3 ms·
> If I flip a coin in a deterministic universe, it's still "random" (air flow, force exerted, etc), but if I "rewind time" and play it back, I'd get the same re
by aaron695 13y ago
> If I flip a coin in a deterministic universe, it's still "random" (air flow, force exerted, etc), but if I "rewind time" and play it back, I'd get the same result.
Couldn't quantum mechanics mean this is not true?
- kaoD 13y agoWhat do you mean? I view "rewind and play back" essentially as replaying the exact way the quantum states collapsed. Although quantum mechanics are probabilistic (whether you believe in multiverses, Copenhaguen, etc.), the key here is that you're replaying the same probabilistic results and not "throwing the dies" again. Or maybe I misunderstood your point? I'd also argue that this is Mario Party using a PRNG. QM do not apply!
- aaron695 13y agoMy understanding would be quantum mechanics would not play the same if you went back in time. It is truly random. But since time travel is impossible then maybe it makes no sense in general to talk about. Plus as pointed out the OP does say it was a deterministic universe (but I would have thought that is not what we are in due to QM)
- plorkyeran 13y agoEven if it turns out we live in a non-deterministic universe due to QM, that obviously does not apply to a deterministic universe.
- gonnakillme 13y agoI don't think there are very many quantum effects working on coin tosses. It seems (to my relatively inexperienced eyes) like something handled pretty adequately by classical mechanics.