6 ms·
Google Wave “is anti-Web”
- notmyname 17y agoOzzie may be right, but only if one tries to implement Wave on top of the web. Sure the interface may be on the web (for some Wave clients), but the underlying protocol, from my understanding, works along side http. Similar to how smtp works along side http even if the user interface is on the web. Google's demo was the possibility, and, yes, it was a shiny system, but I don't get the impression that Google is trying to sell that system. They are pushing the underlying architecture and protocols. Their demo was made up of several "independent and interoperable implementations of services from toolkits of foundational technologies." And the "foundational technologies" is the Wave protocol.
- fizx 17y agoIM is "anti-web" too, and its doing fine. While the Google Wave client may be too much, the open wave protocol represents an improvement over http and im protocols in use today. I'm sure that it will find its niche(s), and perhaps become mainstream when it finds its killer app (which may or may not be from the big G).
- TallGuyShort 17y agoI'm not arguing - I'm just curious, but what makes you say that IM is "anti-web"? Because it's private? Or because the current maintstream protocols have adopted too many features?
- jmillikin 17y agoIMs communicate over their own protocols, such as XMPP or OSCAR, not the Web.
- sp332 17y agoThe web != the internet. IM uses the internet, but is not part of the web because you can't link to an IM. Four principles for being pro-web: 1. Use URIs as names for things 2. Use HTTP URIs so that people can look up those names. 3. When someone looks up a URI, provide useful information. 4. Include links to other URIs. so that they can discover more things. (From Time Berners-Lee's essay on linked data: http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/LinkedData.html http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/LinkedData.html )
- axod 17y agoSo email is anti-web? Skype is anti-web? I don't quite see why anti-web is a bad thing anyway. Why does it really matter?
- stevejohnson 17y agoExactly. You have just stated the main reason why this article is wrong.
- sp332 17y agoEmail is not indexable (I mean by search engines) and not linkable, and therefore one cannot usefully add to the amount or quality of information on the web by email. It doesn't matter how relevant your email would be to someone else; if they're not on the TO: list, they're not going to get the data. Even if you put a URL in an email, there's no way for the web to represent the relevance of the email to the linked page. Also, you can't link from one email to another. I'm not saying email is bad, it's just not part of the web.
- bad_user 17y agoEmail is not indexable Sure it is, like any other text-based document. and not linkable Well, it does have a reply-to header that's used to construct the tree of the conversation. Other than that public mailing-lists are exposed on the web. one cannot usefully add to the amount or quality of information on the web by email Email is good for private conversations. And for public conversations, whenever I search something on Google I often find answers from mailing-lists, exposed through a web interface. That's pretty much as part of the web as it can be.
- crux 17y agoThe very fact that email needs to be pumped through a web server before it enters that workflow somewhat proves the point. Email is not linkable or indexable before you turn it into a web page. Therefore, it is not a web technology.
- tlrobinson 17y agoI think his point is it's "anti-web" but who cares? The internet is not just about the web. Saying something is "anti-web" is not necessarily an argument against it by itself.
- arebop 17y agoAccording to the article, Ozzie objects to the way that Wave has sprung almost-fully-formed from Google rather than evolving slowly by the codification of observations about successful implementations. The headline is a claim about what Wave is and not about how it came to be. I'm not an insider and I probably haven't studied Wave as closely as Ozzie['s staff], but it appears to be consistent with web architecture: the interactions are basically stateless client-server, there is a uniform interface for operational transformations, it accommodates caching, and it imposes enough structure to support layering.
- TallGuyShort 17y agoHe makes a good point. After all, that's what the UNIX philosophy is all about - small, well-written programs that do one job well, and can work together easily. I like having a lightweight IM client, and regular email. From what I've seen of wave, I wouldn't like it. I think this articulates very well what I didn't like about it. However, that's exactly what I don't like about a lot of Microsoft's software. Outlook for instance, tries to include every feature you need in your office, and it crashes on me all the time because it has too many pieces. Please note that in saying this, I do recognize that the man they are talking about doesn't seem like the kind to always tow the party line at Microsoft. After all, he said their mindset was "scary" when he got there.
- noodle 17y agoi dunno. maybe its just me, and maybe i haven't read up enough on the plans, but it seems that the concept behind wave isn't as monolithic as its being made out to be here. seems like its a big idea, sure, turning conversations into objects, but its not something that precludes writing smaller programs to do specific jobs with respect to the objects. google is working on the outlook-in-scale type application in order to try and fully display the possibilities of the wave concept, but the open system will (seemingly, to me, at least) allow for apps with specific purposes. sleeker apps to do smaller jobs and use the objects to interact.
