3 ms·
It's to the point now that I almost feel like the only durable and consistent solution would come from a Constitutional amendment that directly addresses the co
by snowwrestler 13y ago
It's to the point now that I almost feel like the only durable and consistent solution would come from a Constitutional amendment that directly addresses the concept of privacy. It would at least partially satisfy textualists, originalists, and strict constructionists, while addressing the concerns of modern data/privacy activists. It could also potentially address privacy concerns across both government (e.g. NSA) and private (e.g. Facebook) spheres.
There's obviously a huge hurdle to overcome to make that happen. How would it be phrased? Very difficult to work out. And, what would cause sufficient outcry for the public to push for it?
> As he often does when extolling the text of the Constitution, Scalia criticized his colleagues for their "activism" in creating new human rights not articulated by the framers.
Argh, comments like this make my blood boil. My reading of history is that the Constitution was not intended to create any human rights, but rather to prevent the government from limiting the rights that we all have naturally. Which would include privacy.
- rayiner 13y agoWhen you find something difficult to phrase, it usually means that you're not sure yet of the scope and details of what you're trying to say, or there isn't broad consensus as to what should be said. All of which counsels against carving those prototype ideas into the Constitution, either through an amendment or a Supreme Court decision. > My reading of history is that the Constitution was not intended to create any human rights, but rather to prevent the government from limiting the rights that we all have naturally. Which would include privacy. Where the "rights" that the Constitution protects come from and what they are is a complex question: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substantive_due_process http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substantive_due_process. Most modern jurists have abandoned the idea of "natural rights" (which are ironically, essentially supernatural). Most liberals tend to think of the Constitution as protecting an evolving set of rights derived from broad social consensus. Most conservatives tend to think of the Constitution as protecting those rights the founders would have recognized at the time of the framing, based on long-standing English tradition dating back to the magna carta. Scalia had this to say about the "right to privacy" yesterday: http://legaltimes.typepad.com/blt/2013/09/scalia-chides-activist-colleagues-on-eve-of-constitution-day.html http://legaltimes.typepad.com/blt/2013/09/scalia-chides-acti... ("As he often does when extolling the text of the Constitution, Scalia criticized his colleagues for their 'activism' in creating new human rights not articulated by the framers. He made much of the fact that the right to privacy can nowhere be found in the document, yet the Supreme Court has discovered and cultivated it over the decades."). As Scalia noted in Jones, historically the 4th amendment was rooted in a "property rights" view, not a "privacy" view. It's easy to see the 4th amendment's protection of "persons, houses, papers, and effects" as simply expressing that the government may not commit trespass against real property or chattels without a warrant. Of course, a lot of people also think Olmstead (which approved phone wiretaps before it was overturned by Katz) was rightly decided: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olmstead_v._United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olmstead_v._United_States. I personally think the entirety of the Supreme Court's privacy jurisprudence is hand-waving, from Katz to Griswold to Roe to Lawrence. There's just no privacy in the Constitution, nor is there anything in the historical record to indicate that the framers had a well-developed concept of privacy as distinct from property rights.
- barrkel 13y agoWhen information had to be exchanged from enclave to walled enclave via physical tokens, privacy rights were a subset of property rights. There is a real question about interpretation of historical documents in the light of today. Do you interpret them based on their effects at the time they were written, or their literal meaning by modern definitions? I don't like the question at all, because it presumes a sacredness that should not be applied to mere documents written by people. But there are different problems with making a constitution a more mutable document subject to political fashions. Could there be a trailing update mechanism, whereby e.g. amendments are proposed, voted upon, then voted upon again 10 years later, and so on, and only applied if 3 or 5 votes succeed? That would be more legitimate than supreme court rulings, and remove the sacredness that warps people's thinking.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not a matter of sacredness, but rather "problems with making a constitution a more mutable document subject to political fashions." People argue endlessly about Constitutionality not because they view the document as sacred, but because just about the only thing our society agrees on is that the Constitution is one of the few legitimate restrictions on majoritarian democracy. As a result, we fight about exactly what those restrictions are.
- snowwrestler 13y agoI just think Scalia has it backward. He looks at the language of the Bill of Rights and says "where's the right to privacy?" I look at Article 1 Section 8 and say "where's the power to invade my privacy?"
- rayiner 13y agoWhich is where the specific mechanisms the NSA uses become relevant. The Constitution did not, and was not intended to, abrogate most of the common law powers of the courts. Judges can subpoena pretty much anything, and that's a historical practice that dates back to long before the Constitution. If they subpoena, from a third party, information that happens to let them track who you're calling, that's legit from an "enumerated powers" point of view. Also, defensive spying is older than the Constitution and the Constitution gives Congress the power to provide for the collective defense. Though I think your line of argument is a better one than conjuring a "right to privacy" out of thin air.