4 ms·
That's like comparing losing a lottery by guessing only 3 numbers out of 4 and playing a lottery where you need to guess only one number. These are statisticall
by smsm42 13y ago
That's like comparing losing a lottery by guessing only 3 numbers out of 4 and playing a lottery where you need to guess only one number. These are statistically very different events, since you don't guess other 3 numbers correctly every time - and all fail-safes aren't failing at the same time. That's the point of having many of them - if each of them fails one-in-a-million time, you get 10^24 of security.
- nostromo 13y agoHere we have a sample of 8 safety measures across two bombs with 3 failures. That's not 1 in a million, that's 1 in 3.
- corin_ 13y agoThat's not how probability works, though. I could go and buy a lottery ticket tomorrow for the first time in my life and win the jackpot, it wouldn't mean that the odds of winning are 100%.
- nostromo 13y agoNo, this isn't a problem of probability, it's a problem of "not enough data." Based on this tiny sample, here's the lottery analogy: The lottery will flip 4 coins that have a 37.5% chance of being heads. If you roll 4 heads lots of people die. So, just using this very inadequate sample from a single declassified document, you could estimate that a misfired bomb has a 2% chance of detonation (37.5%^4). Obviously none of us know the real dataset, but my point is simply that it's not comforting that so many safety measures failed. (Which, as it happens, is also the opinion of the author of the original report in the article.)
- corin_ 13y ago> No, this isn't a problem of probability, it's a problem of "not enough data." That was exactly my point, that with such little data you cannot judge the probability.
- smsm42 13y agoActually, according to the article, only one bomb suffered failure of 3 security measures out of 4. The second one just dropped to the ground and disintegrated on impact[1], as any well-behaved non-activated bomb should. Of course, this still leaves uranium and other stuff laying around, but that's another matter - no security system can prevent that, if you have it in the bomb and it falls down, it'll be where it fell. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash