7 ms·
Kind of surprised that marketing cost them more than development ($115m vs $150m).
by adamnemecek 13y ago
Kind of surprised that marketing cost them more than development ($115m vs $150m).
- jevinskie 13y ago$115 million? Wow. How many developers/artists/QA/management folks (or man-hours) does that buy you?
- danielharan 13y agoRoughly 1000 person years at 115k/person/year?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoWhich considering some people on the team are undoubtedly paid more, is not that surprising a number. (Although some are paid less too.)
- dpiers 13y agoThe average salary in the game industry is 84k.
- mehwoot 13y agoThe quoted average salary is not the cost of employing someone though, there are always significant on costs.
- robmcm 13y agoRockstar north is based in Scotland, so it's not going to be that high ;)
- AndrewDucker 13y agoPensions, Employers National Insurance Contributions, office space in the middle of Edinburgh (not cheap) - it's not _that_ cheap here.
- robmcm 13y agoI was only joking, Edinburgh costs a fortune!
- pratik661 13y agoI've noticed that people in the game industry make significantly less than other software engineers. Why do you think that is? The few software engineers that I know who work the hours that are the norm in the game industry make even more. I wonder what market forces are at work here.
- bcbrown 13y agoSupply and demand. There's a lot of people who want to work in games, and are willing to work for less pay in order to do so, I imagine.
- nightski 13y agoThere are quite a few people who want to work on games, true. But I am not so sure the pool of talented engineers that are very good at the tasks game development poses is much larger than anywhere else in industry. On the other hand, I don't think a very large portion of game development teams are engineers anymore. Not only are the tools much better, there is much more focus on other things like art, sound, marketing, design, etc...
- bcbrown 13y agoTwo years ago I had a conversation with a recruiter who was working with a company trying to build out a games-testing shop in Portland. They were offering people with 7-10 years experience $35/hr, and seemed shocked when I told them how low that was compared to previous non-games testing jobs I had held previously. It's a good point that the proportion of employees who are engineers is probably lower than in the past. I wonder how engineering vs art/music salaries compare.
- ricardo 13y agoA lot of the engineers making games don't want to do anything else. They're willing to accept a lower rate of pay to stay in the industry. When they look for other opportunities, they're usually just moving from one games company to another. Since there a lot less games companies than there are companies that employee engineers in general, there is less competition and less pressure to pay the same rates as engineers may make at companies like Google or Apple.
- jlgreco 13y agoThat money bought them things like this: http://static.trustedreviews.com/94/000028992/826f/GTA-5-mural-full-LA.jpg http://static.trustedreviews.com/94/000028992/826f/GTA-5-mur... (That is a massive painting on the side of a building, incase that isn't clear)
- adamnemecek 13y agoI'd like to know what are the ROIs for an advertisement like that. I can't really imagine that the people who will buy the game will buy it due to this advertisement. At the same time though, Rockstar probably knows what they are doing.
- enko 13y agoIt's extremely hard to measure, but stunts like that seem to definitely add to "hype". I mean, it's being posted organically here on HN, isn't it! "Hype" definitely gets sales. It leads to people checking out the game/movie, paying attention when they otherwise might not have - it's a form of social proof. $800m in sales, first day. How much of that was due to marketing? Who knows. But it looks pretty positive to me, and stunts like this are part of it. Almost certainly positive, IMO.
- wwwong 13y agoThe overwhelming majority of revenue comes in the first weeks of a game launch. For a major franchise like this, you safely know what minimum dollar amount you'll make. Invest in market for hopes of a big hit. Sure, ROI is tough. But think about the wrong decision to not market and sales flops in the first 2-3 weeks. You can't make up that lost revenue from launch.
