4 ms·
When has it ever been a legal requirement that backdoors be implemented in cryptographic systems?
by chris_wot 13y ago
When has it ever been a legal requirement that backdoors be implemented in cryptographic systems?
- agilord 13y ago"Comprehensive Counter-Terrorism Act of 1991" "Sponsor: Sen Biden, Joseph R., Jr. [DE] (introduced 1/24/1991)" "Cosponsor: [...] Sen Reid, Harry [NV] - 1/30/1991" "It is the sense of Congress that providers of electronic communications services and manufacturers of electronic communications service equipment shall ensure that communications systems permit the government to obtain the plain text contents of voice, data, and other communications when appropriately authorized by law." edit: link is not working, but search for the title, it will open up from something like this: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d102:S266 http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d102:S266:
- ewoodrich 13y agoThis bill died in committee quite a while ago, and the relevant section is available here: http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c102:1:./temp/~c102EXLvfS:e30624 http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c102:1:./temp/~c102EXL...: What is specifically objectionable to you? The quote you provided seems to be the only substantive reference to electronic communication and extremely toothless/redundant. (wouldn't telcos be assumed to be compelled to release "lawful" requests by default?)
- agilord 13y agoIt's not about questioning the law, it's about uncovering the internal works of the law. My previous readings pointed to this bill as one of the earliest regulations that was used by everything in plain text. A nice way to describe backdoors without saying them explicitly, especially if the product claims to be secure from snooping. But what message does it send that the law orders you to screw your customers? This specific bill might have died (I'm sure the patriot act superseded it), but every NSA-related revelation (and the FBI ones ~3 years ago) point in a direction that something similar is still in effect.
- agilord 13y agooops, something deleted the part: [that was used by] US government to access [everything in plain text.]
- ketralnis 13y agoThere are legal requirements that exist that are laws like "If you break into a building, you go to jail". But there are also effective "legal requirements" like "if you don't install this back door, we're going to find a reason to make your life suck in every imaginable way". Or more subtly "we'll fail to forgive this crime that we know about". For instance: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/sep/11/yahoo-ceo-mayer-jail-nsa-surveillance http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/sep/11/yahoo-ceo-... > Mayer said executives faced jail if they revealed government secrets [...] Mayer was asked why tech companies had not simply decided to tell the public more about what the US surveillance industry was up to. "Releasing classified information is treason and you are incarcerated," she said. To quote that reddit thread about that article: > She'd go to jail, but it wouldn't be for breaking the gag order. It'd be because she was suddenly prosecuted for one of the other 1,000 illegal things that any CEO does in a given quarter. Just ask the CEO of Qwest, who blabbed about the NSA surveilling his customers and then was thrown in prison on insider trading charges So, what happened to the former CEO of Qwest: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_of_NSA_surveillance_requests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qwest#Refusal_of_NSA_surveilla... > Qwest was allegedly the lone holdout, despite threats from the NSA that their refusal to cooperate may jeopardize future government contracts [...] Former Qwest CEO Joseph Nacchio, convicted of insider trading in April 2007, alleged in appeal documents that the NSA requested that Qwest participate in its wiretapping program more than six months before September 11, 2001. Nacchio recalls the meeting as occurring on February 27, 2001. Nacchio further claims that the NSA cancelled a lucrative contract with Qwest as a result of Qwest's refusal to participate in the wiretapping program. Nacchio surrendered April 14, 2009 to a federal prison camp in Schuylkill, Pennsylvania to begin serving a six-year sentence for the insider trading conviction. The United States Supreme Court denied bail pending appeal the same day
- 001sky 13y agoShe'd go to jail, but it wouldn't be for breaking the gag order. It'd be because she was suddenly prosecuted for one of the other 1,000 illegal things that any CEO does in a given quarter. Just ask the CEO of Qwest Joe Nacchio was a simple crook. Full stop. Please stop with this meme. His unethical and eventually illegal activity had a long track record. His entire business career and the entire strategy of his Qwest acquisition was, in hindlsight, a giant fraud waiting to happen. It is shitty public policy to have laws that are designed to be (unavoidably) broken. This puts everyone in the position of being a criminal, at the whim of 'selective enforcement'. This is a fair and valid point. The Qwest saga is a completely gratuitious data-point, in this regards. Nacchio was convicted of insider trading in the shares of his own company. This means he witheld material information about the business from public SEC filings. That information was the essentially flawed strategy he had been pursuing was ultimately failing.
- devx 13y agoI'm not sure how it overlaps with other laws, but at least there's this about CALEA: > not only does the law speak about encryption, but it specifically protects the right of companies to build strong encryption for which only the customer has the decryption key into their products. http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2010/09/calea-and-encryption.html http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2010/09/calea-and-encryption.htm... If that's true, then companies could actually use CALEA on their side to implement true end to end encryption, that they can't decrypt themselves, for their customers.
- pivnicek 13y agoOne imagines that this is the reason Lavabit shut its doors.