5 ms·
The "after" screenshots don't seem to have anything in common anymore. Some of the apps look like Android, some look like Windows Phone, some look like Palm web
by pavlov 13y ago
The "after" screenshots don't seem to have anything in common anymore. Some of the apps look like Android, some look like Windows Phone, some look like Palm webOS.
The previous iterations at least shared a few button styles and navigation bar styles, but now it seems like everyone has taken the opportunity to reinvent those too.
It's certainly ok by me that app developers are taking more liberties in making their apps look unique. But if I were running the iOS show at Apple, I'd probably be worried about this development: if the visual presence of the OS disappears entirely from apps, it becomes that much less scary to pick up an Android phone because the apps won't look any different there.
- badman_ting 13y agoPerhaps, but overall it seems like bad strategy to avoid doing something because you're afraid it might help competitors. You do whatever you think is the best thing. Plus, Apple has been doomed for a long time now. Ditto the iPhone and iOS. And yet...
- jjcm 13y agoTo be fair it's a new style language. It's going to take time for people to normalize on designs. Eventually I think that there will be a more homogeneous experience, but right now everyone is trying to feel it out and explore. Design follows trends, but right now there aren't any trends to follow in ios7.
- petercooper 13y agoPreviously, wasn't it just follow Apple's style guide or go home? If so, what's happened in iOS 7? Are Apple just being far more lax in enforcing a style guide or is the style guide out of the window now?
- publicfig 13y agoNope, that wasn't really the case before. There were plenty of apps that deviated from Apple's styles, it's just that their UI tools made it easy to design your own app with your own interface. I think we'll see a lot of apps that look like stock iOS apps once the app makers that have been holding off/don't have a UI Team realize they need to update their apps to match the modern visual style.
- coldtea 13y ago>Previously, wasn't it just follow Apple's style guide or go home? No, it never was that way. In fact, Apple has even given Awards to third party apps with totally unique UIs.
- camus 13y agowhat about designers to "normalize" on people and make their app usable instead of surfing on the flat fad? most of these after design are plain ugly.
- ajross 13y agoI noticed that too. Lots of the new apps have a distinctly "Android" feel to them, even to the point of Fancy having what looks clearly like an Android menu button (though not in the standard Android location). A fun flame war to start (i.e. let's please not) would be to argue whether this is due to app designers feeling an increasing need to target Android or whether it's because the truth is that iOS's "new look" seems distinctly Jellybean-like to an app designer.
- zyb09 13y agoThe simple truth probably is the company that made the app designed their Android version first and didn't bother to come up with a complete new app design for iOS, so they just kinda ported it. You can also find a lot of Android apps that seem to be directly ported from its iOS incarnations, instead of using native UI conventions.
- gbhn 13y agoThat's probably true in some cases. I think another thing that is true is that mobile visual vocabulary is stabilizing, much as the desktop visual vocobulary of menu bars, window title bars, etc. did. That makes for a more boring app world, perhaps, but one users can potentially find more predictable and useful.
- methodin 13y agoI find this deliciously delightful after suffering the wrath of these stupid app developers historically on Android. I don't agree with it, certainly, but I feel some warped sense of justice.
- gcb1 13y agowhich is idiotic. had everyone put effort in browser integration like webos was doing, the end user would be much better served. but lack of lock-in doesnt sell in the corporate world...
- yareally 13y agoThat's always been a pet peeve of mine on Android, though now it seems both ecosystems will have a slightly more consistent user experience if one uses devices on both OSs a lot.
- drpancake 13y agoOn the contrary I think we're entering a temporary period of apps looking closer to each other than they did pre-iOS 7. Hardly any apps used the stock controls anymore as they looked so stale, whereas many of the new designs are taking Apple's lead, at least for now. I can imagine that the same process will begin to repeat itself as we get used to this new style.
- rwc 13y agoNot a lot (any?) of "top 50" most commonly used apps in this comparison yet. Plenty of examples of bad, non-standard design in the depths of the App Store. Just as with iOSes before it, there will be skilled and unskilled interpretations of the design language.
- mcintyre1994 13y agoI noticed this too, although to be fair I did think most of the "after" screenshots looked better than their "before" counterparts. It does seem that there's no real iOS 'presence' any more, but then I always thought the old iOS 'presence' looked hideous anyway so it doesn't look like a loss to me.
- rimantas 13y ago> if the visual presence of the OS disappears entirely from > apps, This actually was one of the goals of the redesign: make content the most important thing on the screen.
- gurkendoktor 13y agoBut look at, for example, "Days To Go". I think it's a very typical iOS 7 design, and it meddles the content with the UI: the caption looks exactly the same as the actual content. On iOS 6, you knew what was the "window frame" (UI) and what was the "window" (content), and you could look through the frame without any cognitive effort. Now both parts look the same.
- overcyn 13y agoI don't believe any of the default iOS 7 apps use gradients like that. http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5330/9023342228_8341c60043_b.jpg http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5330/9023342228_8341c60043_b.j...
- gurkendoktor 13y agoWhat I meant is this: On iOS 1-6, the UI is very clearly UI. The rectangle between navigation bars, tab bars and status bars is the content. It's like looking at a snowy landscape through a heavy, wooden frame. On iOS 7, everything blends together and I don't see how this puts the focus on the content. E.g. in mail, the scrollable content has almost the same colour as the bars above and below it. How is it more prominent now?
- kyriee 13y agoHow do you get to that? The UI is basically the same, but flatter. In addition, iOS 7 is not about aesthetics, it's about depth and movement...
- _random_ 13y agoI guess the biggest take away is that industrial design is not same as GUI design. I hope Johnny Ive will be strong enough to hire those Microsoft UX designers (Zune, XBOX etc) for iOS 8.
- samstave 13y agoWhat do you mean? I am FLAT. What don't you people understand about that? I AM FLAT WITH IMAGES!! -- iOfficeSpace