3 ms·
Sorry, but no. Transhuman-level stuff is not safe or even morally allowable for our current society. No. Just freaking no. I was born in a world where two t
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
Sorry, but no. Transhuman-level stuff is not safe or even morally allowable for our current society. No. Just freaking no.
I was born in a world where two things in life got to everyone: death, and taxes. They've already "relieved" the elite of taxes, and now they're looking to do the same for death.
No. We are not their cattle, and they are not our shepherds.
You want immortality, robots, and post-scarcity awesomeness? Great. Make it for everyone.
Don't develop The Future just so the capitalist elite can exploit even harder.
- julespitt 13y agoYou can't "make it for everyone" before you figure out how to make it in the first place.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoThen fund a nonprofit research agency rather than a for-profit productizing company. Lots of countries have public healthcare systems who could administer life-extension treatments universally if they're not locked down and treated as proprietary, for-profit products!
- julespitt 13y agoIt is pretty weird that it's not a non-profit, I'll give you that.
- jpadkins 13y agoWhy? What is the functional difference? Non-profits just funnel profits back to execs, instead of shareholders. Non-profit != lower prices.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoPrices? You want medical treatment to have a price?
- ivank 13y agoHave you thought this through? Doctors have to be compensated, unless you want to enslave them. Even a single-payer system has prices. On a side note, healthcare costs are high in the US due to artificially limited supply and failed central planning of future demand: http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/2005-03-02-doctor-shortage_x.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/2005-03-02-doctor...
- goldfeld 13y agoJust like the internet, right? A great philantropic endeavour planned for all. Get real, real research doesn't happen in a vacuum, it happens for profit or some advantage. And then it trickles down not because the research funders pass it on, but because market dynamics eventually make it inevitable. So you'd rather the internet hadn't happened? The industrial revolution too? Well let's just head right back to stone age where everyone gets a chance at cracking each other's skull, that's where it's at. Sorry if I'm being harsh, but seriously, "make it for everyone"? Who is that even directed at, god? It's not like post-scarcity and immortality will be the work of Larry Page or anyone in isolation who could take it upon themselves to do it altruistically.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoJust like the internet, right? A great philantropic endeavour planned for all. You mean a government-funded research program that took place in academia and released its results under open licensing, thus allowing a hacker-ethic of free contribution and usage? Because that's how the internet happened, actually. Do remember that the Mosaic web browser was invented by Tim Burners-Lee at CERN while on public payroll, it was released under free licensing, and the whole infrastructure spread precisely because it was decentralized and open. The internet versus the App Store is an excellent example of why we want publicly-funded, open-access research initiatives, not private profit-mongering. Sorry if I'm being harsh, but seriously, "make it for everyone"? Who is that even directed at, god? It's not like post-scarcity and immortality will be the work of Larry Page or anyone in isolation who could take it upon themselves to do it altruistically. Well, if God is listening, I'd certainly like Him to consider that He should come down and issue a few ethical guidelines before we start stomping all over His Creation trying to overpower Him!
- mason240 13y agoThank god people like you weren't around when vaccines were being developed.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago45,000 people die each year in the USA for lack of medical insurance, and these guys want to offer radical anti-aging treatments to those who can afford it. And you say they're the ones serving Life?
- paganel 13y agoI for myself am a little let-down by how many HNers would prefer to live indefinitely as potential economic slaves under a gerontocracy only because everyone is so afraid of dying. The only thing that actually comforts me is that I think aging is really an insolvable problem, the same as strong AI is an insolvable problem.