5 ms·
The "American Dream" for a lot of my friends nowadays is to relocate to Europe. Copenhagen is a frequently-mentioned destination and my destination of choice a
by busterarm 13y ago
The "American Dream" for a lot of my friends nowadays is to relocate to Europe. Copenhagen is a frequently-mentioned destination and my destination of choice as well.
I definitely felt like there was more opportunity in Denmark than here. Gotta say, I'm a bit jealous.
- tptacek 13y agoWhat kind of opportunity are you referring to? Strip it to nuts and bolts as much as you can. I ask because, for instance, it is harder to run a company in Denmark than in the US. Danish employment law requires months of notice before terminating an employee, and allows termination only with cause. It also appears to be somewhat expensive to incorporate there.
- davedx 13y agoInteresting first criteria for judging a country's economic opportunities: the ability to easily terminate your staff. The "Ease of Doing Business Index" actually removed "how easy is it to fire people" from its indicators because of the controversy. Do you think everybody in the USA would agree that being able to fire people at will is a good thing for the US economy?
- tptacek 13y agoYes. Employment at will is one of the major reasons --- perhaps the major reason --- why it is easier to start a company in the US than in, say, France. In a 3-person company, particularly in knowledge work where headcount costs dominate all other operating expenses, a bad 4th hire is a catastrophic problem: it means 1/4 of your staff is dysfunctional, maybe 1/5th of your operating expenses are being wasted, and as many as 1/2 your existing employees are (a) unhappy and (b) steadily becoming harder to retain. Now imagine not being able to terminate that employee. The Ease Of Doing Business index includes no metrics on employment law at all, not just termination; for instance, employee minimum wage, mandatory holidays, prohibition on contracted employees, prohibition of night work, and maximum work week are also not considered. That they aren't says more about the World Bank index than it does about the importance of these issues.
- mjn 13y agoFor small tech companies in Denmark (I don't know much about other sectors/countries), it's common to hire people on a contract or fixed-term basis initially, something like 3-12 months. Then each side can decide if they'd like to make the arrangement more permanent in the future. For tiny companies with uncertain revenues it's pretty common to just have that be the default mode of employment: when you get 12 months of funding, you hire people for another 12 months, because you can't honestly promise any more than that anyway.
- tptacek 13y agoOh, cool, are you a small tech company person in Denmark? Can I ask: why aren't there more small tech companies in Denmark? It can't be for lack of quality education!
- mjn 13y agoI'm not; I'm a useless academic. :) Many of the students in my program start small game companies, though (I teach in a game masters program), so I follow that scene a bit. A few examples that have come out of the program here: http://conquistadorthegame.com/ http://conquistadorthegame.com/ http://machineers.tumblr.com/ http://machineers.tumblr.com/ http://www.knapnokgames.com/ http://www.knapnokgames.com/ http://gutefabrik.com/ http://gutefabrik.com/ http://duckandcovergames.com/ http://duckandcovergames.com/ http://www.seriousgames.net/ http://www.seriousgames.net/ Most of the small tech companies I know are pretty low-key, though. Besides the game company route, another common one is a small team of 1-3 people making a living doing iPhone app development, that kind of thing. Some congregate around hackerspaces like: https://labitat.dk/ https://labitat.dk/ Not as much of the typical 'startup' route per se, although there have been a few (Unity3d and Bitbucket come to mind). There's also Copenhagen Suborbitals, which isn't for-profit, but is probably the most widely recognized organization to come out of the Copenhagen hacker/maker scene.
- busterarm 13y agoShameless plug for where my friends work, but there are consulting companies like http://bestbrains.dk/ http://bestbrains.dk/ Definitely a small tech company but larger than what was mentioned.
- tsotha 13y ago>Do you think everybody in the USA would agree that being able to fire people at will is a good thing for the US economy? Whether or not they would agree, being able to fire people at will is critical for job creation. In countries where you can't fire people expanding your operation is a much bigger risk. So you avoid hiring people - automation, outsourcing, whatever it takes. To remove this metric from any "Ease of Doing Business Index" is crazy, quite frankly.
- coldtea 13y ago>Whether or not they would agree, being able to fire people at will is critical for job creation. In countries where you can't fire people expanding your operation is a much bigger risk. And who said it should be risk free? Better it being more risky for the employer than the employees.
- tsotha 13y ago>Better it being more risky for the employer than the employees. More risk for me as an employer means I don't hire anyone until I've exhausted every other possibility. When every employer does that there's high unemployment, so if you do lose your job you can't replace it. How is this a benefit to employees?
- coldtea 13y ago>More risk for me as an employer means I don't hire anyone until I've exhausted every other possibility. Doesn't matter, there would be someone else who does hire. Or you thing jobs would dissapear if people dont have a cushy road to business success?
- tsotha 13y ago>Doesn't matter, there would be someone else who does hire. But not as many as there would have been otherwise. It doesn't take a big change in labor surplus to lower wages for everyone. >Or you thing jobs would dissapear if people dont have a cushy road to business success? Yes, jobs disappear as it gets harder to fire people. That's what I've been trying to explain to you. That's why you don't want to make it hard to fire people - it's bad for everyone, but it's especially bad for employees.
