2 ms·
>Consider the stress imposed by 24-hour surveillance. Every moment of your life, you would have to dedicate part of your consciousness to calculating how your a
by Karunamon 13y ago
>Consider the stress imposed by 24-hour surveillance. Every moment of your life, you would have to dedicate part of your consciousness to calculating how your actions may be interpreted by others, some of whom may be hostile to you.
That stress only need exist when the lack of privacy is asymmetrical. When everybody has dirt on everybody else, it gets a whole lot harder to shame someone.
I do find myself wondering what a completely post-privacy society would look like and how/if it would function...
- jarrett 13y ago> When everybody has dirt on everybody else, it gets a whole lot harder to shame someone. That point of view is a credible hypothesis. Despite being a defender of privacy, I too have wondered whether perfect knowledge, perfectly distributed, might lead to some kind of utopia that we can hardly imagine. But that's all speculation. I don't want to count on it. It seems equally plausible to me that the abolition of privacy will lead to a nightmare scenario in which everyone has dirt on everyone else, and it's ruthlessly exploited. Everyone is throwing stones from their glass houses. In that scenario, people would no doubt adapt. They would learn to calculate their every action, every facial expression. This is the source of the stress to which I alluded.
- forgottenpass 13y agoWhen everybody has dirt on everybody else, it gets a whole lot harder to shame someone. Not really. The bounds of what we know about eachother's behavior would just widen from "the things everyone shares about themselves" to "the things everyone actually does." There would still be people who's behavior falls within 1 standard deviation of the average/default/acceptable everyman. And they'll still shame everyone who does not. It also puts a whole lot of glue onto the current social structures. Imagine in a society intolerant of homosexuality with no privacy. Unless the dictator and most of his inner circle are gay, the fact everyone has dirt on everyone doesn't stop him from killing all the gays. When people can't express their secret orientation to eachother in private, there is no way for gradual acceptance to be a thing. Sure it's a contrived example, but someone already wrote about these problems [1] more clearly than I can in a quick break form work. You could argue that this wouldn't be a problem in some societies. Even if we posit that it could work under some conditions, the properties of necessary for it to work are not guaranteed by the abolition of privacy. And they sure as hell don't exist anywhere in the world today. [1] http://www.wired.com/opinion/2013/06/why-i-have-nothing-to-hide-is-the-wrong-way-to-think-about-surveillance/ http://www.wired.com/opinion/2013/06/why-i-have-nothing-to-h...