2 ms·
lutusp has a bit of a bee in his bonnet about psychology and psychiatry. His approximate view is that if a field can't be held to the same evidentiary standards
by jacques_chester 13y ago
lutusp has a bit of a bee in his bonnet about psychology and psychiatry. His approximate view is that if a field can't be held to the same evidentiary standards as experimental physics, it's not a science. Because the two fields are imperfect, they are therefore of course completely and entirely wrong. But fear not! fMRI will save us!
- lutusp 13y ago> Because the two fields are imperfect, they are therefore of course completely and entirely wrong. Wrong? No, just dangerous to children and some especially foolish adults. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebecca_Riley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebecca_Riley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candace_Newmaker http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candace_Newmaker > His approximate view is that if a field can't be held to the same evidentiary standards as experimental physics, it's not a science. That's how any scientist looks at a field that the public trusts to deliver medical care. In fact, because physicists don't have clinics, they are off the hook with respect to this issue, but happen to be far more scientific. http://xkcd.com/435/ http://xkcd.com/435/
- jacques_chester 13y agoI understand that psychology and psychiatry are imperfect, that they have a checkered history, that observability is difficult, that falsification is often unavailable, that the subject of study is itself tremendously capable of introducing confounding factors and so on and so forth. This is all true. Physicists have subject domain advantages that psychologists and psychiatrists do not. Quarks do not self-deceive. Atoms will submit to any torture. Photons behave weirdly, but every photon behaves identically to every other photon. Humans are an altogether trickier subject of study and so the full apparatus of science is not always applicable. What a mature scientist does is say, "OK, let's accept the limits of our field and do the best we can". As better observational tools become available, I expect that psychologists and psychiatrists will change their theories to fit the evidence. They've already been doing that for a long time.
- lutusp 13y ago> ... that falsification is often unavailable ... Yes, and the possibility of falsification is required for science. It's not a convenient option. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory Quote: "The strength of a scientific theory is related to the diversity of phenomena it can explain, which is measured by its ability to make falsifiable predictions with respect to those phenomena." No falsifiability, no scientific theories. No scientific theories, no science. > What a mature scientist does is say, "OK, let's accept the limits of our field and do the best we can". Yes, in science. Psychology is not a science. You do grasp, don't you, that there is a lower threshold below which it's misleading to call something science? This is why the director of the NIMH recently (and reluctantly) decided to drop support for the DSM. It hasn't occurred to psychiatrists and psychologists yet, but when the NIMH dropped the DSM, it dropped them too. This fact may require 30 more years to sink in, in much the same way that the changing status of astrology did in Galileo's time. As serious as astrologers sometimes are, astronomy just works better. These things take time. > I expect that psychologists and psychiatrists will change their theories to fit the evidence. 1. Psychologists don't have theories, they have hypotheses. A scientific theory must be falsifiable. 2. I expect more fiascoes like Recovered Memory Therapy, in which science and evidence were held in contempt. So do many others.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> Yes, and the possibility of falsification is required for science. It's not a convenient option. According to Popper's definition. I don't recall him being appointed the universal lawmaker for science. I mostly recall that he created a definition and then insisted, as you do, that everyone accept it wholesale and hurl into the outer darkness anything that didn't fit his square hole. You're also fond of trying to create false dichotomy between Science, immaculately conceived, ever perfect, and the process of systematically searching for truth to the limits of our ability to observe reality and compound evidence pro and contra which inevitably varies according to subject matter. For example, you pin your hopes to neuroimaging, apparently unaware that subject variability means that eventually that too will rely on (gasp!) large sample studies to produce (oh noes!) statistical results. I presume that you hope by saying "it's not a science" over and over that people will instead decide that it is utter quackery, astrology, akin to crystal healing and chakra-cleansing. Because you never address, or even acknowledge, the median between strong sciences with experimentally-friendly linear problem domains and utter falsehood. Your other favourite debating tactic is to select particular very serious failures, reintroduce them over and over, and then to implicitly generalise them to the entire field for all time. By this standard Galen condemns modern medicine and Ptolemy makes physics a joke. You talk about science, but you refuse to entertain the view that psychology and psychiatry change when the evidence becomes sufficiently resolved. You give only one test for what is a science and ignore all the others. I don't know why you have singled out psychology and psychiatry for this treatment.