3 ms·
I think the problem with letting people choose individually is that a lot of software work is essentially collaborative. One team I'm working with right now is
by wpietri 13y ago
I think the problem with letting people choose individually is that a lot of software work is essentially collaborative.
One team I'm working with right now is entirely distributed. And they're building a video call tool, so they like remote-presence tech just fine. But they still work one week physically together every month, even though that means a bunch of 10-13 hour flights. Despite the pain, they see the direct collaboration as necessary to making rapid progress.
If you let individuals be remote or unavailable as they please individually, it becomes very difficult to collaborate. Another team I work with has made Tuesday the optional work-from-home day just to minimize the scheduling chaos and communication impairment that comes from people being out of the office.
I'm hoping that remote-presence tech will solve this problem eventually, but for now, there's just no substitute for having everybody in the same room.
- darkarmani 13y ago> I think the problem with letting people choose individually is that a lot of software work is essentially collaborative. > One team I'm working with right now is entirely distributed. And they're building a video call tool, so they like remote-presence tech just fine. But they still work one week physically together every month, even though that means a bunch of 10-13 hour flights. Despite the pain, they see the direct collaboration as necessary to making rapid progress. In the broader discussion, I feel like your example invalidates your argument. Yes, software work is collaborative, but these people are greatly successful collaborating in person less than 1/4 of their time. This is way less collaboration than they would have working in the same office with private offices.
- wpietri 13y agoThey actually do a fair bit more collaboration than just the monthly get-togethers. They meet at least daily via video, and they do a lot of virtual pair programming, too. But the point of my example is that they are going to extraordinary lengths to get physical presence, which is a sign of how vital it is. To make that happen, they can't just let individuals choose to be present or not; they have to all agree.