4 ms·
How was it tax deductible since he essentially was keeping all the value of the product? I can't buy a stack of cars and then donate a ashtray to the Salvation
by aaron695 13y ago
How was it tax deductible since he essentially was keeping all the value of the product?
I can't buy a stack of cars and then donate a ashtray to the Salvation Army and claim the car back?
- lusr 13y agoHe donated the product and kept the barcode.
- rschmitty 13y agoHe purchased pudding and donated pudding. If you want to buy a stack of cars, keep the invoice papers and donate the car feel free
- aaron695 13y agoNo, that's why it was at the Salvo's in the first place he was getting them to peel off the thing of value he bought, bar codes that give flyers miles.
- nmeofthestate 13y agoThe pudding was the same price before and after the promotion, so the barcode was worth zero cents. He claimed back tax on the non-barcode value.
- aaron695 13y agoIt's a bit a stretch that any judge/anyone would believe that he was buying pudding. Or that he went to all that effort to keep something of zero value.
- nmeofthestate 13y agoIn the UK, any promotional 'tokens' like this have to have a monetary value on them - normally it's something like 0.0001p. IANAL but perhaps this minute monetary value is the legal value (i.e. effectively nothing)?
- vidarh 13y agoThey wouldn't need to believe he was buying it for just the pudding. They would need to believe that the donated pudding had a certain monetary value, that this guy then donated. And that value would be natural to assess against the cost of acquiring the pudding when the donation was made to someone for the benefit of the food.. That he could extract additional value through the work of removing the bar code does not implicitly reduce the value of the pudding itself. It is not unusual for it to be possible to extract more value by splitting up a product and selling or taking advantage of parts separately. A lot of businesses are even built on buying lots and separating them to extract value as people are often willing to pay over the odds for a smaller part, or parts of the lots may have been undervalued (as clearly was the case here).
- pm90 13y agoDoes it matter? Free pudding was given to Salvo. Salvo had no idea what to do with the barcodes.
- drharris 13y agoBar codes have no intrinsic value. The value is in the promotion. Think of it as a "reimbursement" not for the product, but for the activity of purchasing it.
- driverdan 13y agoIn the USA airline miles are not considered income and are untaxed. Purchase a product, get the miles, donate the product to charity.
- dlhavema 13y agoi might be wrong but if it's a tax deduction, doesn't that just reduce his tax liability by some percentage of the $800, so more like 20-30% depending upon his tax bracket? That way the $800 is only worth maybe $200 - $300.. A tax credit would be a full dollar for dollar comparison.
- Lagged2Death 13y agoYou're quite right. Very common error, unfortunately.
- PeterisP 13y agoThe article seems to state that he got $800 deduction out of the $3k pudding purchase - which matches that 20-30% expectation.