4 ms·
TLDR is probably a lot more than Second Life impacted the meatspace real estate market, but probably less than Amazon impacted the bookstore market. Sorry if I
by VLM 13y ago
TLDR is probably a lot more than Second Life impacted the meatspace real estate market, but probably less than Amazon impacted the bookstore market. Sorry if I gave it away for anyone, as if this couldn't have been guessed.
One thing not discussed, or I somehow missed it, is the topic of using resources from "online classes" to help traditional classes as a multimedia resource. As an example, there's a good Youtube video series of a Cornell prof's Verilog FPGA course. If you're a bit confused about, say, writing a cellular automata in Verlog or at least the general concepts of doing something like that on a FPGA, well, spin up lecture 3 or 4 or so in the series.
In the long run, a state U could probably just show this prof's videos as the lecture, and hire a TA or two to answer questions for the people who won't pay attention to the video. Those pro videos are actually edited to exclude mistakes, editorial comments, and small talk, which is in some ways unfortunate.
There are a couple classes worth of Gilbert Strang mathematics lectures. I don't really see any point in an amateur trying to lecture on uni level math if you can just watch Strang's videos.
If you want to spend money, "The Teaching Company" has innumerable excellent production quality video lecture series on vaguely academic topics. My public library has them for loan for free.
Another excellent example, the "History of Iran" podcast audio lecture series. Audio recordings of Prof Richard Bulliet teaching a class at Columbia around 2008ish. If you have 100+ hours to burn an amateur's "History of Rome" podcast is pretty good too. There's more out there than just "tech".
I suspect the primary long term effect is the end of the professorial lecture. You'll simply watch videos and at most talk to a TA. I attended a thousand person Calc lecture a long time ago, never saw the prof closer than 100 feet or talked to him personally. My discussion section TA was alright. There would have been no loss replacing the prof with a video cassette of Strang (This was over two decades ago...)
- _delirium 13y agoRe: the prediction, it's possible, but these predictions have been coming out since the '60s at least, and renewed every decade. With the advent of videorecorded lectures, one vision of the future was that there would be no more need for every school to have professors giving local physics lectures, for example, and instead everyone would just watch videos of someone like Feynman. That didn't quite happen, though, even though video lectures have been available for a long time. People do use them for self-study (even the 1964 Feynman lectures, which were only audio-recorded, are popular for that purpose), but typically for personal enrichment type purposes: study outside one's own specialty, weekend study post-college, etc. (I personally don't use them at all, because I use an even older technology for self-study: the textbook.) If MOOCs succeed to a larger extent than video-lectures did, I think it will have to be by providing something other than just recorded lectures, which has been tried many times already.
- VLM 13y agoTrue, but, the interesting new ability is being able to externalize the costs. Don't like my linear algebra lecture, go watch Strang. For free. In the "olden days" we used to pay profs, in some cases cash collection, in exchange for hundreds of pages of photocopied text. Now you can distribute a video, with someone else paying bandwidth both up and down for the cost of putting a URL on the class website or in a class email, which is kind of impressive. There is an amusing meta "loop" that I was watching the FPGA video lecture series at home last week and during a video distributed so motivated students can self-teach, the prof was very unhappily complaining about students being too lazy to look up a simple .pdf datasheet for a temperature sensor so he was providing the information now as part of his notes or something along those lines. So it would be possible that the same students too lazy to google for a simple device datasheet would never be motivated enough to watch a video lecture. There are other alternatives. Profs used to be graded on how well they used high tech multimedia, I could see a prof editing a MOOC-type or EDx-type video down to fill 80% of their class time and then spending most of the class time showing a video and then 15% or so answering questions or expanding upon topics or whatever. I think the parasitic book industry would be very unhappy were they replaced by free web videos, so we can pretty much expect a very expensive video service to appear. Parasites gotta be parasites.
- ghaff 13y ago>I suspect the primary long term effect is the end of the professorial lecture. From a rationalist perspective, this makes perfect sense. But... We've had the technology to do away with 9AM lecture halls filled with sleepy undergrads and replace them with videos from the best lecturers for at least a couple of decades now. And it hasn't happened. Which makes me a bit skeptical.