2 ms·
I just think Scalia has it backward. He looks at the language of the Bill of Rights and says "where's the right to privacy?" I look at Article 1 Section 8 and s
by snowwrestler 13y ago
I just think Scalia has it backward. He looks at the language of the Bill of Rights and says "where's the right to privacy?" I look at Article 1 Section 8 and say "where's the power to invade my privacy?"
- rayiner 13y agoWhich is where the specific mechanisms the NSA uses become relevant. The Constitution did not, and was not intended to, abrogate most of the common law powers of the courts. Judges can subpoena pretty much anything, and that's a historical practice that dates back to long before the Constitution. If they subpoena, from a third party, information that happens to let them track who you're calling, that's legit from an "enumerated powers" point of view. Also, defensive spying is older than the Constitution and the Constitution gives Congress the power to provide for the collective defense. Though I think your line of argument is a better one than conjuring a "right to privacy" out of thin air.