3 ms·
When information had to be exchanged from enclave to walled enclave via physical tokens, privacy rights were a subset of property rights. There is a real quest
by barrkel 13y ago
When information had to be exchanged from enclave to walled enclave via physical tokens, privacy rights were a subset of property rights.
There is a real question about interpretation of historical documents in the light of today. Do you interpret them based on their effects at the time they were written, or their literal meaning by modern definitions?
I don't like the question at all, because it presumes a sacredness that should not be applied to mere documents written by people. But there are different problems with making a constitution a more mutable document subject to political fashions.
Could there be a trailing update mechanism, whereby e.g. amendments are proposed, voted upon, then voted upon again 10 years later, and so on, and only applied if 3 or 5 votes succeed?
That would be more legitimate than supreme court rulings, and remove the sacredness that warps people's thinking.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not a matter of sacredness, but rather "problems with making a constitution a more mutable document subject to political fashions." People argue endlessly about Constitutionality not because they view the document as sacred, but because just about the only thing our society agrees on is that the Constitution is one of the few legitimate restrictions on majoritarian democracy. As a result, we fight about exactly what those restrictions are.