5 ms·
There are some concepts at odds here. "The measurements included numbers like 78 13/64, and all this multiplying and dividing was to be done without a calculato
by vacri 13y ago
There are some concepts at odds here. "The measurements included numbers like 78 13/64, and all this multiplying and dividing was to be done without a calculator." is not 'rote learning'/'memorisation without rationalisation'. It's directly exercising an ability. I've had a university-level experience reach for her calculator to multiply 0.2 by 3, and when I forbade her from using it, she just stared dumbly at me. That someone of that age can't do that multiplication 'automatically' was quite a surprise, especially given that it was a science course.
Similarly, finding the distances between state capitals exercises research and application skills, and gives a feeling for geographical distances. Doing it in miles and kilometers is helping to get people accustomed to using the Standard International set of units alongside the archaic Imperial units. Likewise, a journalist finding scientific mathematical notation 'unintuitive' doesn't mean it has no merit.
The workload is ridiculous, absolutely, but the content of the homework doesn't sound as useless as the article makes it out to be.
- rtpg 13y agoI spent a lot of time up until high school forcing myself not to use a calculator, because I wanted to work on my mental skills in arithmetic, but I always make a lot of small mistakes, even now. I have a hard enough time concentrating on 'easy' things , please don't ask me to hold numbers in my brain. I am a pretty "mathy" person but mental multiplication is not meant for the human thought process, too much is going on. I say this half in jest, but I've met people with very good mathematical sense (especially in domains such as topology) who are incapable of multiplying 3 numbers without making a mistake. Some people have very few registers, and RAM is really slow.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI have a hard enough time concentrating on 'easy' things , please don't ask me to hold numbers in my brain. I am a pretty "mathy" person but mental multiplication is not meant for the human thought process, too much is going on. That's like saying humans were never meant to run up stairs so you're taking the elevator. In any case, nobody's asking yo to hold numbers in your brain; it's OK to use paper and pencil for your calculations, as generation after generation of mathematicians did.
- vacri 13y agoTo be fair, I don't hold her to be the slightest bit representative, it's just that such a simple mathematical process is just... automatic. I'm not mathy at all - I've abandoned several online crypto intro courses because I can't follow at a reasonable speed when the notation comes out - but when it comes to manipulating single-digit numbers? In her case it was significantly affected by her lack of motivation, but it was just plain odd that such a trivial thing wasn't 'automatic' for someone in a science course (the actual question was calculating V=IR). I had to simplify it with "Well, what's 2x3?", and then, 'given the answer', she could continue.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm enjoying your comments. Regarding the crypto: that's too bad, because a big chunk of crypto involves de minimis math, and that chunk is the most useful; crypto is as much algorithms and computer science as it is math. Consider letting us beat you over the head with crypto challenges sometime; we wrote them in ASCII text, so there's no notation. :)
- vacri 13y agoI forgot that you have the ascii crypto challenges - I'll certainly look into them, ta.
- neltnerb 13y agoI think a good part of the problem is that we learn to multiply and divide backwards. The standard US algorithm involves starting at the least significant digit and working your way up. It is much easier to do in your head if you do it from the most significant digit down. Or learn to convert hard multiplications into easy ones, for instance: 9x27 = 10x27-27 = 243 The other way to do this would be to multiply 9x7 to get 63, and then hold that in your head while you multiply 9x2 to get 18, add a zero to get 180, and then recall the 63 to add to 180. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rgw9Ik5ZGaY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rgw9Ik5ZGaY Basically, to do MSB multiplication it looks like: 27x16 = 27x10 + 20x6 + 7x6 = 270+120+42 = 432 We can do accumulators much more easily from big numbers and then adjusting with small corrections than we can the reverse.
- Someone 13y agoIn my head, what I do in the end is 9x27 = 3^2 * 3^3 = 3^5 = 243 ('everybody' knows that, because of 7^3 = 343) And 27 x 16 ends up being (32 - 5) x 16 = 512 - 80 = 432. And yes, I could be way faster at mental arithmetic if I just did the calculations instead of switching to cuter approaches halfway through all the time.
