6 ms·
"Obama claims his hands are tied" Its a pity he's not Commander in Chief of the military. Then he could issue orders to soldiers in charge of a military facil
by VLM 13y ago
"Obama claims his hands are tied"
Its a pity he's not Commander in Chief of the military. Then he could issue orders to soldiers in charge of a military facility. Perhaps whoever is the Commander in Chief should step forward and solve the problem.
I am well aware of the true arguments that he would be unable to defund or outright eliminate the facility, Congress would have to do that. It is WELL within his ability to, say, directly order all prisoners released, or order all troops to leave the facility and no troops to re-enter the facility.
- MichaelSalib 13y agoIt is WELL within his ability to, say, directly order all prisoners released Released where? To Cuba? Into the sea? If you want to release people, you need to send them someplace. Congress has banned the government from sending them to the US. You can't send them to other countries because those countries won't take them. So...where do they go? or order all troops to leave the facility and no troops to re-enter the facility. How do the prisoners eat after the US Navy leaves?
- rdtsc 13y ago> Released where? To Cuba? Into the sea? If your father/mother/son/daughter was kidnapped when you were 5, and you didn't know where they were for years and then found out he is in Gitmo, pretty sure you'd like to see them back at your house? Why "the country/town/house" they were kidnapped from isn't even a choice on your list?
- MichaelSalib 13y agoBecause those countries generally don't want them back. Or because they don't want to go back. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_detainees_at_Guantanamo_Bay#Asylum_in_Albania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_detainees_at_Guantanamo_... for an example The US government has ruled that many Gitmo detainees are no threat and have been trying to repatriate them but their home countries (which are not always the countries they were taken from) resist. That is stupid and wrong, just like taking them in the first place. But you can't just wish that inconvenient fact away. I get that this is a nightmarish horrific injustice. But that shouldn't allow us to lose all rationality and start living in a fantasy world. Ordering the US Navy to abandon the facility won't help Gitmo detainees: they're run out of food and water and they'll still be thousands of miles from their families with no way to get home.
- tomjen3 13y agoWhy not take them with them then?
- MichaelSalib 13y agoDo you mean have the US Navy take the detainees with them? If so, then the question is: where? You can't take them into the US because Congress has made that illegal. You can't take them into other countries because those countries won't let you. So where do they go?
- tomjen3 13y agoTake them to the US anyway, then by the time the Supreme court rules on the matter (and it may go either way) it will be too late - there is putting that genie back. It is hardly less legal than the spying program or plenty of other things the president has done. It is the very least the US government can do as a token of reparation for the huge injustice that was/is Guantanamo.
- krapp 13y agoNo governor wants to be pegged with "letting a flood of foreign terrorists" settle in their state. I seem to recall there was a similar issue with Iraqi refugees during the last war. To get that to work you would have to expect far too many people to fall politically on their swords, and then the refugees have an almost impossible time actually assimilating because doubtless they'll be put onto some sort of watchlist as if they were a felon or pedophile, and employers would refuse to hire them, and no one would rent to them, and credit would be impossible to get, etc. Although I agree we should at least be trying. We seem to have given up as a nation on even accepting the possibility of a productive solution that doesn't just involve having them all die then pretending like it never happened.
- jdp 13y agoIf government has ruled that detainees are no threat, why are they still treated as if they are, shackled even when alone and watching television? It costs $2MM per year per detainee to keep them in Gitmo. Wouldn't it be much more cost-effective to provide some relocation assistance? I get that repatriation isn't always possible but can it really be true that less than 200 people can't get at least temporary visas somewhere else? That's less than the capacity of a single trans-oceanic flight. It seems silly (and apparently very expensive) to me to perpetuate the farce, and wringing our hands and talking about rationality while letting people rot in prison just because they can't be repatriated without exploring other options seems either equally silly, or not to be the real reason they remain there.
- jessaustin 13y agoReleased where? To Cuba? Into the sea? Most of the men abducted to Guantanamo have been released. All of those went somewhere. Most just went home, although some went to more colorful locales like Palau and Albania, particularly if they had been abducted while abroad so their native land had some excuse not to accept their return. This isn't surprising, since the vast majority of these men were not "combatants" and had little connection to AQ or any other terrorist organization. The "recidivism" of released abductees has been calculated at 4%, which is such a mind-blowingly low number that it speaks more to the indiscriminate nature of the abductions rather than the rehabilitational effectiveness of Guantanamo. Besides, what's your brilliant solution? Maintain this obscenity until the last abductee dies of old age in about 60 years? Thanks for reminding us of the typical practicality of status quo Beltway-insider conventional wisdom.
- MichaelSalib 13y agoI think the US government should offer most of the detainees visas to come and live in the US and should offer them financial compensation for unjust imprisonment. That is politically impossible, so I think the government should continue working to repatriate them and improve living conditions in Gitmo itself. That's not a good solution. But it seems like the best feasible solution. I'd love to be proven wrong. Can you do that? Or are you going to make a big public display of your moral purity by talking down on pragmatism?
