5 ms·
I joined Stack Overflow about 4.5 years ago and I was one of the top 10 all time users on Stack Overflow for a couple years or so, so I have seen my fair share
by mehrdada 13y ago
I joined Stack Overflow about 4.5 years ago and I was one of the top 10 all time users on Stack Overflow for a couple years or so, so I have seen my fair share of SO/EE arguments on the web. What's interesting is that not a single time I'd seen EE defended by anyone but its current or former employees.
Also, the blog post mentions "I think their public, negative campaign against Experts Exchange was excessive, mean-spirited, and at the very least immature and silly. Admittedly, it worked – they’ve achieved their goal, and “death to EE” became the rallying cry."
I don't really get this. Aside some joke-like mentions in the podcast or blog entries, Stack Overflow did not really do anything to harm EE specifically. They were just a better QnA platform and much closer to what users wanted. No one rallied against EE just to kill EE; whatever was done was to build a better QnA system and that succeeded. Experts Exchange is just something users don't want and it never reacted to the presence of Stack Overflow and Stack Overflow eventually ate their lunch in its entirety. Stack Overflow's mission was to become the wikipedia of programming questions, which meant EE-like sites would eventually die should SO becomes successful, but EE was never a specific target of a tactic or anything beyond joke-like verbal attacks. It was, however, a good model of "how not to do things"; something you'd learn from.
- gknoy 13y agoMy impression from reading Atwood's writings on the origins of SO was that being Not Experts Exchange was a primary initial goal.
- mehrdada 13y agoI know that was what he said, but I believe that sentence was just a simple way to communicate their vision like using "XYZ done right" to describe a company. He did not particularly care about Experts Exchange IMO.
- andy_adams 13y agoPublicly naming someone as your arch enemy is pretty specifically targeting them, if you ask me...
- mehrdada 13y agoAlright, fine. If you believe calling Experts Exchange names by a tiny startup, that had just joined the QnA business, had anything to do with killing EE, you are horribly wrong. It's like me calling for Microsoft's death as an individual and when they die eventually, get blamed for their death as if my rant, not their incompetence, contributed to their death at all.
- jackmaney 13y agoYou bring up a very important point in that the only defenders of EE seem to be current or former EE employees. Has anyone, anywhere seen someone defend EE who is not a current or former employee of EE?