- girvo 13y agoHuh, so I'm not the only one who goes most-sig to least-sig when doing it in my head. Really makes things easier, oddly enough -- you end up with big numbers with lots of zeroes on the end, and add them to the smaller numbers.
- evincarofautumn 13y agoOur insanely good fuzzy classification skills let us select and continually update a solving strategy. In computing terms: writes to long-term memory are slow, but reads are fast; short-term memory is extremely size-constrained and time-volatile, but fast for both writes and reads. Efficient algorithms for human brains should rely as much as possible on pattern matches, long-term memory reads, and limited short-term storage—exactly the opposite of what you want to do on a computer! It’s no wonder that the polynomial-time multiplication algorithms that work fine on paper aren’t going to perform very well in our heads.
- kaybe 13y agoIt's a well-known fact here that mathematicians can't do calculations. I've had professors in class ask the class to do very simple calculations for their complex examples for them. (Or they get it wrong. A lot.)
- Tichy 13y agoThe driving factor for mathematics is laziness. I didn't even memorize the basic multiplication table (1-10) for a long time, but I remembered some shortcuts (like multiplying stuff by 9 was easy) and got by.
- dsego 13y agoThe multiplication table really bothers me. It's considered to be the least a child can learn in elementary school. And kids that haven't learned to do math mentally just memorise it like a poem. I really don't think this is the correct approach.
- Tichy 13y agoI feel a bit bad for not memorizing it, to be honest. Not sure if there is any other way for learning to multiply? How do you "understand" that 6x 8 = 48? With bigger numbers, then you can apply a system. And as I mentioned I also "cheated" a bit with the basic table. For example I would have remembered that 5 x 8 = 40 and then calculated 6 x 8 = 5 x 8 + 6 in my head, because the multiplications for 5 are easy (half the other factor x 10 +/- 5). But there might not be a cheat for every point in the table?
- dsego 13y agoYou can learn to better comprehend a quantity or amount. So you understand that 6 * 8 is larger than 2 * 8, and then understand that it is actually 3 times that. Another approach would be to always think of multiplication as condensed summation, so 6 * 8 = 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 + 8 = (8+8) + (8+8) + (8+8) = 32 + 16 = 48. I would let my kid write out the summation and apply an analytical approach rather than memorising it blindly. I guess you have to memorise it eventually, but a lot of kids are lost if they fail to recollect the answer.
- comex 13y agoOne comment: there's a difference between mental arithmetic, which is as useful as ever to be able to perform quickly/effectively, and the pen-and-paper variant (which I assume the cited assignment required), which is not. Everyone should, of course, know how to do the latter, but doing long pen-and-paper operations usually doesn't save time over reaching for a calculator, and is error-prone. Unfortunately, schools (at least here) seem to endlessly practice pen-and-paper while giving essentially zero attention to mental arithmetic.
- Tichy 13y agoDo calculators even routinely work with infinite precision (like (sqrt(2) x sqrt(2) = 2)? I guess you could achieve some results with Mathematia or something like that, but I have my doubts about the average calculator. Sometimes it is still useful to do calculations by hand, also to understand what is going on. (Edit: just tested the OS X calculator, sqrt(2) x sqrt(2) works out by chance, but sqrt(200) x sqrt(200) fails).
- mike_esspe 13y agoIt just means you should choose a better calculator From my calculator (Genius Mathematical Tool): genius> sqrt(200)*sqrt(200) = 200.0
- Tichy 13y agoWell that is also wrong, or at least the .0 shows that the calculator is not doing the equations, it is just calculating. It doesn't know know that sqrt(2) x sqrt(2) = sqrt(2 x 2) = sqrt(2^2) = 2 And that is the kind of thing you get to understand if you do the calculations by hand.
- richardwhiuk 13y agoA better way to look at sqrt(2) * sqrt(2) is: sqrt(2) * sqrt(2) = 2^(0.5) * 2^(0.5) = 2^(0.5+0.5) = 2^1 = 2
- yardie 13y agoWhen I got to university the calculus instructor told us "we could use calculators, but they're going to be worthless" sure enough we only had symbols with a few numbers used as filler, but nothing you couldn't work out in your head. ie. (5x+2)^-3n