4 ms·

Rockstar scores a 1, 2 with GTAIV & GTAV in all time highest review scores

16 points by restlessmedia 13y ago

The hype machine was well oiled this time, but with most things Rockstar, it looks like it was justified. [edit] This is the chart, I couldn't change the first one http://www.metacritic.com/browse/games/score/metascore/all/ps3?view=condensed&sort=desc

tremorchr 13y ago
I wonder what will be the rating after more than a week.
- jaredmcateer 13y ago
  Based on the reviews I saw yesterday only the Escapist was willing to even criticize the game and give it less than a 90% (they gave it 70%). Everyone else seems to have toed the line on this one.
  - cbg0 13y ago
    I saw one that criticized quite a few aspects but still gave it a 9.5, which is almost perfect.
    - Argorak 13y ago
      Which, depending on how much you appreciate the scope of an endeavour, can be valid. Some of the most appreciated games of generations are deeply flawed. An example is Deus Ex, which is a very mediocre shooter, but was enjoyed by many.
      - objclxt 13y ago
        > Some of the most appreciated games of generations are deeply flawed. An example is Deus Ex, which is a very mediocre shooter Deus Ex, deeply flawed? I think a lot of people would disagree with you. I suppose you could come to that view if you considered it to be a shooter, but it's really RPG first, FPS second. You can complete the entire game without firing once. I don't think Warren Spector set out to create a FPS, so I wouldn't judge the game on that basis. If anything, I think Deus Ex has got more appreciated from a critical perspective as time has gone on.
        Argorak 13y ago
        Even as an RPG it was much worse than many competitors at that time. It is (basically) linear, your choices don't influence the ultimate ending (you get a final pick), which, at that time, some pure RPGs already provided. But you basically reiterate my point: Deus Ex did enough great things to cover the bad things. So it's perfectly fine to give it > 90%, while you can still find strong critique in almost any part of it, without even nitpicking.
  - minimaxir 13y ago
    Gamespot gave the game a 9/10 instead of a 10/10, causing a rather large amount of controversy. Not the first time that's happened to Gamespot, of course. (see the 8.8 Twilight Princess incident)
  - canthonytucci 13y ago
    Link to Escapist Article - http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/editorials/reviews/10598-Grand-Theft-Auto-5-Review-People-Suck http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/editorials/rev... ------ (OT) Today I learned that I've been doing this wrong. I always assumed "Tow the line" as in help to keep things moving in the same direction or slavishly and mindlessly do as ordered (or something). I guess I never saw (or noticed) it written down before....thanks! ----- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line http://grammartips.homestead.com/toetheline.html http://grammartips.homestead.com/toetheline.html
- dfan 13y ago
  Yeah, Metacritic scores tend to decline over time. Based on my experiences I'm going to guess it'll stabilize at 94.
nilkn 13y ago
It just came out, so there is considerable room for this to go down. Not saying it will, but if there's anything I learned from following game reviews in the past, it's that they frequently change drastically after the first week.
Zoepfli 13y ago
If anybody is wondering which GTA5 to get - PS3 or Xbox, Digital Foundary has got you covered: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-grand-theft-auto-5-face-off http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-grand-theft... According to them the versions are nearly identical, with a very tiny advantage to the PS3 version. In this light, it's interesting that the PS3 version got 97% while the Xbox360 version got 98%: http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/grand-theft-auto-v http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/grand-theft-aut... http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/grand-theft-auto-v http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/grand-theft-auto-v
- bradleyland 13y ago
  There are 26 and 37 opinion samples for the PS3 and XBox respectively. Given the small sample size and the subjectiveness of the evaluation, I would imagine that the margin of error is much higher than 1 point.
darkstar999 13y ago
How many game reviews are bought and paid for by the industry? (not saying this game doesn't deserve it, but it makes me wonder)

16 points by restlessmedia 13y ago

tremorchr 13y ago

I wonder what will be the rating after more than a week.

jaredmcateer 13y ago
Based on the reviews I saw yesterday only the Escapist was willing to even criticize the game and give it less than a 90% (they gave it 70%). Everyone else seems to have toed the line on this one.
- cbg0 13y ago
  I saw one that criticized quite a few aspects but still gave it a 9.5, which is almost perfect.
  - Argorak 13y ago
    Which, depending on how much you appreciate the scope of an endeavour, can be valid. Some of the most appreciated games of generations are deeply flawed. An example is Deus Ex, which is a very mediocre shooter, but was enjoyed by many.
    - objclxt 13y ago
      > Some of the most appreciated games of generations are deeply flawed. An example is Deus Ex, which is a very mediocre shooter Deus Ex, deeply flawed? I think a lot of people would disagree with you. I suppose you could come to that view if you considered it to be a shooter, but it's really RPG first, FPS second. You can complete the entire game without firing once. I don't think Warren Spector set out to create a FPS, so I wouldn't judge the game on that basis. If anything, I think Deus Ex has got more appreciated from a critical perspective as time has gone on.
      - Argorak 13y ago
        Even as an RPG it was much worse than many competitors at that time. It is (basically) linear, your choices don't influence the ultimate ending (you get a final pick), which, at that time, some pure RPGs already provided. But you basically reiterate my point: Deus Ex did enough great things to cover the bad things. So it's perfectly fine to give it > 90%, while you can still find strong critique in almost any part of it, without even nitpicking.
- minimaxir 13y ago
  Gamespot gave the game a 9/10 instead of a 10/10, causing a rather large amount of controversy. Not the first time that's happened to Gamespot, of course. (see the 8.8 Twilight Princess incident)
- canthonytucci 13y ago
  Link to Escapist Article - http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/editorials/reviews/10598-Grand-Theft-Auto-5-Review-People-Suck http://www.escapistmagazine.com/articles/view/editorials/rev... ------ (OT) Today I learned that I've been doing this wrong. I always assumed "Tow the line" as in help to keep things moving in the same direction or slavishly and mindlessly do as ordered (or something). I guess I never saw (or noticed) it written down before....thanks! ----- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line http://grammartips.homestead.com/toetheline.html http://grammartips.homestead.com/toetheline.html
dfan 13y ago
Yeah, Metacritic scores tend to decline over time. Based on my experiences I'm going to guess it'll stabilize at 94.

nilkn 13y ago

It just came out, so there is considerable room for this to go down. Not saying it will, but if there's anything I learned from following game reviews in the past, it's that they frequently change drastically after the first week.

Zoepfli 13y ago

If anybody is wondering which GTA5 to get - PS3 or Xbox, Digital Foundary has got you covered: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-grand-theft-auto-5-face-off http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-grand-theft... According to them the versions are nearly identical, with a very tiny advantage to the PS3 version. In this light, it's interesting that the PS3 version got 97% while the Xbox360 version got 98%: http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/grand-theft-auto-v http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/grand-theft-aut... http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/grand-theft-auto-v http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-360/grand-theft-auto-v

bradleyland 13y ago
There are 26 and 37 opinion samples for the PS3 and XBox respectively. Given the small sample size and the subjectiveness of the evaluation, I would imagine that the margin of error is much higher than 1 point.

darkstar999 13y ago

How many game reviews are bought and paid for by the industry? (not saying this game doesn't deserve it, but it makes me wonder)