6 ms·
This is impressive and cool, but I think web-based gaming will never catch on with the 'hardcore' for a few reasons. For one, C++ and the native toolchain is s
by Mikeb85 13y ago
This is impressive and cool, but I think web-based gaming will never catch on with the 'hardcore' for a few reasons.
For one, C++ and the native toolchain is still more efficient. But it mostly comes down to perception and convenience. The perception of web-based games is that they're casual and cheap. And most hardcore gamers like to have a copy of the game on their computer - they paid for it, they want a copy that they can keep (and at least store on their hard drive) for years. They don't want to stop playing a game because the dev decided to end its life...
This is why platforms like Steam, Xbox, HumbleBundle, etc..., still rule for distributing games (both AAA and indie).
- Cakez0r 13y agoAn excellent game could change perceptions though. I'd be more concerned about how easy it would be to reverse engineer a web game compared to a native binary. If it's easy to bot or cheat, any competitive aspect will be ruined.
- girvo 13y agoSC2 is easy to hack and cheat. Blizzard rarely do ban waves. Oddly enough, with this type of game, no hacks are enough to let you beat those who are truly better than you (at least with starcraft!). Kinda neat to be honest. Doesn't stop me yelling at map hackers tho ;)
- jamesgeck0 13y agoConvenience is exactly why this is interesting. I don't buy many games outside of Steam because it's so convenient not to have to back up installers or hunt for a particular XNA version or what have you. There's a low barrier to entry to trying something that runs in a browser. I just navigate to the page, wait for a progress bar, and maybe bookmark the game if I like it. The low barrier to entry is one reason that flash games are still so popular. http://xkcd.com/484/ http://xkcd.com/484/
- pjmlp 13y agoThat is what consoles are for.
- bluntly_said 13y agoNo, it's really not. This is what consoles are trying to become, but they're also a long way off. They're also expensive, dedicated machines. Even assuming this IS what console are for, why in the world are you going to complain about more competition in the market for a good way to distribute games?
- pjmlp 13y agoNo, consoles were always like that. Fixed set of hardware, that the developers could easily target and build their skills. For the gamers, just put the cartridge or disc, and start playing. No need for driver updates, or whatever else might be required.
- CDRdude 13y agoI'm not convinced that web-based is automatically doomed among the hardcore. I think that Quake Live the most popular game in it's subgenre (Arena FPS), and it's still hanging on as an esport, with a slot in Dreamhack as well as weekly tournaments. Granted, Quake Live has the massive advantage of being a resurrected version of Quake 3 Arena--but it does make a precedent in people's minds of a hardcore web-based game.
- nickbarnwell 13y agoQL uses a native binary that you install, no? Like BF3, the only components handled in the web browser are matchmaking, clan management, etc. For the actual matches/gameplay, it invokes the native client
- Narishma 13y agoQuake Live is a native game (that's why you have to install a plugin) that is launched through a web-based interface.
- devx 13y agoWhat does "catch-up" mean? Will they ever be as powerful as advanced as the hardcore cares are today (2013)? Yes, they will be. Will they catch-up to hardcore games of the future (2023?). No they won't. But that's irrelevant. What matters more is if they will catch-up to being "good enough", and that is likely to happen.
- Mikeb85 13y agoI never said catch-up. I personally think WebGL IS good enough to make quality games, I have no issue with it. I just don't think it will catch-on with the gaming public for other reasons. Look at how much resistance there was to Microsoft's 'always-on' feature of Xbox One, to the resistance to DRM that calls home (it is annoying if you're trying to play a game somewhere that you have no connection), and then the requirement that the developer also maintain infrastructure. The current system, where you create something native using a cross-platform toolkit, then distribute it once, and the user has it forever - this is what gamers are used to, and what they like. And I admit, it's nice being able to play games when I have no internet connection. I don't think this paradigm is necessarily the best one, but it certainly has its merits.
- d0m 13y agoWell, I'm a hardcore gamer and I think you're all wrong, no offense. I care for good games. Whether it's from the browser or native, as long as it's addictive and competitive I'll play it. Also, the thing about having a copy is a thing of the past. Think about Starcraft2 that you can download and already have the settings you used on a different computer. Or steam where you download the game and press play. My personal concern with the browser is more about the freedom of game developers to tweak the app as they want. You're very vulnerable in a browser in term of how you can use the keyboards and how the client will receive what you're trying to show them. For instance, in starcraft2, you use "ctrl+1" to bind an army to the key "1". In chrome, ctrl+1 switches to the first tab. Some webapp uses hacks to go around that.. for instance, with Asana, you use the [tab] key, such as [tab]C to go to the comment section. Everyone talks about performance issues.. but if the trend continue, it won't be a problem. But I'd agree that right now it's still hard performance-wise. Maybe one way to solve these problems is to have a gamer browser. Could be based on V8 and even have the look&feel of Chrome, but small parts would be tweaked to make it gaming friendly. Maybe no plugin allowed, more resources dedicated to it, performance optimized for certain tasks, etc.
- thefreeman 13y agoI real like the idea of a game-mode for browsers, or a dedicated game browser. It could disable all hotkeys, have extremely minimal chrome, and be optimized for the gaming environment.