- TallGuyShort 17y agoWell I certainly need to learn more about the protocol itself before I can say anything more intelligent on the topic. If anyone wants to join me, I just found this site, which I wasn't aware of, before: http://www.waveprotocol.org/ http://www.waveprotocol.org/
- snprbob86 17y agoHas anyone ever actually used Groove? Or Mesh? They are both awful. I've heard Lotus Notes was even worse. I don't really put much weight on Ozzy's opinion. That said, I think Wave is VERY WEB. Which is exactly why it stands a chance of succeeding where Ozzy's attempts have failed. I looked at the protocol and it doesn't seem all that crazy or complex. Robots can be written in any language as long as they can read and write JSON over HTTP. Gadgets are written in HTML and Javascript and are deployed over the web. It appears that near 100% of the gadgets and robots they demoed are UNIX-style "small, well-written programs that do one job well" and they plugin to a more complex UI. Distributed, micro-kernel applications -- like the web -- do not preclude big ideas and large host apps. Browsers themselves are incredibly complex. If Wave proves to have utility and people use it, I don't see how it could fail.
- reyu 17y ago->"Rather, it is an attempt to foist a fully-formed, complex system onto the online ecosystem, and the Web rejects such approaches." Ozzie's arguments as presented in this condensed article seem vague to me. I'm not sure if he's trying to argue that Google Wave represents the AOL "walled garden" approach. If so, I don't think Wave is comparable.
- mike_organon 17y agoI disagree with that quote by Ozzie. The wave protocol is an extension of an existing IM protocol. The app is a combination and rethinking of existing web concepts (IM, email, and others). This isn't something entirely new. Also, other providers, along with robots and gadgets, do not need to be nearly as complex as the Wave app to participate, allowing more interop than is possible now with the old protocols.
- jmillikin 17y agoI think he's wrong, for several reasons: The services Wave aims to replace -- instant messengers, E-mail, IRC, groupware, Usenet -- are not part of the Web. While there are gateways between the Web and other Internet-based platforms, such as webmail and Mibbit, I'd guess that most interaction remains separate from the Web. Therefore, at worst, replacing these services with Wave is irrelevant to the status of the Web. In a related note, Google itself has released Web gateways for E-mail and Usenet. I do not believe that they have since forgotten what the Web is. Indeed, Google's demonstration video itself demonstrates a Wave <-> Web gateway, in the form of an Javascript-based web application. Second, Ozzie espouses an incorrect view of what Wave is. Based on the information Google has released so far, Wave is -- just like HTTP -- a protocol for communication between cooperating, heterogeneous agents. Aside from implementing Wave, which is merely a set of extensions to XMPP, no additional cooperation is required to write a Wave-enabled application. His statement that "Wave is just too big and complex a system" reveals just how fundamentally he fails to understand it. Here, I take a quote and replace "Web" with "Wave": """As Ozzie described it, the power of Wave lies in the ability of many different developers to build their own, independent and interoperable implementations of services from toolkits of foundational technologies. It doesn’t matter if some of these implementations are very basic and lack the full capabilities of others: what matters is that they can be created easily and interoperate. """ Doesn't it remain true? Doesn't it still make sense? I believe that Wave will be a roaring success, for the same reasons SMTP, NNTP and HTTP have been -- simple to implement, distributed, and not controlled by any single party.
- axod 17y ago>> "simple to implement" I haven't looked into wave in much detail, but being based on XMPP is by no means simple. XMPP is the most over engineered over complex verbose ridiculous protocol ever invented. There were several people saying Jabber would kill IRC years ago. I'm reserving judgement on wave personally, I'm skeptical it'll be able to make a dent. Technically awesome, but I'm not convinced yet it solves real problems users have.
- calambrac 17y agoYou've never seen SOAP and WS-*, then, I guess?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tlrobinson 17y agoPeople seem to forget that the internet isn't just "the web". It's simply not realistic for certain applications to be built on the web (I mean the Wave protocol, not Google's Wave client) And of course this is coming from a top executive at one of Google's main competitors. They don't have a history of saying nice things about Google, Apple, etc.
- adw 17y agoThis isn't my idea, it's my colleague's, but he managed to get it through my thick skull this morning: it's all about the robots. Wave robots can do anything, including publishing from a wave to somewhere else, filtering and parsing, importing content, linking, whatever. They're bidirectional pipelines! And that means they're a fantastic tool for automating things, and what's more, they're easy to explain to people less technical than us mob. Imagine this: "here, i'll copy in the room booking robot", which goes away and reads the wave to book you a room, just as you might copy a secretary into an email conversation if you were lucky enough to have administrative support... Two of the web services I've got most from recently have been Highrise and Tripit, in both cases because I can just forward them stuff and what I wanted to happen happens. Google Wave makes building that kind of app much, much easier. That gets my attention, anyway.
- stilist 17y agoIt seems the age of intelligent agents may have finally arrived. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_agent http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_agent)
- nailer 17y agoWhy do we care what the creator of Lotus Notes has to say regarding the web?
- tybris 17y agoTo summarize, Wave does not kiss.
- billybob 17y ago"That was the verdict of... Microsoft’s top software guru" This may be kneejerk, and I don't know anything about Mr. Ozzie, but try reading it this way: "Google's new web thing denounced by maker of competing desktop things." Even if he's right, it just doesn't sound objective.
- cjoh 17y agoGoogle Wave is Anti-Web says Microsoft? How rich.
- tptacek 17y agoSays Ray Ozzie.
- cdibona 17y agoI was mentally replacing "Wave" with "Azure" and it made the article much more accurate. Just sayin...
- Raphael 17y agoMy foot.