- jessaustin 13y agoIt takes a lot of chutzpah to ask the question, "Into the sea?" as if that's what anyone wants, as if a rational being could ever commit that misunderstanding, and then get all butt-hurt when someone points out that the vast majority of abductees have been released with no problems. Aren't you the ass who came up with "green lanternism"? I actually googled it: the first usage was Brad DeLong pulling heroic pundit duty on the Fed Chair campaign of Larry Summers. Just as I said: status quo Beltway-insider conventional wisdom. Do I have a sixth sense about this shit or something? Now you want "to be proven [sic] wrong"? Please. If anyone has a burden of proof, it's whoever who describes Guantanamo as "pragmatic". Good grief. If the commander-in-chief wanted prisoners in any USA military facility in the world transferred to any other USA military facility in the world, he could send an email and have wheels up within an hour. Of course, keeping a campaign promise might have consequences for him. He might have to send a Joint Chief to testify to Congress or something. I'm not sure how he'd recover from that harrowing ordeal, but I still think he should keep his promise.
- tomjen3 13y agoYes into Cuba. The US commander in chief orders the soldiers to withdraw and vacates the base then lets the Cubans get it. Now all the prisoners are in Cuban and they can return them (which they will because it is a huge propaganda coup).
- MichaelSalib 13y agoIf the detainees home countries refuse to take them now, why would they suddenly agree when Cuba offers? I mean, at least the US can do some horsetrading on this issue (which it seems to have), but Cuba is much poorer and has a lot less to offer. It seems like the most likely outcome is that the detainees end up as Cuban prisoners.
- tomjen3 13y agoThey likely stay in Cuba, yes, but at least they are semi-free (and will be completely free once Cuba gets rid of the commies). Castros government will treat them well because it is a huge propaganda victory for them.
- VLM 13y ago"If the detainees home countries refuse to take them now, why would they suddenly agree when Cuba offers?" I find this rather unlikely. The enemy of my enemy is my friend so anyone not willing to deal with the USA because we're, well, the USA, would bend over backwards to cooperate with Cuba. Cuba has a moderately good international rep. They don't get involved in too much international empire building once the Soviets broke up, and they export good doctors to the 3rd world. And they're an enemy of the greatest current Imperial power. I think they'd do pretty well..
- dantheman 13y agoObama never wanted to end the injustice of Guantanamo, he merely wanted to move it: Long before, and fully independent of, anything Congress did, President Obama made clear that he was going to preserve the indefinite detention system at Guantanamo even once he closed the camp. President Obama fully embraced indefinite detention — the defining injustice of Guantanamo — as his own policy. ... hen the President finally unveiled his plan for “closing Guantanamo,” it became clear that it wasn’t a plan to “close” the camp as much as it was a plan simply to re-locate it — import it — onto American soil, at a newly purchased federal prison in Thompson, Illinois. William Lynn, Obama’s Deputy Defense Secretary, sent a letter to inquiring Senators that expressly stated that the Obama administration intended to continue indefinitely to imprison some of the detainees with no charges of any kind. The plan was classic Obama: a pretty, feel-good, empty symbolic gesture (get rid of the symbolic face of Bush War on Terror excesses) while preserving the core abuses (the powers of indefinite detention ), even strengthening and expanding those abuses by bringing them into the U.S. http://www.salon.com/2012/07/23/the_obama_gitmo_myth/ http://www.salon.com/2012/07/23/the_obama_gitmo_myth/
- twoodfin 13y agoI think in a way you're being unfair to President Obama. I believe his actual intention was to get the prisoners onto continental American soil and into a Federal prison so that the Supreme Court would feel more inclined to require they be released or charged in the civilian system. He'd get the outcome he wanted (I think he really does believe Gitmo and unlimited detention are bad ideas) without having to take political responsibility for it himself. President Obama's stranger decisions can often be explained as an attempt to vote "present".
- michaelt 13y agoYou think he said to himself "I'd like to shut guantanamo bay, but only if I can do it without getting credit or blame, if I have to take credit or blame I just won't do it" ? Seems to me he's in his final term - it's not like closing guantanamo bay would be the thing that stopped him getting re-elected. More likely, in my opinion, is that after being elected he received secret information (maybe proving the detainees are guilty, maybe proving they've been subject to torture which they'd go to the press about, maybe both) and he decided he didn't want them released.
- nitid_name 13y agoIn the United States, Congress controls the so called "purse strings." The House, where all spending bills must originate under the US Constitution, passed a bill denying any funds being used toward the closing of Guantanamo or the relocation of the prisoners. This has been happening yearly in the National Defense Authorization Act since Obama took office. So Mr. Obama's hands are, in fact, tied, by law from "issu[ing] orders to soldiers in charge of a military facility." This does not, of course, preclude him from using the so called "bully pulpit" to make a case to the American people. He also could take the more drastic measure of vetoing the NDAA, but he would then run the risk of leaving the military unfunded. The first option is plausible (and he has, on occasion, taken to discussing Guantanamo in his stump speeches around the time the NDAA is moving through the lower chamber), the second would be an incalculable political risk.
- gshubert17 13y agoCould someone take up a collection for the funds, and bypass the Congress?