4 ms·
Last year I visited Germany for the first time and was astounded at how good their English was, despite it being so far from French/Spanish/Italian (which I'm a
by danso 13y ago
Last year I visited Germany for the first time and was astounded at how good their English was, despite it being so far from French/Spanish/Italian (which I'm a little familiar with)...everywhere I went, people were happy to speak to me in English, almost in a slightly condescending way, like "poor American, let me speak your language for you" (and the condescension is well-deserved, IMO).
But wow, the German executives at hand must think Americans are really anti-multi-lingualism if "WRITE IT IN GERMAN" is one of their protocols for obfuscating their fraud.
- _delirium 13y agoIt's getting more common in Europe to be fine with speaking English in a variety of circumstances, not mainly because of Americans, but because it's often the only feasible way to communicate among Europeans. When Danes visit Berlin, they typically speak English, and when Germans visit Copenhagen, they typically speak English there too.
- Locke1689 13y agoYou're aware English is primarily a Germanic language, right?
- TillE 13y agoNot particularly relevant, partly because English has been corrupted by all sorts of influences. There's some common vocabulary, but the syntax and sound are very very different. Look at it from the other perspective: German is commonly (and IMO properly) considered a bit harder for anglophones to learn as compared to Spanish or Italian. The linguistic family is only a small piece of information, and doesn't tell the whole story.
- asveikau 13y agoAs far as I know the fact that "the sound is different" from most European languages is not really due to any "corruption" (like the Norman Conquest) but due to this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Vowel_Shift Quoting from the Wikipedia article linked above: > Vowels of Middle English had "continental" values much like those remaining in Spanish and liturgical Latin. However, during the Great Vowel Shift, the two highest long vowels became diphthongs, and the other five underwent an increase in tongue height. As for syntax I've always heard and read that it sounds very natural to speakers of Germanic languages.
- willvarfar 13y agoI was recently listening to some real Saxon from the dark ages and was struck by how, knowing modern Swedish and English, I could sort of understand it. The big thing about modern German is the word order, which is what makes machine translation so daunting iirc some Google presentations on the subject.
- djrogers 13y ago"and the condescension is well-deserved, IMO" Really? You are to be expected to speak fluently in every language of any country you might visit? Or is it that you are expected to be polite and refuse to visit any country where you can't speak the language? Criminy, there are far too many languages and interesting foreign countries around to be holding yourself to that standard. As english is the most common lingua franca, knowing it allows one to travel freely to the vast majority of the world and communicate on some level with some locals. I am friends with a linguist - speaks 9 languages - if German wasn't one, would condescension still be well-deserved? Would you be condescending to a german/thai/ecuadorian visiting your hometown if they couldn't speak english? Get over your self loathing and enjoy your travels...
- lukifer 13y agoI think OP is referencing the fact that most Americans are monolingual, and that we place a low priority on languages in our educational system. If OP spoke three languages fluently, but not German, the condescension wouldn't be deserved.