3 ms·
Ayn Rand is the most overrated "philosopher" although I wouldn't even call her a philosopher. That actually requires at least some careful thinking. If that bo
by ThomPete 17y ago
Ayn Rand is the most overrated "philosopher" although I wouldn't even call her a philosopher. That actually requires at least some careful thinking.
If that book is on the rise, then rationality is for sure on descend.
Sad
- Retric 17y agoJust flag it. Articles like this have no place on HN. PS: A linkbait title. Suggesting Income Tax numbers are meaningful without including SS, or Medicare numbers is effectively a lie. Which is why I feel this is pure political spin and is not worth discussing.
- erlanger 17y agoI strongly take issue with this approach. Politics are one thing, but as a site somewhat devoted to startups, an article on the economy, vapid or precise, certainly has a place. If people didn't want to read it, they would not vote for it.
- jcl 17y agoHow about this, then: The article defies logic. There are a couple reasonable connections given between Rand and the modern world (e.g. the note about the doctors), but the rest of the connections are so tenuous or ill-framed, she might as well be explaining the economic genius of The House at Pooh Corner. Merely listing a character name followed by a real-life name doesn't cut it. By 2000, that 1 percent was paying 37 percent, and "Atlas Shrugged" sales were at 120,000. By 2006, the top 1 percent carried 40 percent of the burden. Obviously, increased sales of "Atlas Shrugged" leads to legislation increasing taxes on the rich, because Randian lobbyists are at home, reading. Or -- just guessing, here -- this correlation is meaningless and should be omitted? This one takes the cake: Of all American governors, Arnold Schwarzenegger of California is the one who most resembles Rand’s outsized characters. [...] Yet Schwarzenegger seems to be missing the Rand gene. His policies are all pain and no growth. Either he resembles something in the book or he doesn't. Why claim both?
- erlanger 17y agoLike I said: Don't vote it up then. Deleting it accomplishes nothing.
- davidw 17y agoWhat it accomplishes is making a clear statement that this sort of material does not belong on this site, and people who are only interested in politics, economics, and similar topics (rather than hacking/startups) would do well to find another place to chat about them.
- Retric 17y agoJust talking about the economy also has almost no place on HN. As a bassic rule of thumb if you see the same thing on CNN or FOX then it has no place here. The goal is to avoid becoming Redit / Dig / Slashdot and the fastist way to let that happen is to constantly talk about Politics or the Economy. They might be News, but they don't really have a significant impact on startups. Most small company's don't care about the larger economy at all. It's just not important when all you need to do is find 100,000+ of revenue each month to thrive. Exeptions would be a law that is going into effect that chaning the rules for becoming startups or some such. PS: Ok, talking about what exit number you need to retire based on X income tax would be a good and usefull article, linkbait that's talking about politics belongs somewhere else.
- zimbabwe 17y agoCan we lay off on the obnoxious Rand criticism? She's like anybody: Half her ideas are really good and worth discussing, half of them are crap. Rand was a lot more obnoxious than a lot of philosophers, but that doesn't immediately invalidate her ideas, and the fact remains that shrill as her voice may sound in the philosophical world, she made her ideas easier to understand than most philosophers do. Look at Nietzsche. Absolutely pretentious, wrote his philosophy in semifictional narratives, made up ridiculous fantasies like eternal recurrence. But people don't dis Nietzsche like they do Rand, not even when his readers are more obnoxious and pretentious than even the most obnoxious of Objectivists, because Nietzsche at least hit the vein of being difficult and therefore respectable. Give Rand credit for at least one thing: Her ideas are given to you so simplistically that it's very easy to build a counterargument against them. Would that most philosophers would do the same favor. That said, this article shouldn't be here, and Objectivism debates are old and tired. tl;dr Blasting Rand without balance is just as bad as worshipping her without balance, so if you're going to disagree with her be less of a jerk about it.
- ThomPete 17y agoHer ideas is not the problem, her reason for them is.
- zimbabwe 17y agoPlease elaborate. If you want to have a discussion on this I'd love to, because I'm sure we can get into a lot of interesting topics from here. But you need to explain yourself a bit more, or else this is going nowhere.
- Radix 17y agoAlso, if that is really true then you must be able to build up her ideas from a different basis; I presume with less flaws. Otherwise it is her ideas. (I'm in general agreement with Zimbabwe)