7 ms·
It's too bad that the definition of 'won' in these cases is usually 'spent thousands of dollars on lawyers, that you will never get back because the troll is a
by kevingadd 13y ago
It's too bad that the definition of 'won' in these cases is usually 'spent thousands of dollars on lawyers, that you will never get back because the troll is a shell company with no actual assets'.
- SG- 13y agoIt could have been much worse, $50K default penalty if he ignored it or his apps and others going off the market.
- mildtrepidation 13y agoDespite this being true, "it could've been much worse" and "$50k default penalty" are things that don't mesh with most people's (very reasonable) expectations of rational business.
- burkemw3 13y agoThe shell company owns some right to assert the patent. It may even own the patent itself. This right is a revenue generating asset. The shell company should even have records of just how much revenue that asset generates. Can anyone point me to an instance where an infringement defendant went after the assertion rights or patent ownership? My search-fu hasn't turned up anything in the validity or success of this tactic.
- ksherlock 13y agoRighthaven (copyrights, not patents) was eventually shut down for lack of standing since they didn't own the copyrights but only the right to sue over them. In the Apple/HTC ITC case, 5 of HTCoogle patents were thrown out over lack of standing (Google sort of gave them to HTC but retained some control over them).