3 ms·
Released where? To Cuba? Into the sea? Most of the men abducted to Guantanamo have been released. All of those went somewhere. Most just went home, although so
by jessaustin 13y ago
Released where? To Cuba? Into the sea?
Most of the men abducted to Guantanamo have been released. All of those went somewhere. Most just went home, although some went to more colorful locales like Palau and Albania, particularly if they had been abducted while abroad so their native land had some excuse not to accept their return. This isn't surprising, since the vast majority of these men were not "combatants" and had little connection to AQ or any other terrorist organization. The "recidivism" of released abductees has been calculated at 4%, which is such a mind-blowingly low number that it speaks more to the indiscriminate nature of the abductions rather than the rehabilitational effectiveness of Guantanamo.
Besides, what's your brilliant solution? Maintain this obscenity until the last abductee dies of old age in about 60 years? Thanks for reminding us of the typical practicality of status quo Beltway-insider conventional wisdom.
- MichaelSalib 13y agoI think the US government should offer most of the detainees visas to come and live in the US and should offer them financial compensation for unjust imprisonment. That is politically impossible, so I think the government should continue working to repatriate them and improve living conditions in Gitmo itself. That's not a good solution. But it seems like the best feasible solution. I'd love to be proven wrong. Can you do that? Or are you going to make a big public display of your moral purity by talking down on pragmatism?
- jessaustin 13y agoIt takes a lot of chutzpah to ask the question, "Into the sea?" as if that's what anyone wants, as if a rational being could ever commit that misunderstanding, and then get all butt-hurt when someone points out that the vast majority of abductees have been released with no problems. Aren't you the ass who came up with "green lanternism"? I actually googled it: the first usage was Brad DeLong pulling heroic pundit duty on the Fed Chair campaign of Larry Summers. Just as I said: status quo Beltway-insider conventional wisdom. Do I have a sixth sense about this shit or something? Now you want "to be proven [sic] wrong"? Please. If anyone has a burden of proof, it's whoever who describes Guantanamo as "pragmatic". Good grief. If the commander-in-chief wanted prisoners in any USA military facility in the world transferred to any other USA military facility in the world, he could send an email and have wheels up within an hour. Of course, keeping a campaign promise might have consequences for him. He might have to send a Joint Chief to testify to Congress or something. I'm not sure how he'd recover from that harrowing ordeal, but I still think he should keep his promise.
- MichaelSalib 13y agoas if that's what anyone wants I don't think anyone wants that, but I do think some people haven't thought through the consequences of their policies. Aren't you the ass who came up with "green lanternism"? I didn't invent it but I did mention it. Here's a more original description: http://www.smirkingchimp.com/thread/845 http://www.smirkingchimp.com/thread/845 Just as I said: status quo Beltway-insider conventional wisdom. This is so weird. The invocation of green lanterism was coined to make fun of Beltway insiders and their bizarre fixation on using magical thinking to solve all problems. he could send an email and have wheels up within an hour. Except for when Congress passed a law making that illegal. Hey, are military officers required to obey illegal orders?
- jessaustin 13y ago...magical thinking to solve all problems. The problems are created when some defense contractor's lobbyist floats some vile proposal and then makes it worth a few Pentagon staffers' time to implement it. The magical thinking is saved for the talking-head shows, when enough of the public notices the travesty. Then an ex-general or columnist or whoever must be sent around to argue the dubious proposition that stopping indefensible conduct is much more difficult than starting it. As if that were even an argument. When I fuck up, I experience the consequences. Why is that impossible for people in the federal government? Hey, are military officers required to obey illegal orders? Now I know you're trolling me. Anyway, Obama signed that law in 2011.
- nitid_name 13y agoNOTE: I am not the OP >Now I know you're trolling me. Come on, seriously? There's no need for that. >Anyway, Obama signed that law in 2011. ... and in 2010, 2012, and 2013. It's been part of the National Defense Authorization Act every year Mr. Obama has been in office. The last two years he's stumped around the time the bill was moving through the house, trying to use the Bully Pulpit to remove the prohibition of funds being used to relocate the prisoners. So far, he has been unsuccessful.
- rayiner 13y ago> Most of the men abducted to Guantanamo have been released. Yes, they were either tried or sent back to their home countries. The ones that are left are the ones that no state is willing to host a trial for (not trying Guantanamo detainees in Alexandria became a political issue in Virginia state politics recently), or whose home countries don't want them back. What do you do with them?
- arethuza 13y agoI think the decent thing to do would be to give everyone not convicted of an offense US citizenship and a chunk of money by way of compensation. Of course, that's not going to happen....
- jessaustin 13y agoExactly right! To our shame, the reason decent things don't happen isn't because they're impossible, but because they might have some political fallout. To a certain species of troglodyte, "impossible" and "some political fallout" are the same thing.
- superuser2 13y agoThat would be the decent thing to do, but Congress has explicitly blocked that. Under no circumstances can a detainee be transported to the United States.
- rayiner 13y agoRight, but the President and Congress are not elected to do the "decent thing" but rather to implement the will of the people. When the Senate voted to block transfers from Guantanamo to the U.S. by 98-0, that suggests that they understood that the political will in the U.S. was strongly against such an action.
- arethuza 13y agoI apologize - I didn't know that had explicitly been blocked.