4 ms·
Your logic can be dismissed as nonsense with a very easy thought experiment. Imagine you have two groups of people: Group A and Group B. You are voting on a te
by enraged_camel 13y ago
Your logic can be dismissed as nonsense with a very easy thought experiment.
Imagine you have two groups of people: Group A and Group B. You are voting on a technology that can prevent 90% of deaths in Group A. Do you vote yes or no?
If you vote no, congratulations, you just condemned a large group of people to continue dying for the sake of egalitarianism.
(The reason this thought experiment is powerful is that it strips the scenario of value-judgments such as "elite" and "poor.")
- gilrain 13y agoYour logic can be dismissed as a false dichotomy.
- enraged_camel 13y agoOf course. After all, it is simply a stripped down version of the parent comment that I responded to. He polarized the scenario such that it was a false dichotomy, but even then it was flawed.
- newsign 13y agoits not about whether elite is saved or not ... its about whether you're healthy or not .... Imagine you have two groups of people: Group A and Group B. Group A is living longer but unhealthy and Group B is living shorter but extremely healthy , which one do you pick - I rather pick Group B ... dont know whether Calico will be about living longer or living healthier - its not a easy thing to crack but I hope they succeed ...
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIf Group B is 99x the size of Group A, then I vote no.
- BrandonY 13y agoIn his example, he did not suggest that there were any downsides to voting yes. What was your basis for voting no?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoSimple: indefinite lifespan for the members of tiny minority Group A will turn them into a ruling elite even if they're not one already. You can't separate the issue of lifespan from social hierarchy.
- enraged_camel 13y agoOkay, let's attach numbers to the scenario. Assume there are 1 million people in Group A and 990 million people in Group B. By voting no, you just condemned 900,000 people in Group A to eventually die, simply because you wanted to prevent them from becoming the ruling elite. Stated differently, you had the power to prevent 900,000 deaths (and in fact many more than that, moving forward), and you chose not to because of ideology. Surely it is better for people to not die - to not cease to exist - even if that means they rise to the top of the social hierarchy?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoSurely it is better for people to not die - to not cease to exist - even if that means they rise to the top of the social hierarchy? Not unless they're going to be benevolent rulers, no. I will not grant people immortal life so that they can make everyone else's lives into a living hell.
- henryaj 13y agoBy that logic, we should never have eradicated smallpox. Medicine extends lifespan - and a rising tide lifts all boats.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoBy that logic, we should never have eradicated smallpox. We eradicated smallpox for everyone, without distinction between rulers and ruled. That's the difference! a rising tide lifts all boats. "A witty saying proves nothing." -- Voltaire