yes, I am a parent, a very devoted one in fact.)
- ArtB 13y agoI think of it as paying forward what your parents gave to you. I help my parents, but I fund my child and expect him to do the same.
- NovemberWest 13y agoPaying it forward and cutting your own throat are not remotely the same thing.
- tls 13y agoI wasn't speaking to that, it is of your interest as a parent to 'invest' into your child, be it time, knowledge etc... (honestly I never come here to read the articles, I touch the headline and gauge the article by its comments, so I 'maybe' offbase when declaring what I think.) Regardless, you know as well as me - once you walk down that path no one knows it better then yourself.
- 13y ago
- rodedwards 13y agoAre parents in the US obligated to give their children downpayments on houses? Food, shelter, and education is looking after your kids. Giving them cash to buy houses is above and beyond, and I don't think he should have felt morally obligated to do so as your comment implies...
- ams6110 13y agoIt varies. Some parents want to help their kids buy their first house. Some feel they should save for it on their own. Probably depends a lot on what their own parents did for them.
- sanswork 13y agoChildren don't need down payments at the expense of making their elderly parent work for minimum wage long after "retirement".
- ams6110 13y agoOne of the things that most financial planners and guides will tell you is "save for yourself first." Worst case, your children can work, borrow, do a military enlistment, etc. to pay for college. There are a lot more ways and a lot more time to pay for college than there are to make up for insufficient retirement savings.
- FfejL 13y agoThe other way to look at this is a guy smart enough to rise to VP of Marketing at a major corporation and make in the low six figures isn't smart enough to manage his own retirement savings. He's a VP of Marketing. Why is it that we expect him to know how to manage a retirement fund, even if it is his own? The wide-spread end of the pensions system and the rise of 401(k)s is going to be a disaster as more and more Baby Boomers retire.
- rb2k_ 13y agoBecause it's not very hard. Probably a lot easier than most of the things he coordinated in his job. I'm not American and I still know what to do: 1. Do montly investments in a few cheap ETFs (S&P 500, Emerging Markets, MSCI World) within your 401k 2. Once you get closer to retirement, roll most of the money over to more secure asset classes like bonds 3. done
- HarryHirsch 13y agoIt's right there in the article: The median 401(k) balance for households headed by people aged 55 to 64 who had retirement accounts at work was $120,000 in 2011. This is a fact. No matter how easy saving for retirement is, it's a fact that the majority of Americans have retirement savings that are utterly insufficient. I have no idea how this will play out.
- rb2k_ 13y agoGermany has a state run retirement fund that gets deducted from you paycheck (about 19%. split between employer and employee). That mostly solves that problem, but leaves people like me that would like to handle retirement savings themselves a bit annoyed.
- RandallBrown 13y agoThe US has Social Security which is basically a state run retirement. The problem is that it's funded by the people currently working. This worked out great when there was a surplus of workers. Now that less people are working than are retiring, the social security funds are in danger of running out.
- asabjorn 13y agoMany articles on retiring baby boomers have made the point that most of their assets are tied into their home, and in this case it seems like that was true as well. I wonder what the social and economic implications are of baby boomers needing to sell of their house to free up assets. Maybe generational homes will become common again? Maybe housing prices will become sane again?
- Tichy 13y agoThe article mentions that he actually has enough money to live on, but works to get extra perks, like flights to visit his children. I suppose he is also a "protestant work ethic" kind of guy who can't stand not working.