- mjn 13y agoThe area where Denmark is most clearly easier, in my opinion, is starting a one-person company ("lifestyle business", freelancing, consulting, etc.). Since most benefits (healthcare, childcare, etc.) are independent of employment, you don't have to worry about all the headaches of losing your benefits when you quit a bigcorp job to go solo. As far as hiring/firing employees, it's not quite that bad. The standard notice is six weeks (on both sides, so employees can't just walk out tomorrow either). Termination does have to be with cause, but changing business conditions or revenues suffices as cause, so it doesn't require proving actual fault on the part of the employee or anything of that sort. The official policy aim is "flexicurity" [1], though it's implemented to varying extents. The goal is to have a flexible labor market where companies can hire and fire as needs dictate (contrary to, say, the French model), and also, but separately, to have a safety net providing income security for workers (through systems like the a-kasse funds [2]). I don't think it's 100% as rosy as the goal, but it's much easier to run a business than in some European countries. It ends up basically tied with the U.S. in the ease-of-doing-business indices I know of. The World Bank's index places it just behind the US (#5 vs. #4) [3], while the Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom puts it just ahead (#9 vs. #10) [4]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexicurity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexicurity [2] Example: http://www.ca.dk/bliv_medlem/dimittend/466.html http://www.ca.dk/bliv_medlem/dimittend/466.html [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_doing_business_index#Ranking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_doing_business_index#Ra... [4] http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking http://www.heritage.org/index/ranking
- tptacek 13y agoMy understanding is that while you have some flexibility on "cause", "cause" gets adjudicated when the employee disagrees, which makes terminating employees risky. I agree that the health care situation in the US is a real problem.
- rhizome 13y agoDanish employment law requires months of notice before terminating an employee, and allows termination only with cause. It also appears to be somewhat expensive to incorporate there. QED
- tptacek 13y agoExtra points awarded for fatuous attempt to reframe the start of a discussion as its ultimate conclusion.
- rhizome 13y agoFatuous maybe, but your criticism is a restatement of the rhetorical use of "QED" itself. Reframing in your preferred terms, framing always being a function of preferences and selection, just so happens here to speak to an instability in the US worksphere that has affected The American Dream (were that it ever existed).
- busterarm 13y agoDamn, you're really holding my ass to the fire here, tptacek. For starters, I should make clear that I was communicating two separate ideas in my comment: 1) that most people I know want to leave the US on an extended-permanent basis. 2) that Copenhagen is a desirable place to live for us. I know only one person who has actually relocated to Copenhagen. Most have actually ended up in Asia, actually. Singapore, Thailand and Japan. Of the European countries that people I know have relocated to, it has mostly been the UK and Germany with a few going to Italy (family reasons). Anyway, as far as "why Denmark", I actually have a handful of Danish friends who work in software. All of them are well paid and have a good quality of life. All of them live within city limits with a ~15-20 minute commute time. All of them either own an apartment or are in a rent-to-own situation and at reasonable rates. They all have _great_ financial situations. I'm from NYC where really none of what I mentioned is possible. I understand that running a business may be more inflexible, but not impossible. I know it's really flexible to start business here in the US, but to do so in a good location in a fantastic city to live in is much harder. I've done a ton of traveling around the US and other than New York, New Orleans is the only other city I've been to where I've said "I would really enjoy living here." That statement comes much easier to me traveling around Europe with Copenhagen standing out the most to me. Quality of life seems to be really good there. Despite the generally pessimistic attitude towards the future that most Danes seem to have, prospects for the future seem really good there. I don't have a similar feeling about the US.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm really not trying to hold your ass to the fire; I'd just rather see the conversation driven towards direct comparisons. Something to consider about your evaluation of Copenhagen vis a vis the US: you're a software developer with enough career mobility to opt into working in Copenhagen; ergo, you are probably very much situated in the 10% of Americans that Tyler Cowan believes will be the US "elite". So: of course you find Copenhagen congenial: you get to pick where you live based on aesthetics and luxuries. (More power to you!) But then: would most of the US middle class be well served by considering a move to Copenhagen? I suggest that they probably would not.
- 13y ago
- coldtea 13y ago>I ask because, for instance, it is harder to run a company in Denmark than in the US. That affects company founders (and mostly of non serious startups, that don't bring much to the job table in the first place). The reverse, which affects employees (which are more numerous than employers by definition) is that it's easier to be an employee in Denmark than it is in the US.
- tptacek 13y agoIt's not that simple. Things that affect employers also effect employees by changing the nature of the kinds of companies that offer employment.
- coldtea 13y agoWe prefer the kinds of companies that offer stable employments and long term businesses in Europe (and "lifestyle business" that is what we call "actual companies"), rather than startups aiming at some acquihire or fast cash-out that benefit mostly their founders.