4 ms·
The rise of online “certificates” and how they threaten traditional degrees
- mathattack 13y agoI do see them hitting at the price point for all but the top schools, as they should. MIT will always have a long line at the door waiting to pay full price. Should Illinois Institute of Technology?
- riggins 13y agoShould Illinois Institute of Technology? it is certainly going to be interesting to watch. I'm a huge fan of MOOC's. However I'd like to see some facts on their impact on employability so far.
- mathattack 13y agoIndeed because having the fancy certificate can help get you into the interview but its skills and personal fit that get you out.
- 616c 13y agoIt is interesting you bring that up IIT, as University of Illinois was one of the first online education programs in the United States, starting in 1997. [0] O'Reilly picked them as partner for the O'Reilly School, ostensibly for this reason. [0] http://www.uis.edu/colrs/about/history/ http://www.uis.edu/colrs/about/history/ [1] http://www.oreillyschool.com/ http://www.oreillyschool.com/ -us/our-history/
- michaelochurch 13y agoThe traditional undergraduate model (also, business school) adds almost no value. I know this is a dickish thing to say, but let's look at it honestly. First, the top universities admit people who least need to attend them. Most admissions officers will admit that they want the kids who don't need to go to a prestigious college to be successful. Now, that's exactly what they should do-- getting the best students means they get the best teachers and researchers-- but it limits their value-add. They'd add more value (even if it'd be the wrong thing to do) by admitting students who actually need them, not the ones who don't. In general, social transformations (education processes, jobs, mentorship programs) converge on a state where those who can get the resources are those who need them the least. That's not "wrong"; it's just the equilibrium. People want to help those who don't need the help. It's human nature. Now, one can argue that their value-add is inherent in what they do with those talented people once they are in, but if you compare the cost of a four-year degree and what is learned to what would be learned with that money, autonomy, and time, I don't think the yield is better. Give a smart person 4 years of extremely high autonomy, and that person will learn a lot and grow. The high cost (in particular, opportunity cost) of university or college education cancels out what is gained (to society, and the person) by attending. What's exciting about MOOCs is that, by removing the scarcity and gatekeepers and rising market tuitions that lead to a zero-value-add equilibrium, we finally are getting to a point where all of this stuff might genuinely add value to the world. That will be an exciting thing to see.
- VLM 13y ago"The traditional undergraduate model" Probably meant to write something like: "The traditional for profit elite/ivy league undergraduate model" The local public unis and public community colleges operate under a different model, eligibility seems solely limited by ability to attend. Which results in a huge remedial issue; there are more remedial math students than "real" math students...
- VLM 13y agoTLDR is probably a lot more than Second Life impacted the meatspace real estate market, but probably less than Amazon impacted the bookstore market. Sorry if I gave it away for anyone, as if this couldn't have been guessed. One thing not discussed, or I somehow missed it, is the topic of using resources from "online classes" to help traditional classes as a multimedia resource. As an example, there's a good Youtube video series of a Cornell prof's Verilog FPGA course. If you're a bit confused about, say, writing a cellular automata in Verlog or at least the general concepts of doing something like that on a FPGA, well, spin up lecture 3 or 4 or so in the series. In the long run, a state U could probably just show this prof's videos as the lecture, and hire a TA or two to answer questions for the people who won't pay attention to the video. Those pro videos are actually edited to exclude mistakes, editorial comments, and small talk, which is in some ways unfortunate. There are a couple classes worth of Gilbert Strang mathematics lectures. I don't really see any point in an amateur trying to lecture on uni level math if you can just watch Strang's videos. If you want to spend money, "The Teaching Company" has innumerable excellent production quality video lecture series on vaguely academic topics. My public library has them for loan for free. Another excellent example, the "History of Iran" podcast audio lecture series. Audio recordings of Prof Richard Bulliet teaching a class at Columbia around 2008ish. If you have 100+ hours to burn an amateur's "History of Rome" podcast is pretty good too. There's more out there than just "tech". I suspect the primary long term effect is the end of the professorial lecture. You'll simply watch videos and at most talk to a TA. I attended a thousand person Calc lecture a long time ago, never saw the prof closer than 100 feet or talked to him personally. My discussion section TA was alright. There would have been no loss replacing the prof with a video cassette of Strang (This was over two decades ago...)
- _delirium 13y agoRe: the prediction, it's possible, but these predictions have been coming out since the '60s at least, and renewed every decade. With the advent of videorecorded lectures, one vision of the future was that there would be no more need for every school to have professors giving local physics lectures, for example, and instead everyone would just watch videos of someone like Feynman. That didn't quite happen, though, even though video lectures have been available for a long time. People do use them for self-study (even the 1964 Feynman lectures, which were only audio-recorded, are popular for that purpose), but typically for personal enrichment type purposes: study outside one's own specialty, weekend study post-college, etc. (I personally don't use them at all, because I use an even older technology for self-study: the textbook.) If MOOCs succeed to a larger extent than video-lectures did, I think it will have to be by providing something other than just recorded lectures, which has been tried many times already.
- ghaff 13y agoI suspect that we're seeing the future of MOOCs here. There will continue to be free low-touch courses which, in many cases, will essentially function as ads for the university. But the real focus will be on online and blended certificate programs that, while inexpensive compared to traditional degrees, will certainly not be free. None of this is a bad thing but I imagine it will be at least somewhat disappointing to those who value MOOCs as free/very low cost educational options or who saw MOOCs as something more disruptive to higher education than they are likely to ultimately be. (It's probably also worth noting that the institutional beneficiaries of this blended model are going to largely be those schools which already have a strong brand and which don't feel threatened by online programs.)
- auctiontheory 13y agoWhat MOOCs (will increasingly) highlight is the limited incremental educational value provided by most traditional educational institutions. The value is in the signals: (1) proving you can stick with something long enough to get a degree, and (2) proving you were good enough to get into a selective institution. I have two degrees from famous universities. I remember very little from my classes, but even at the time, I don't think I learned much that I couldn't also have got from a really good MOOC class. (And from some college classes I learned nothing at all.) And yes, learning from great classmates and making relationships for life is also invaluable, but that's not how most schools market themselves, nor why most students choose to go.