4 ms·
Its an aside, but it always frustrates me to hear about the cuts at NASA and how the budget simply won't allow this or that project when every city in America s
by noonespecial 17y ago
Its an aside, but it always frustrates me to hear about the cuts at NASA and how the budget simply won't allow this or that project when every city in America seems to think it needs an $800mm tax-payer funded arena to "stimulate the local economy."
No, you don't get moon bases, hover cars and cures for cancer. You spent your allowance on football, remember?
- crescendo 17y agoFootball is a very important pastime to a lot of people. Just playing devil's advocate here: can you name one reason why those NASA programs are more important than the football arena, without making reference to your own subjective value system which would be at odds with that of the ardent football fan's?
- Retric 17y agoFootball can and would exist without subsidies. Spending public funds to support private industry is a bad economic decision. Funding space travel on the other hand is something that would not exist without public funds. So it's outside of the effecency debate. “debating gladiator reform while Rome burns…”
- alexgartrell 17y agoFootball can and would exist without subsidies" Yeah, but it'd exist in a different city. City's have to compete for the franchise. It's a supply and demand thing (LOTS more cities than franchises).
- bokonist 17y agoFunding space travel on the other hand is something that would not exist without public funds. So it's outside of the effecency debate. If activity X is to matter in people's lives, it needs to be scalable. To be scalable it needs to be profitable. Since the U.S. government does not operate on a profit motive, the spending on the space program will have as little long term impact as the Zheng He fleets. You should read this article: http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2006/10/how-to-succeed-or-fail-on-frontier.html http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2006/10/how-to-succeed-or-f...
- pj 17y agoperhaps the federal government should fund commercial endeavors in space like they fund commercial endeavors in sports. Lots of people would pay to go to space if they could afford it. Make it affordable.
- philwelch 17y agoThe federal government doesn't fund sports at all. Stadium subsidies are usually a municipal or state matter at best.
- pj 17y agoIt doesn't matter which entity signs the check, it all comes from the tax payers. If the feds weren't paying for the roads, the municipalities would. It's all the same.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- m0th87 17y agoThe Apollo program inspired a generation of engineers that got America on the fast track to victory in the Cold War. Furthermore, NASA has facilitated a great deal of technological and scientific innovation in the past few decades, both directly and indirectly. It is understandably difficult for a politician to justify this value to an apathetic audience when NASA projects are so expensive and they rarely provide any directly observable positive economic impacts. But I don't think it's unfair for noonespecial to assert that the sciences should be prioritized above something whose sole purpose is entertainment. It's interesting to observe how something like NASA can shape a society, public discourse, and the economy in a positive direction. I wish it could be quantifiable to express this value to the voting base, but I doubt it can be done.
- req2 17y agoHow about limiting health calamities caused by hypertension or congestive heart failure? http://ims.ivv.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/news/pressrel/2008/08-043_licensed.html http://ims.ivv.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/news/pressrel/2008/08-... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Spinoff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Spinoff has a nice list.
- pj 17y agodon't forget velcro and memory foam
- alexgartrell 17y agoFrom the point of view of the average taxpayer, deliverables on space missions are too few and far between. When you build an arena (even for non mainstream sport), you make money off of taxing the Franchise, but more substantially off of the local businesses that opened up to serve the fans of the team. Over priced beer, food, and jerseys can make a lot of money if there's a well-liked team behind it all. Plus, people LIKE it. It's a regional pride thing. If you're an average guy, do you want to see three astronauts orbit the earth for 6 months, or go down town with your buddies, get drunk, and watch a game? That's why the average guy votes for the new stadium over NASA.
- jacoblyles 17y agoThere is an eternal tension between elite opinion's love for democracy and its distaste for the tastes of the common man. (We, on the right side of the education and income bell curves, qualify as "elites").
- kiba 17y agoI have a distaste for democracy but not for the common man. As far as I am concerned, democracy is mob rules at best and two wolves and one sheep deciding what to eat for dinner at worst. As for the common man, I don't give a damn if joe sixpack watch football games rather than conduct scientific experiments.
- whughes 17y agoThe common man's opinions determine the elections, though. It's the common man's money that funds NASA and provides grants to researchers. Whether you care or not, the common man is a powerful force in determining the future.
- ckinnan 17y agoThis is wrong. A number of economic studies show that taxpayer-funded stadiums reallocate dollars, they don't help local business on net-- they just increase the value of the sports team. https://www.policyarchive.org/handle/10207/302 https://www.policyarchive.org/handle/10207/302 http://www.cato.org/pubs/regulation/regv23n2/coates.pdf http://www.cato.org/pubs/regulation/regv23n2/coates.pdf Teams and regional pride would still exist without taxpayer-funded stadiums.
- ajross 17y agoI don't want to spoil your rant by throwing numbers on it, but unfortunately that doesn't add up. Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis is (I think) the newest stadium in the NFL. Wikipedia tells me that the cost to taxpayers was $620 million. Let's say that the average stadium lasts 20 years, and note that there are 4 major sports leagues in the US with about 30 teams each, so that an average of 6 such arenas that must be built every year, at a total taxpayer cost of $3.7 billion each year. NASA's budget for 2009 is $17.6 billion. And obviously that's just a fraction of total federal science spending, much of which lives under DoD, DoE, NIH, etc...
- philwelch 17y agoYour numbers are essentially right. Most hockey teams share the basketball stadium, though, and almost all soccer stadiums are shared. But stadium costs are rising: both the new Yankee Stadium and the new Cowboys Stadium cost over $1 billion. However, what makes your numbers very conservative (in terms of overestimating public costs) is that few stadia are fully funded by the public. Most of them are partially funded by the team or the league. (Amusing notes: Montreal's stadium, built for the Olympics and used by the Expos, cost 1.4 billion dollars, but .9 billion was in interest. The world's most expensive stadium, the new Wembley, cost 1.5 billion.)
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoThere is also added infrastructure cost, police cost and more. But you're right that the football budget is less than the Space budget. But why is ANY public money being spent on personal entertainment when it could be spent on progress? another 4 billion a year could pay for a lot of research and scholarships.
- jerf 17y agoThe government doesn't give all of its money to space exploration (or other worthy causes) and spends money on entertainment for the same reason you don't give all your money to space exploration (or other worthy causes) and spend some money (including time) on entertainment. The only way that could happen is if we, as a species, could somehow dedicate all of our time to "worthy pursuits", but we can't. We need downtime and entertainment, and by "need", I mean, need. My first paragraph is not sarcastic. It really is the same reason, just writ large. (This argument is one layer of "why?" beyond the more obvious, but less interesting, point that these stadiums get built because they pull enough in tax revenues in to justify it, or at least so the municipalities assume.)