2 ms·
I agree, and would add that the mission of the CIA is to assess foreign threats to the U.S. The end of the Soviet Union was not a threat to the U.S., thus pred
by snowwrestler 13y ago
I agree, and would add that the mission of the CIA is to assess foreign threats to the U.S.
The end of the Soviet Union was not a threat to the U.S., thus predicting the exact date of its occurrence was not a priority.
- smacktoward 13y agoThe sudden end of the Soviet Union was a massive threat to the United States. The Soviet Union was a regime that by the 1980s had amassed a stockpile of tens of thousands of nuclear weapons, which were stored and deployed across the vast interior of the USSR. The regime was the only guarantor of the security of those weapons. A breakdown of the regime would (and did) throw open the question of who now controlled those weapons. A new successor state? Individual breakaway republics? Factions within the army or internal security forces? Non-state actors? Random locals who happened to show up at a silo with a big enough mob behind them to claim them? The USSR also had huge conventional forces stationed across Eastern Europe, Asia and Africa. If the authority these forces reported to were to suddenly break down, how would they respond? Would factions among them split and fight each other? Would a general use his tanks to set himself up as King of Poland? Would a revanchist politician rally the army to establish a military dictatorship? With hindsight we know the answers to these questions, but at the time we did not. Which is why intelligence agencies exist -- to help answer them. Thanks to quick thinking and quick action by both Americans and Russians (and Ukrainians, and Belarusians, and Kazakhs, etc.) in the years following the dissolution of the USSR, Soviet conventional and nuclear forces were (mostly) secured. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/story/2009/09/20/ST2009092002315.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/story/2009/09/2... for an example of one story from that time.) But there were no guarantees at the time that things would turn out as well as they did. So the question of whether the USSR was breaking up should have been of urgent interest to the CIA, because a breakup that went bad could have had catastrophic consequences for the US and the world.
- snowwrestler 13y agoThat's a great point and I did not think of it that way. Thanks.
- lutusp 13y ago> The end of the Soviet Union was not a threat to the U.S. But it was. When the Soviet Union was at the height of its power, all it wanted was to stay in power (the mandate of any empire). But when the Soviet Union ended, that was a time of maximum danger -- a rogue general, or a political radical, might take control of the state, and use doomsday weapons that the old guard was too wise to consider using. Believe me when I tell you, the Soviet Union under Brezhnev was quite stable, all appearances to the contrary, but a collapsing Soviet Union was extremely dangerous. And since the collapse of the SU, we've been doing all in our power to keep nuclear materials out of the black market, something that wasn't a possibility during the height of Soviet power. > thus predicting the exact date of its occurrence was not a priority. On the contrary, for reasons given above.