3 ms·
Naw, OP doesn't 'get it'! First, let's get a leading example of "sad" music, the music for the death of Siegfried from Wagner's opera 'Götterdämmerung', damnat
by graycat 13y ago
Naw, OP doesn't 'get it'!
First, let's get a leading example of
"sad" music, the music for the
death of Siegfried from Wagner's
opera 'Götterdämmerung',
damnation of the gods, the fourth
and final opera in Wagner's
Ring of the Nibelung:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L8wHteSOwW4
Yup, that sounds sad alright! Sounds like
how one feels just hit with the worst
loss in life.
So, why does it make people feel better?
Well, to lead up to the answer, that music
is art as in the common definition
the communication, interpretation of
human experience, emotion. So, that
music communicates the emotion of a big
loss.
Now why would one want to hear that?
Because the music clearly says that
many other people both understand
that emotion and have experienced it;
so, a listener with such a loss and emotion is not alone;
their loss is not nearly the first
such; many others have been there
before; the listener's loss is not unique
and, thus, comparatively not
as bad as they might have feared;
so that's good news for the listener,
and they feel better. That's why!
- teeja 13y agoWell said!
- graycat 13y agoThanks. Not just everyone will understand what I wrote. Many readers will need to listen to the YouTube piece, and for the first few times through that music will be a challenge for many readers. Glad you 'got it'. It's not really psychology but just Art 101. E.g., there's a good reason Wagner wrote that music; it's been darned effective for well over 100 years; lots of people 'get it', enough to keep opera companies going around the world. "You mean you can make such sounds with a symphony orchestra?" "Yes, Virginia!". The music can sound like what it feels like to have a great loss, a dear child, a loved spouse, a company founded that failed, a case of cancer, and much more. Great losses are so common that the music can 'reach' nearly everyone in a large audience.