33 ms·
The biggest problem is that Samsung and LG think they need to customize & brand the phone to be recognizable as their own product. They're spitting in the face
by ameoba 13y ago
The biggest problem is that Samsung and LG think they need to customize & brand the phone to be recognizable as their own product. They're spitting in the face of OSS when they go and half-ass their own versions of standard components. Things are even worse when you get carriers into the mix trying to provide their own unique user experience.
A great example of how this can blow up in their face is a recent T-Mobile visual voicemail app. Not only is it slow, buggy & constantly crashing but they had the audacity to place advertisements in it. For some reason, customers didn't like being forced to use their time & metered bandwidth to view shitty ads (the "Click here to upgrade your memory!" sort) while using a service that they had already paid for. If you look at the Play Store, you'll see brazillions of 1-star reviews complaining about this. Fortunately, T-Mo listened & removed the ads. The app is still slow & buggy. I still can't uninstall the Slacker app or remove the Fox News bookmark from the browser but at least I don't have to stare at advertisements while waiting for my voicemail to crash.
Manufacturers & Carriers need to recognize that the value they bring to the table with Android is by providing good hardware, low prices & good service, not crapping up an awesome phone with reminders that Samsung & Verizon are the Best Thing Ever.
- takluyver 13y agoManufacturers do that, even in the face of evidence that they're terrible at it, because they really want to avoid ending up like PC manufacturers. Consumers treat PC makers as interchangeable suppliers of largely similar products, forcing them to compete on price, so they have very small margins. Samsung is very keen for you to think of your phone as a Samsung phone, not as an Android phone made by Samsung. So to them it makes sense to reinvent standard components, even if it doesn't make the user experience any better. And Samsung does seem to be managing this, though I don't think any of the other Android OEMs have.