- sharkweek 13y agoExactly -- and from a GTA franchise standpoint, their biggest success is just hyping the release as much as possible. They have tons and tons of fanboys who all rushed to buy copies on opening night. There was no doubt this would be a success -- But to build awareness and convince more people to go out and buy it during the opening weeks, that's where a poster like this comes into play. Constant visible reminders of the release date turn a 500m release into an 800m release
- sgloutnikov 13y ago"The game spent four years in full development, by a team of an estimated 250 people. Media analyst Arvind Bhatia estimated the development budget for the game exceeded US$137 million, and The Scotsman reporter Marty McLaughlin estimated that the combined budget of the development and marketing efforts exceeded £170 million (US$265 million), which would make Grand Theft Auto V the most expensive video game ever made."
- dested 13y agoFrom the wiki, 137 million to develop for four years with roughly 250 people (137000000/4/250) = 137k a year average per person
- roel_v 13y agoQuestion is, would it have made the game better? Or would it have been the same game with more content (so that you could hunt 1000 different animals instead of 50 (just throwing out number, I don't know the actuals)) but which nobody knew about?
- dualogy 13y agoOften missed is the massive amount of motion-captured acting and voice acting in that game. How many voice actors just for random peds, hundreds? Another big-ticket budget item is clearly music licensing and celebrity involvement for major-character voice acting (like GTA:SA had Samuel L. Jackson in a major role for example and some old-school rap celebs for "radio moderator" talking).
- NicoJuicy 13y agoNot only celebs, Soulwax a belgian music group created their own Radio Station on GTA V...
- fhd2 13y ago> Kind of surprised that marketing cost them more than development ($115m vs $150m). Kinda depressing, considering how game developers are typically underpaid and overworked... But as long as people are willing to put up with it, it's going to continue.
- skeletonjelly 13y agoDepressing? What would have been more depressing is that they might not have received a bonus had there been no marketing and the game didn't meet budget.
- golergka 13y ago> game developers are typically underpaid and overworked And marketing people aren't? I'm a game developer, and it depresses me how much undeserved hatred and contempt "suits" get form us "technical" guys. We work hard to make something, and they work hard to get it to the people. If you don't like the idea that games like GTAV should be advertised in order to get the money they deserve (and I think no one here disagrees that GTAV deserves it), you should be disappointed with the audience who wouldn't notice it if not for a marketing budget.
- fedvasu 13y agoI totally agree,but aren't already gamers psyched about GTA franchise (I am!!)? Yes GTA deserves it.
- ebbv 13y agoOk let's just ignore the argument of whether marketing people or developers work harder (which, personally, having worked in both sides, I don't think is even a question.) And let's also ignore the argument of whether marketing departments contribute positively to society as compared to development departments. Let's just look at it logically; the budget dedicated to development determines the quality and quantity of what can be created. If you have a finite pool and < 50% is going to development and > 50% is going to marketing then logically you're going to get a lesser product than if you put say, 75% in development and 25% in marketing. So yeah, that's sad. You don't even need to get into who works harder, etc.
- maximilianburke 13y agoMarketing has been a larger cost than development for quite some time now in the world of AAA video games.
- sspiff 13y agoExactly. I remember a greater inbalance in the Call of Duty series, where marketing dwarfed development. I can't seem to find the source though.
- jemeshsu 13y agoWatched Riddick in cinema last night and there was an ads for Grand Theft Auto V. It is rare to see computer game ads in theatre.
- CWIZO 13y agoHere in London they show at least one ad for a game before the movie. London is also littered with billboards for this and other games...
- hbbio 13y agoMy first internship was at a very successful (non-tech) company. One the things I learned there is how R&D costs were 2% of revenue, while marketing... 50%. And we're talking billions here.
- hbbio 13y agoI remember my first internship at a famous company. The first thing they told us was R&D was 2% of revenue. Marketing 50%. And we're talking billions here.
- jessaustin 13y agoKind of surprised... Congratulations sir. You must not watch much TV. It's understandable if they have commercials on all the sports, but I don't even watch much sports and I feel like I've seen the GTA-V spot a hundred times.