3 ms·
> A little guy with a legitimate patent may have difficulty convincing large corporations to pay a license fee. I think the key distinction is that "legitimate
by AndrewKemendo 13y ago
> A little guy with a legitimate patent may have difficulty convincing large corporations to pay a license fee.
I think the key distinction is that "legitimate patent" would seem to have a different definition for the USPTO than it does for the technology industry.
For example USPTO considers sending a scan to an e-mail a legitimate patent, while I would venture to guess the tech world does not: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/04/meet-the-nice-guy-lawyers-who-want-1000-per-worker-for-using-scanners/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/04/meet-the-nice-guy...
So yes, some of these are so broad and obviously just there to make a buck - like the swipe option.
The idea of a patent was to ensure that the creator who had spent considerable time, energy and money creating the invention was ensured that for some period he could benefit from that. Being the first person to patent something which is simple and often thought up does not in my opinion meet that threshold.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoThere needs to be a cheaper way to challenge patents and force the USPTO to do a thorough job of it. If the obvious option is always, "nope, challenge", and the usual outcome is, "hm on second thought it doesn't take a rocket scientist to come up with scan-to-email"; patent trolls would find some copyrights to troll or move into a related field like blackmail.
- kamaal 13y agoI don't get this. Its simple, why can't we just tell HP or Canon we would get sued if we used their printers. So we won't. HP or Canon has much to lose here. And its very obvious a big part of business is under a threat because of these stupid games. They would definitely take on the troll themselves.
- TrevorJ 13y agoYep - it's this gap between common sense and actual patents that the patent Trolls are exploiting. The only true way to fix it is to reform the patent system itself.