3 ms·
In public, people instinctively have an expectation of privacy. If you started following people around with a video camera and microphone (or even just started
by nitrogen 13y ago
In public, people instinctively have an expectation of privacy. If you started following people around with a video camera and microphone (or even just started staring at every passerby in the eye without breaking eye contact), you'd get a lot of unhappy reactions.
Having ubiquitous automated surveillance is effectively the same as having someone follow everybody around with a camera and microphone, so the public's reaction to the latter should be used to determine policy with regard to the former.
- saraid216 13y agoThat's not what privacy is. The lack of privacy in public spaces is such because it's unreasonable to have an expectation of privacy. Until we're all cyborgs and have our vision automatically filtered, it's unreasonable to expect that you will remain unseen when walking through a public park. The lack of privacy in public spaces is based on the ubiquity. If you followed someone around, the issue isn't a violation of privacy. It's harassment: the singling out of an individual for exceptional behavior. If you plant a camera and watch everyone, then it becomes a lot more OK. (Still arguably not, but you'd get far fewer "unhappy reactions".)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 13y agoThe lack of privacy in public spaces is such because it's unreasonable to have an expectation of privacy. Until we're all cyborgs and have our vision automatically filtered, it's unreasonable to expect that you will remain unseen when walking through a public park. It's only unreasonable if you say it is. Different cultures have made different decisions with regard to what's socially acceptable to notice about others' behavior in public. It's perfectly reasonable to expect that you will remain unfollowed when walking through a public park, and ubiquitous surveillance is much closer to following everybody than noticing everybody. If you plant a camera and watch everyone, then it becomes a lot more OK. (Still arguably not, but you'd get far fewer "unhappy reactions".) I'd argue this is only because people aren't cognizant of the fact that planting a camera to watch everyone is the same as planting people to follow everyone. People's instincts haven't caught up with the reality that is presented by ubiquitous surveillance, so IMO the right way in this case to decide whether surveillance is acceptable is by analogizing to the closest available cultural and instinctive concept that is still fully functional.
- saraid216 13y ago> ubiquitous surveillance is much closer to following everybody than noticing everybody The issue is still that you're likening surveillance to harassment more than you're likening it to an intrusion of privacy. Based on this argument alone, I'm less inclined to agree with your position, because surveillance isn't harassment. > People's instincts haven't caught up with the reality that is presented by ubiquitous surveillance, so IMO the right way in this case to decide whether surveillance is acceptable is by analogizing to the closest available cultural and instinctive concept that is still fully functional. You realize you're not saying anything more than, "I think it's wrong, so I'm going to go searching for a rationalization," right? I don't disagree that the surveillance we can safely suspect is being done by governmental organizations is probably immoral and should be illegal, but what I'm not hearing is a solid, justified argument for your position other than, "It's icky." You don't even have the fallback of "everyone thinks it's icky" since by your own admission, people don't. I'm not interested in doing that hard philosophical work, personally, so I'll leave you with a suggestion. Privacy, at its root, is really about dignity: its most ancient manifestation is the capacity to relax without tainting one's public image, whatever that image may be. It is from this foundation that all other arguments about privacy are really built. So I'd challenge you to show that ubiquitous surveillance necessarily violates everyone's dignity. I think you'll find that more difficult than you expect, but I don't think it's impossible to come up with a reasonably sound proof.
- nitrogen 13y agoThe issue is still that you're likening surveillance to harassment more than you're likening it to an intrusion of privacy. Based on this argument alone, I'm less inclined to agree with your position, because surveillance isn't harassment. You're still using definitions of privacy violation, surveillance, and harassment with which I do not agree. The distinctions between the three don't have to be drawn where you seem to be drawing them, and both the example I gave and invisible surveillance should qualify as all three. By the way, would you still call it harassment if you never got in the way of the person you were following, never acknowledged your presence, and generally let them go about their business while you were busily recording everything they did? Most people would still be very unhappy. You realize you're not saying anything more than, "I think it's wrong, so I'm going to go searching for a rationalization," right? That's not the case at all. I've raised arguments that appeal to technical people in the past, and users like rayiner jump in with a claim that "common people" just don't care about technical stuff. Now I'm using arguments that appeal to the aforementioned "common people," and you're jumping in to say they aren't technical enough :-). Moreover, I was responding to your specific claim that "it's unreasonable to expect that you will remain unseen when walking through a public park." I'm not interested in doing that hard philosophical work ... but I don't think it's impossible to come up with a reasonably sound proof. I don't expect to conclude the privacy and surveillance debate once and for all in this thread. No doubt Bruce Schneier, the EFF, and others are way ahead of us on formalizing the best arguments.